Talk:Q18177306

Autodescription — Andrea (Q18177306)

description: male given name

Useful links:

Pretty display of data  (with Wikidata:Reasonator)
Pretty display of data (with Wikidata:Sqid)
View it! – Images depicting the item on Commons
Scholia
Report on constraint conformation of “Andrea” claims and statements. Constraints report for items data
Number of statements about Andrea by property (query)
All claims about Andrea (query)
List of items with same label (query)
List of lexemes with sense Andrea (query)

See also

This documentation is generated using {{Item documentation}}.

Lua error in Module:Name_item at line 145: attempt to index global 'data5' (a nil value).
Count uses by given name (P735)	Basic count Chart by item creation date Compound names
People with given name “Andrea”	List of 25 random people List of items with most sitelinks List of items with most statements (non-identifiers, some filtered) Most frequent family names Most frequent 1st given name of people with “Andrea” as 2nd given name (uses qualifier series ordinal (P1545)) Bubblechart of country of citizenship (P27) sex or gender (P21) Gallery (uses Wikidata Skim (Q85083863)) Counts by decade of birth (uses date of birth (P569)) Map of places of birth (slow, uses place of birth (P19)))
Compare	Rank within all given names (P735) if above #1000 Rank within related given names (uses said to be the same as (P460)) Rank within similar names (uses Soundex (P3878)=A536) Given name and family name swapped (uses family name identical to this given name (P1533)=Andrea) Same family name, but given name for other gender (uses given name version for other gender (P1560): Andrea)
Check this item	Constraint report Compare with 100 items of the same type Compare with “model” item(s) (uses Q202444#P5869) Compare with "properties for this type"-statements (uses Q202444#P1963)
Expand	Search for candidates for P735 statements Search for items lacking “family name” (P734) “Andrea” with fewest statements Search on Commons for pronunciation audio files
See also: WikiProject Names/Properties, general maintenance reports, create missing name, suggest other queries

Property:P1533

@Jura1: I think that this property should be removed from items like this one, because the provided information is already available through its superclass. Navigate to it this way: Andrea (Q18177306) → subclass of (P279) → family name identical to this given name (P1533). Doing so will allow us to make family name identical to this given name (P1533) a bijection. Petr Matas 08:15, 18 November 2014 (UTC)[reply]

P1533 is a fairly simple property: it just lists an item that happens to have the same label, an item that would otherwise be harder to find.

Even if it was listed elsewhere, the statement still remains true for this item.

I'm not aware of a rule that prevents us from having statements here.

Besides, I don't quite see how one would systematically look for such statements on superclasses. --- Jura 10:11, 18 November 2014 (UTC)[reply]

I have brought the discussion to Property talk:P1533#Constraint:Unique value disputed. Petr Matas 11:30, 18 November 2014 (UTC)[reply]

Talk:Q18177306

Autodescription — Andrea (Q18177306)

Property:P1533

Navigation menu

Search