When he first noticed his feelings

                                    

                                          
Corbyn
                          
Corbyn first noticed his feelings for you when you were at a school dance and you were laughing at something he just said. He realized how much he liked you.
                          
Daniel
                          
Daniel first noticed his feelings for you when you two were out at dinner and you two accidentally touched hands reaching for the same piece of pizza. 
                          
Jack
                          
Jack first noticed his feelings for you when you two went to the mall and he pretended to be your boyfriend to get someone to go away, so he decided to hold your hand and kiss your forehead as the guy walked off.
                          
Jonah
                          
Jonah first noticed his feelings for you when he had taken you on a roller coaster and you cuddled into him because you were scared of heights. You stayed cuddled up the entire ride and he had his arms around you. 
                          
Zach
                          
Zach first noticed his feelings for you when you fell out of a tree one day and instead of crying just laughed. You ended up with a broken arm, but somehow that moment made him realized how much he loved you.