Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
A few years had passed since you left the Van Der Linde gang well... left John and didn't look back. And honestly, your life turned out better for it. You had settled down with a rich man in Blackwater. That man gave you all that you could wish for. His love and a family.
Although, you did find yourself late at night thinking about John Marston. Of what could've been. "Will that be all miss?" The man asked kindly as he packed up your groceries in your wagon. You nodded.
"Y/N is that you?" John takes his hat off darting towards you.
"Hi, John." You smile warmly at him but then all the memories of your relationship come flooding back. Him almost cheating on you. All the arguments. Your expression that was once a smile soon turned into a stone-cold stare.
He looks down, his eyes trailing to your hand which had your wedding ring on. "You're married now?" He frowns at you.
You look at his hand to see a wedding band as well. "I'm not the only one who's married."
He rubs the back of his neck, "Yeah me and Abigail got married a few weeks back."
That one sentence burnt through you like a swallow of tequila. "So after all we went through you went back to her?!"
"You left me! It wasn't the other way around." He huffs.
"No. You left me the moment you left the tent that night. You have no idea how much seeing you trying to bed Karen hurt me."
He sighs, "Darlin' I was drunk and angry. I didn't know what I was doin'"
Suddenly John felt a sharp sting on his scarred cheek. You had slapped. Something he would have never expected you to do. You looked at him anger lacing your eyes, and before you could even process what he was about to do. His hands reached behind and grabbed your bottom firmly pushing you against the back of the General Store.
Your heart thumping wildly in your chest, you weren't sure what to say. All you could do was stare at the man before you. You wanted him so badly. Even if it meant being a cheater. His lips collided against yours and before you knew it your hands were tangled in his brown locks bringing him closer to you. Resulting in his erection pressing where you needed him most.
"I'm no cheater John." You huff out of breath resting your hands on his chest.
"Neither am I."
"Then what are we doing right now?"
Before you could register what was happening his member was already inside of you. Your arms wrapped around his neck holding on for dear life. "Fuck... I missed you." He mumbles as your soft moans turn into much louder ones. His thrusts get faster and harder as your claw at his back.
He was close you knew he was. That's when you forcefully pushed him away. He huffs still out of breath. "Runaway with me." He mumbles softly barely enough for you to hear.
"John, we're both married now, and as much as I would love to marry you and have a family our time has passed."
"It hasn't though! There's still time. Otherwise, I wouldn't have found you."
He had a point.
Choice A running away with John:
You dropped your wedding band on the ground. John faintly smiled at this. Dropping his with you, you both started a new life together. You had both divorced your previous beau as taboo it seemed it was worth it in the end.
You got the love of your life back. And now you really had everything you wanted.
Choice B leaving John:
"John, I can't."
"Why?" He frowns.
"You almost cheated on me and I've moved on. And now you've cheated on Abigail with me!"
"I wasn't ready before but I'm ready now. I wanna be married to ya."
You shake your head getting on the wagon. "Our time has passed John. It's time we both move on with our lives."
You went back home to your husband as if you had never met John Marston but you cherished that last moment with John forever.
A/N: how do we like the idea of choosing the ending? :) let me know your thoughts on this fic for John, I really enjoyed writing for John
