What do you do if your feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good?

When your design feedback feels destructive, take a step back. Assess if it's clear and specific. Vague comments leaves the designer lost. Instead, pinpoint why and offer suggestions. Open a dialogue. Discussing your concerns lets the designer explain their vision and brainstorm solutions together. Remember, the goal is a great final product, not micromanagement. Consider if your feedback aligns with the project's goals. Is it straying from the target audience or brand identity? Refocusing on these core elements can help ensure everyone's on the same page. By clarifying your feedback, fostering collaboration, and keeping goals in mind, you can turn potentially harmful critiques into positive steps towards a successful design.

According to me, if my feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good, I would first reassess my approach to giving feedback. I would consider whether my feedback is constructive, specific, and delivered in a respectful manner. I would also seek feedback from others to understand how my feedback is being received and make adjustments accordingly.

E fundamental Feedback mas temos que ser claro e as vezes saber ouvir, nem sempre somos os donos da Razão, o feedback quando bem direcionado só tem agregar valores.

Muitas das vezes a forma de como nós, nos expressamos tem que ser a mas clara , o feedback para ser bem claro muitas das vezes temos que ser direto, caso não esteja sendo bem compreendido devemos para e ouvir também.

A forma de como temos que agir muitas das vezes requer uma adaptação seja ela, por conta de uma pergunta que nos fazem por não entender nossa comunicação ou para melhor entendimento de todos.

Quando o feedback não está sendo muito Ben compreendido devemos nesse momento usar de outros meios para que possa vim ajudar.

Approach feedback like a gentle breeze, not a hurricane. Soften your blows, and you'll avoid extinguishing the creative flames. it's not about tearing down the tent; it's about raising the circus. Focus on constructive criticism and praise the acrobatics, even if they stumbled a bit. Positivity goes a long way in keeping the show running smoothly. Once, I critiqued a designer's work too harshly, and it felt like I sent a cannonball through their confidence. Instead of doubling down, I apologized and offered a helping hand. Together, we turned that stumble into a graceful leap. So, when giving feedback, be mindful of your words, offer support, and remember, we're all performers in this design circus.

It depends from whom the feedback is coming. If it's from a genuine client or someone I know. I do think about it and take it seriously. But when you open a dialogue or something on a social platform the whole game changes. I use those feedback wisely because feedback is a kind of suggestion and I only take back home the ones I can resonate with. Sometimes it's not important to take every feedback seriously.. trust me.