Lost Gem (Ticci Toby, Creepypasta) Part 2

                                    

                                          
You did it. You kidnapped Toby. Slenderman discovered that you kidnapped him and try to kill you.

                          
But you black-mailed him that you will kill Toby and hunt down the others to kill....and maybe eat them too.
                          
Slenderman hesitate at first. He cares so much for his 'children' and will not let them die. But...he can just sigh in defeat as he sees the unconscious Toby in your arm while your lips showed a sinister smirk as your (E/C) eyes glowed and a hint of red was seen.
                          
"I am grateful you made the good decision, Slendy!" You said as you laugh and enter your house. Ticci Toby was in your arm, he was waking up and look at you.
                          
"W-wha..." He looks on his side to see Slenderman standing behind them, his tendrils stretching out of his back, and was ready to stab you when you suddenly disappeared and appear behind the tall man.
                          
Toby hitch when he felt the cold blade of a knife on his neck, he looks on his side to see you glaring at Slenderman. He trembled when he saw the bloodlust in your now red eyes.
                          
"Are you testing me, Slender?" Your voice was demonic as you slide the knife on Toby's neck making a wide cut. Blood pours out of the wound, Slenderman frown and face both of you.
                          
"I am not." He then sighs and looks at Toby. "Farewell, Toby. I cannot do something about this." He said and vanish. Toby widens his eyes as he heard your laugh.
                          
"You're mine now!" You said while hugging him behind.
                          
≈≈≈CREEPYPASTA≈≈≈
                          
You sat on your bed that is dirty and unkempt inside a room full of cobwebs and red stains on your floor and wall, Toby was on your lap ticking and twitching nervously as you check every inch of his body. Caressing it in a loving way, sniffing the scent, kissing them.
                          
He can't help but be scared of you for what you did minutes ago. He can't believe Slenderman abandoned him with this psycho. He can't believe that they lost to this insane man and this said guy threatened his boss. He can't believe that he is feeling fear now. He can't believe that something like this is happening to him.
                          
"You're eyes..." Toby was tense when you whispered and look at you. His forest green eyes meet your (E/C) eyes.
                          
"I want them...but it should be yours..." You said as you place your finger below his eyes and lick your chapped lips. Toby trembled in fear as you intertwined his left hand with your right hand.
                          
"And this..." You whispered and kiss the back of his hand. "These beautiful hands..." You kiss his fingers in a loving way while your eyes are closed. "I also want them...but it should be yours..."
                          
You sigh and opened your eyes to look directly at Toby. You frown gently as you saw the unshed tears in his eyes.
                          
"Don't cry, my little killer." You said and wipe them. He sniffles and closes his eyes tightly.
                          
"You should smile." You said and drag your finger on his bottom lips. He just shut it tight while he let out a whimper.
                          
Your heartbeat fast than it should be. You keep on muttering under your breath and your eyes dilated while you hold his left arm in a tight grip making him hurt. You trembled while looking at him. Your eyes going red to (E/C) repeatedly.
                          
"Did I do something wrong to you? Am I that bad? What...what did I do?! ANSWER ME!" You grip his arm tightly. Toby twitches uncontrollably, he tried to calm his syndrome while clenching his left fist. He slaps you with trembling hands to snap you out of your breakdown.
                          
"STOP IT! You didn't do anything wrong to me...it's just that..." Toby turned his eyes away to you as you look at him with shock (E/C) eyes.
                          
"I..didn't do something wrong?" You said, sounding vulnerable all of the sudden. Toby nod his head and look at the much taller male in front of him. You removed your hands on his arm and rest it on his waist.
                          
You were silent but then you felt liquid dripping on your cheek. You were crying for some unknown reason.
                          
But why it is water? Not blood?
                          
Toby watch you in surprise, why did you suddenly cry?
                          
"It's not blood?" You asked in a surprised tone while touching them.
                          
"Why...Something is wrong, I knew it! SOMETHING IS WRONG!" You screamed and grip your hair as your tears continue to flow. Toby was getting terrified as he pushes himself away from you. Your breath is ragged and you let out a silent cry. You remove your hands on your hair and hug your knees while you buried your face on your knees.
                          
"Something...something is wrong...something is wrong with me..." You whispered words after words while racking back and forth. Toby wants to escape but found himself unable to do it because of what he is seeing right now. He felt like he should do something to make you stop doing this.
                          
"Hey? A-are you okay?" Toby asked. You stop crying and hugging your knees and look up at Toby.
                          
"Do I look like I'm okay to you?" You whispered while gazing at Toby's beautiful green eyes.
                          
"N-no..." Toby said. You stare at Toby, unable to look away at his eyes like a gem. You are fascinated by his eyes, the way it glistened unshed tears, the way the light reflects on those little pieces of a lost gem.
                          
"I really love your eyes." You said. Toby looks away and close his eyes as his heart speed up. His hands are getting all cold and clammy when you said those words again and again.
                          
Toby needs to escape now or he will lose his eyes and his life too.
                          
≈≈≈CREEPYPASTA≈≈≈
                          
Third Person POV
                          
The (H/C) hair male can't remove himself away from Toby. He is always with him, even when the brunette is in the bathroom.
                          
Toby doesn't know (Y/N) really well. He also won't know why something like that happened. Toby was afraid that (Y/N) will become like what he became when Slenderman confronted him while he turns his back to him. He fears for his family's safety but his guts told him they can defend themselves as they are strong.
                          
But he has this nagging feeling, that something might happen when he did something (Y/N) doesn't want.
                          
Toby is planning on escaping but he is having a second thoughts. All he can do is not be terrified of this cannibal. In the blink of an eye, the cannibal might snap at him and...eat him when he betrayed him.
                          
Three months had passed since (Y/N) got his little killer. (Y/N) treat him nicely, gave him some food(that is definitely not a human's meat), and rejoices when he discovered that Toby is also a cannibal.
                          
Every day, (Y/N) discovered new things about his precious killer, and every time he discovers it, the more (Y/N) fall in love, but every time Toby asked something about (Y/N), the (E/C) eyed male will only have the blank look while gazing away at Toby and resume talking after a minute or so. 
                          
Unknown to Toby, (Y/N) have fallen for him so hard it hurts, especially Toby's eyes, they are so pretty to stare at. Toby's eyes are a little dead but it keeps on having this certain glint that (Y/N) knew all too well, it is the same emotion his past lovers have when they left him alone while staring at him with eyes filled with that glint and (Y/N) cried of blood while laughing maniacally when the life in that dead eyes slowly fade. Even if the eyes have no life in them, their dead glass-like eyes keep on staring at him, seeming to accuse him of something he quite knew all too well too.
                          
He cried of water because of that too.
                          
He stopped on his thoughts and smile at Toby's confused and scared face. (Y/N) and Toby seems to have a peaceful time without reality destroying it with a click.
                          
But all things are short-lived.