One Wrong Choice - PrimaryQ - Wattpad

One Wrong Choice

Reads 2,513
Votes 146
Parts 28
Time 3h 53m

Reads 2,513
Votes 146
Parts 28
Time 3h 53m

Mature

1 new part

arthurmorgan dead fanfiction mature rdr2 red reddeadredemption2 redemption rockstargames romance xreader

This is a Red Dead Redemption 2 Fan-fic. 
Arthur Morgan x Female Y/n (Reader)

   Life is pretty simple as a rich woman. No, let me try that again, life is pretty simple as woman married to a rich man. Stay silent unless spoken too, dress with only the latest fashion, don't do anything unlady-like, and remain faithful to your husband no matter what.
   
   Heaven forbid a happily married, high society woman of any respectability be found going against any of these rules. Good thing then, you are not a happily married woman; and when a group of outlaws makes a sudden appearance in your dreary city of Saint Denis, you happily break every single rule in the book.


This story will not follow strictly along the lines of Red Dead Redemption 2 but I will do my best to do every character the justice they deserve. However I'm a suckered for happy endings so I will be adding my own spin on it.

DISCLAIMER: I do not own rdr2 or any of its characters.
This is a non-profit fan made story.All Rights Reserved

arthurmorgan dead fanfiction mature rdr2 red reddeadredemption2 redemption rockstargames romance xreader

Table of contents

28 parts

Sign up to add One Wrong Choice to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Unplanned - A RDR2 Fanfic (OCxArthur) by ponyboygrimes

[[A slow burn OCxArthur story with both new and original characters]] They say the best things in life are unplanned. But sometimes... they're the worst. After the Blackwater catastrophe, Arthur feels the heavy weight of responsibility; being one of the gang members looked up to and relied upon to get them out of this mess, he's strained by the notion that they may not be getting out this time. With the West slowly transformed into a civilized hellhole, they are forced to move in all directions despite the place they wanted to return to most. Grimly aware that the age of outlaws may be up, Arthur does what he can under Dutch to get money for their escape, all according to plan... Until a detour. Stuck in a rut of her own, the independent, God-fearing, and wistful Summer Grace Monroe has been searching for her own place in life. After being scorned by lovers and in and out of jobs, she feels amiss her late twenties without a true home. She finds the most peace in her church and helping those in need, especially the local Native population. Her father, Captain Monroe, works within the Army as a voice for those being silenced. She helps others find their story, but what would be her own? Things all seem to take a turn when fate brings a chance encounter, permanently altering whatever path her life was going to take and intertwining her destiny with that of a notorious group of outlaws - yet she would not be the only one whose path would be changed. **This story will contain mature content such as violence/gore, sexual themes, and language. Do not read if you are under 18** [These characters all belong within the Red Dead Redemption universe/Rockstar, but I have made a few original characters and altered storylines.]

The Night Shift: A Red Dead Redemption 2 AU by goodbyelisahoney

[ Arthur Morgan x OC ] Mia North needed a job. Kicked out of the apartment she shared with her (now ex) boyfriend with nothing but the clothes on her back, she'd found a new one for half the size and twice the rent. When she applies for a nighttime server job at Outlaw, a storied restaurant helmed by locally-famed chef Arthur Morgan with reservations booked through the year, it feels like her luck is about to change. She has no room in her frustrating life circumstances for the brooding, unwelcoming man...that is, until she tastes his food. And then all she wants is more. *** This is a modern / restaurant AU romance with the beloved VDL gang. This story was completed on November 11, 2023. Mature content within, 18 readers only. All RDR2 characters (c) Rockstar Games.

Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) by goodbyelisahoney

Arthur Morgan x OC: "Take a boozy short leave of your nymphs on the shore, and silence their mourning with vows of returning, though never intending to visit them more." After a near-deadly shootout in Valentine, Arthur Morgan retreats to a wooded cabin to lick his wounds and recover. But the reclusive woman he meets there causes him to question everything he believes in, and all of the people he holds dear. Does she have secrets of her own that she's hiding? ** Hi all; this is a little RDR2 romance (Arthur x original character) story. It follows the events of the game for the most part (meaning there are some spoilers, if you haven't finished the game yet!), but there are some changes/additions. Of course, all RDR2 characters/settings are Rockstar Games. Hope you all enjoy and would love to hear your thoughts. This story was completed September 18, 2021. A content warning: depictions of sex, violence, swearing, and other mature themes.

Bad Men {Arthur Morgan x Reader} by Bellynta

Arthur Morgan is aware that he's a bad man in a group with just as bad men. But as the years go on, he starts to think whether or not he's fighting for the right causes. Then he runs into a woman whom he hasn't seen in years since they were both young and ran together before splitting. What happens when fate brings two childhood friends back together? {I DO NOT own any of the RDR2 characters! Sorry if the summary is confusing!}

1899 Arthur Morgan X OC by homely-jess

Arthur Morgan x OC COMPLETED 9/8/2024 If you're looking for an Arthur fic about love, heartache, and adventure, you've come to the right place. 1899 is both ruthless and beautiful just like the year itself. 🥇#1 in reddeadredemption on 7/2/24 🥇#1 in redeadredemption2 on 7/7/24 🥇#1 in Arthur Morgan on 7/8/24 ***** Elizabeth 'Beth' Lawrence is stuck living in the life her parents have made for her. From the moment she was born in the bustling town of Saint Denis she was told who she was going to be, what to do, how to act and eventually who she would marry. One evening of her fathers extravagant garden parties her whole world is flipped. Follow her story as she willingly goes from riches to rags. Innocent debutante to wanted gang member. And somewhere in that mix, she captures the heart of cowboy, Arthur Morgan. **** 18 ONLY. This work contains MATURE CONTENT: sexual themes, violence, blood, and strong language. Chapters will NOT be marked with trigger warnings. THIS IS YOUR ONLY WARNING. This work also contains AI generated images from prompts I made using Instagram's Imagine, to serve as reference photos only.

The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story by goodbyelisahoney

[ Arthur Morgan / John Marston x OC love triangle ] "Let me be sweet to you," she murmured, nuzzling into his neck. "I'm always giving you such a time, aren't I?" * Tine Nilsen, known outside of the law as the Butcher of Rio Bravo, is a fearsome member of the Van der Linde gang when they run afoul of the Pinkerton detective agency in Blackwater. But will she help steer the gang and its two key gunslingers - Arthur Morgan and John Marston - right? Or will she be responsible for its downfall? * Well, here I go again, folks! Tine Nilsen was an OC cooked up for an otherworldly short story in my RDR2 collection, BELLICOSE (that story is called "Left Behind"). I liked her and her dynamic with Arthur and John so much, I thought I'd give this a spin! It will follow events of the game for the most part, but with the omission of a certain character, expect things to change, some. This story was completed on February 23, 2023. Hopefully you'll like it! This is a mature story written for mature, 18 audiences: violence, swears, smut will all be within, reader beware. RDR2 and related characters/settings belong to Rockstar Games.

Saving Arthur Morgan | rdr2 by thatredheadxo

Isabella Monroe is a college student who is struggling to make ends meet. She works constantly and college is giving her a real kick in the pants.. Her roommate Lindsay is the complete opposite. While they both are attending college, Lindsay's parents send her money every week unlike her counterpart. She doesn't quite understand Isabella's struggle. One night, a very hard day in particular for Isabella, Lindsay tells her to relax and play her new game which so happened to be Red Dead Redemption 2. Isabella refuses because she's not a gamer and she's absolutely exhausted which Lindsay never understands..but she instead agrees to watch her and chills with a beer in hand.. but hours go by and Lindsay somehow convinces her to play. She instantly gets hooked to the story and the character Arthur Morgan. It's like a book but the details and the visuals quench her every need in ways that a book couldn't. That night she decides to look for clues and secrets online..but her phone acts weird. She accidentally opened a "dark browser" that hacks her PS4 and phone. She waves it off as if it is nothing and goes to bed...but when she wakes up, her whole life has changed.. to her disbelief she wakes up in the cool hills of the Cumberland Forest. A mysterious voice from above offers her a deal, if she saves Arthur, she can come home. The kicker is.. she only has five chances to save him or...game over.

Riches to Revolvers | rdr2 | Wattys2019 by thatredheadxo

COMPLETED. The Van Der Linde gang kidnaps the innocent Sarah McDonnell during a train robbery. Her mother sent her off that same day to get away from settling and missed opportunities. She was only 20 and didn't know a single thing about the real world. She's shoved into Arthur Morgan's hands all because of Dutch Van Der Linde's games of revenge. She's helpless and falls in love with the brooding Mr Morgan. But he doesn't know what to do with a pretty, innocent rich girl who knows nothing of rough living. RDR2 fanfiction. I would've love for Arthur to fall in love but who says I can't make him in my own story? CONTAINS SPOILERS!!! Read at your own risk! I DO NOT OWN RDR2. This is purely for fun. My OCs are Amelia and Sarah. The rest are Rockstar affiliated characters. I have to state this for obvious reasons.

Arthur Morgan x Reader by imagineyourcreator

[Completed] The beginning of the story takes place when they settled in Colter. When everyone was together before they moved to horseshoe overlook. Traveling the wild west can be a hell of a journey! It even gets crazier when you meet a man named Arthur Morgan, your life is going great but as you get into more and more trouble. Things go south really fast. This is my third fan fiction and I played this game like no tomorrow. I absolutely fell in love with Arthur and his big heart. I told myself I had to do a story on this game. Hope you enjoy. I do not own any of these characters. Thank y'all so much for nine thousand reads! 😭 #5 RDR2 #11 Arthur Morgan #52 RDR2 #15 John Marston #1 Arthur Morgan

Mud and Gold [Arthur Morgan] [RDR2] by catharsxs

➵ ❝Y'know... I ain't a good man.❞ ❝You're good to me, and that's enough.❞ ➵ Arthur Morgan had heard many tales about grand treasures hidden all over the Heartlands, yet he wasn't one to believe in mere rumors as such, most claimed by drunken lowlifes spending their miserable lives in rundown saloons. Until the day the Van der Linde gang saves a farm girl from Colm O'Driscoll's boys, and something more; with a legitimate treasure map in the girl's possession, the chance to earn a great amount of gold arises, and is far too tempting for Dutch van der Linde to turn down. Arthur takes it upon himself to find this secret stash of gold - and it's during this treasure hunt where the outlaw finds out more than he'd bargained for; the gold is not the only secret that has remained hidden for far too long. ➵ Arthur Morgan x Fem!reader ➵ Warning: this story contains foul language, violence, gore and death. ➵ Credits: RDR2/Arthur Morgan belongs to Rockstar Games, I only own my writing. ➵ Cover edited by @catharsxs ➵ IF YOU HAVE NOT FINISHED RDR2, BE AWARE OF POTENTIAL SPOILERS IN THIS STORY !!

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Unplanned - A RDR2 Fanfic (OCxArthur) cover

The Night Shift: A Red Dead Redemption 2 AU cover

Vows of Returning: A Red Dead Redemption 2 Story ( Arthur Morgan xOC ) cover

Bad Men {Arthur Morgan x Reader} cover

1899 Arthur Morgan X OC cover

The Angel Butcher of Rio Bravo: An RDR2 Story cover

Saving Arthur Morgan | rdr2 cover

Riches to Revolvers | rdr2 | Wattys2019 cover

Arthur Morgan x Reader cover

Mud and Gold [Arthur Morgan] [RDR2] cover

Unplanned - A RDR2 Fanfic (OCxArthur)

[[A slow burn OCxArthur story with both new and original characters]] They say the best things in life are unplanned. But sometimes... they're the worst. After the Blackwater catastrophe, Arthur feels the heavy weight of responsibility; being one of the gang members looked up to and relied upon to get them out of this mess, he's strained by the notion that they may not be getting out this time. With the West slowly transformed into a civilized hellhole, they are forced to move in all directions despite the place they wanted to return to most. Grimly aware that the age of outlaws may be up, Arthur does what he can under Dutch to get money for their escape, all according to plan... Until a detour. Stuck in a rut of her own, the independent, God-fearing, and wistful Summer Grace Monroe has been searching for her own place in life. After being scorned by lovers and in and out of jobs, she feels amiss her late twenties without a true home. She finds the most peace in her church and helping those in need, especially the local Native population. Her father, Captain Monroe, works within the Army as a voice for those being silenced. She helps others find their story, but what would be her own? Things all seem to take a turn when fate brings a chance encounter, permanently altering whatever path her life was going to take and intertwining her destiny with that of a notorious group of outlaws - yet she would not be the only one whose path would be changed. This story will contain mature content such as violence/gore, sexual themes, and language. Do not read if you are under 18 [These characters all belong within the Red Dead Redemption universe/Rockstar, but I have made a few original characters and altered storylines.]