You’re trying to give feedback to a colleague. What are some common challenges you might face?
Feedback is an essential part of research management, as it helps you and your colleagues improve your skills, performance, and collaboration. However, giving feedback can also be challenging, especially when you want to be constructive, respectful, and supportive. In this article, you will learn about some common challenges you might face when you’re trying to give feedback to a colleague, and how to overcome them.
One of the first challenges you might face is deciding when and how often to give feedback. You don’t want to overwhelm your colleague with too much feedback at once, or delay it until it becomes irrelevant or outdated. You also want to balance positive and negative feedback, so that your colleague feels appreciated and motivated, but also aware of their areas for improvement. A good rule of thumb is to give feedback as soon as possible after observing a behavior or outcome, and to follow the “sandwich” method: start with a compliment, then address the issue, and end with another compliment.
-
🔸Finding the right time to give feedback can be challenging, especially in a busy laboratory environment where everyone has tight schedules. Additionally, the frequency of feedback can impact its effectiveness. For instance, giving feedback during a critical or busy testing period may not be well-received. Instead, schedule feedback sessions during quieter times or after completing a particular project to ensure better focus and receptivity.
Another challenge you might face is choosing the right tone and language for your feedback. You want to be clear, honest, and specific, but not harsh, vague, or judgmental. You also want to avoid using absolutes, such as “always” or “never”, or personal attacks, such as “you are lazy” or “you don’t care”. Instead, use “I” statements, such as “I noticed” or “I felt”, and focus on the behavior or outcome, not the person. For example, instead of saying “You missed the deadline again”, you could say “I was concerned when you didn’t submit the report on time”.
-
🔸The tone and language used in delivering feedback can significantly influence how it's received. In a technical field like medical laboratory science, it's essential to maintain a professional and constructive tone. Avoid using overly critical language or sarcasm, which can undermine the message and damage relationships. Instead, frame feedback in a positive and objective manner, focusing on specific behaviors and outcomes. For example, instead of saying, "You always make mistakes in sample labeling," try saying, "Let's review the sample labeling process together to ensure accuracy."
A third challenge you might face is dealing with your colleague’s receptivity and response to your feedback. You can’t control how your colleague will react, but you can influence it by creating a safe and trusting environment, and by inviting them to share their perspective and feedback as well. You also want to be prepared for different scenarios, such as your colleague being defensive, angry, or dismissive, or your colleague being grateful, curious, or open. In any case, you want to listen actively, empathize, and acknowledge their feelings, and then offer suggestions, solutions, or action steps to help them improve.
-
🔸Not everyone may be open to receiving feedback, especially if they perceive it as criticism or judgment. Understanding the individual's receptivity to feedback is crucial for delivering it effectively. Consider the person's personality, communication style, and past experiences with feedback. Create a supportive and non-threatening environment where they feel comfortable receiving constructive criticism. Encourage open dialogue and active listening to ensure their concerns and perspectives are also heard and addressed.
A fourth challenge you might face is taking into account the culture and context of your colleague and your organization. Different cultures and contexts may have different norms, expectations, and preferences for giving and receiving feedback. For example, some cultures may value direct and blunt feedback, while others may prefer indirect and subtle feedback. Some contexts may require formal and written feedback, while others may allow informal and verbal feedback. You want to be aware of these differences and adapt your feedback accordingly, while also respecting your own style and values.
-
🔸Cultural differences and organizational norms can influence how feedback is given and received. In a diverse medical laboratory environment, it's important to be mindful of cultural sensitivities and communication preferences. Adapt your feedback approach to align with the cultural background and communication style of the recipient. Consider factors such as hierarchy, power dynamics, and individual preferences when delivering feedback. For example, in some cultures, direct feedback may be perceived as confrontational, while in others, it may be expected as a sign of honesty and transparency.
A fifth challenge you might face is following up and evaluating the impact of your feedback. You don’t want to give feedback and then forget about it, or assume that your colleague will implement it without any support or guidance. You also want to measure the results of your feedback, and see if it led to any changes or improvements in your colleague’s behavior or outcome. You can do this by setting specific and realistic goals, checking in regularly, providing additional feedback or resources, and celebrating achievements.
-
🔸Providing feedback is not a one-time event; it requires follow-up and ongoing evaluation to ensure improvement and effectiveness. After giving feedback, establish clear expectations and timelines for implementing any suggested changes or improvements. Schedule follow-up meetings or check-ins to assess progress, address any lingering issues, and provide additional support or guidance as needed. Evaluate the impact of the feedback on individual performance and overall team dynamics to identify areas for further improvement.
A final challenge you might face is receiving feedback for yourself. You might think that giving feedback is easier than getting feedback, but both are equally important and difficult. You want to be open and receptive to feedback from your colleagues, as it can help you grow and learn as a research manager. You also want to apply the same principles and tips that you use for giving feedback, such as timing, tone, language, receptivity, response, culture, context, follow-up, and evaluation. By doing so, you will show your colleague that you value feedback as a two-way process, and that you are willing to improve yourself as well.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Social WorkYou're trying to help a colleague who's not receptive to feedback. How can you get through to them?
-
Interpersonal SkillsHere's how you can provide feedback to your colleagues without falling into potential pitfalls.
-
Business CommunicationsWhat are some best practices for giving feedback to a sensitive colleague?
-
RecruitingHere's how you can provide feedback to a senior colleague.