Peter vs Brad (Peter Parker)

                                    

                                          

Requested by VOIDSTILES34: Y/N goes to Peter's school, and is in a love triangle with him and another guy. 

I stood at my locker, my hands shoving what I didn't need for first period into the metal box and filling it before class.
"Hey." My heart exploded into butterflies as he placed his hands on my waist, his chin also resting on my shoulder as he appeared behind me.
"Hey, Pete." I chuckled at my crush as I turned around in his arms.
"How's my favourite girl doing?" He smiled, making me playfully roll my eyes and shake my head as I rested my hands against his chest.
"You know that you shouldn't call me that." I teased.
"Why not? It's true." He continued flirting, making me chuckle and bite my lip as I looked into his gorgeous eyes.
"Hey, listen, I wondered if you wanted to come over after school and study for the Spanish test. And then, I don't know, watch a movie or something." He shrugged, his gaze flicking between my eyes and lips and his hands gently massaging my waist as he looked at me. My smile dipped and my eyes wavered slightly at his words.
"Fuck, um...I'd love to, Pete, I really would, but I actually already agreed to study with-."
"You want to get your hands off of my girl, Parker?" We both looked to the side, Peter's smile dipping as Brad walked towards us.
"She's not your girl, Brad." Peter nodded, making me gulp as I looked between them.
"Not yet, anyway. Isn't that right, babe?" Brad smiled, making Peter clench his jaw as Brad looked at me.
"Let's not jump to any conclusions yet, I still don't know." I chuckled awkwardly and shook my head, making Peter sigh and look at me. Peter and I had been best friends since he had moved in with his aunt and uncle just down the hallway from where I lived with my parents. We had clicked immediately, Peter never failing to make me laugh and feel loved whenever we hung out, which was a lot. Of course my feelings had always run deeper for the boy, my mind wanting a full relationship with him, not just best friendship. Though, he had never given me any hints to suggest that he felt the same up until about six months ago, and so I had never acted on it before that time. The problem was that, whilst six months ago marked when Peter started to imply that he liked me back...it also marked when Brad had transferred to our school. Brad was the complete opposite of Peter, the black-haired boy being an extremely confident and popular jock who just got on with everyone. Which was why I'd been so confused, and flattered, when he'd taken a liking to me. I had started to reciprocate those feelings, which was when things started to get complicated, because my feelings for Peter hadn't gone away, or even shrunk at all in response to me also developing a slight crush on Brad. And so I was currently in a love triangle, with my best friend and the school's popular boy both competing for a relationship with me. And I still had no idea who I wanted more, despite the fact that I had been in this position for the last few months. I. Was. Fucked.
"Are we still on for tonight, babe?" Brad asked as he got closer to us. I gulped and bit my lip as I looked up at Peter. He returned the look with his chocolate eyes filled with hope. Hope that I'd cancel on Brad and instead study with him, maybe. And that broke my fucking heart.
"Um...y-yeah, we're still on for tonight." I nodded as I looked back at him, Peter's eyes wavering and his arms slowly uncurling from my waist as I spoke. My heart hurt at the action, but at the end of the day, that was my fault. My own fault for hurting Peter by still not having made a decision.