What are some common causes and effects of cost and schedule variances in EVM?
Cost control is a vital skill for any project manager, especially when using earned value management (EVM) to monitor and measure project performance. EVM compares the planned value (PV), earned value (EV), and actual cost (AC) of the project to calculate key metrics such as cost variance (CV), schedule variance (SV), cost performance index (CPI), and schedule performance index (SPI). These metrics help you identify and analyze any deviations from the baseline plan and take corrective actions if needed. But what are some common causes and effects of cost and schedule variances in EVM? And how can you use EVM formulas and examples to improve your cost control skills? In this article, we will explore these questions and provide some tips and best practices for using EVM effectively.
-
Oseghale Okohue BEngr. Msc. MBA. DBA. Prince2®PractitionerEngineering Project Manager | EPICM, Oil & Gas, Subsea Engineering, Renewable Energy (Solar, Wind, Hydrogen, Electrical…
-
Lucas CarrollConstruction Cost Analyst | Project Controller, Forecaster, Budgeter | I help you track cost and stay under budget on…
One of the most common causes of cost and schedule variances in EVM is poor planning. If you don't have a clear scope, realistic estimates, accurate assumptions, and well-defined deliverables, you are likely to face issues such as scope creep, rework, delays, and budget overruns. Poor planning can also affect your baseline plan, which is the reference point for EVM calculations. If your baseline plan is not aligned with the project objectives, stakeholders' expectations, and available resources, you will have inaccurate or misleading EVM metrics.
-
I've seen firsthand how bad planning can mess up projects - causing them to go over budget and miss deadlines. To stop this, it's important to clearly define what the project includes from the start and make sure everyone is on the same page. Regularly checking progress, involving key people in changes, and keeping good records helps. Choosing reliable vendors, setting realistic timelines, and having backups can prevent delays. Building strong relationships with vendors and conducting regular performance reviews can also mitigate risks. Careful planning is key to making a project successful and keeping costs under control.
-
Common causes of cost and schedule variances in Earned Value Management (EVM) include inaccurate estimations, scope changes, resource constraints, and unexpected disruptions like supplier delays. Effects include decreased profitability, project delays, resource wastage, and compromised stakeholder trust. These variances highlight risks and areas for improvement, demanding regular monitoring and mitigation strategies for project success.
The effect of poor planning on EVM metrics is low performance. If your EV is lower than your PV, it means that you are behind schedule and not delivering the expected value. If your AC is higher than your EV, it means that you are over budget and not using your resources efficiently. Both scenarios result in negative CV and SV, and lower than one CPI and SPI. These indicators show that your project is underperforming and at risk of not meeting the success criteria.
Another common cause of cost and schedule variances in EVM is external factors. These are factors that are beyond your control and influence, such as market changes, regulatory requirements, customer feedback, supplier issues, weather conditions, and unforeseen events. External factors can affect your project scope, schedule, cost, quality, and risk, and require you to adjust your plan accordingly. However, if you don't update your baseline plan to reflect these changes, your EVM metrics will not reflect the current reality of your project.
The effect of external factors on EVM metrics is inaccurate reporting. If your baseline plan is outdated or irrelevant, your EVM metrics will not provide a reliable picture of your project status and progress. For example, if your PV is based on a scope that has changed significantly due to external factors, your SV will not tell you how much work you have completed or how much work remains. Similarly, if your AC is based on a budget that has increased or decreased due to external factors, your CV will not tell you how much money you have spent or how much money you have left. Inaccurate reporting can lead to poor decision making, stakeholder dissatisfaction, and loss of trust and credibility.
A third common cause of cost and schedule variances in EVM is human factors. These are factors that relate to the people involved in the project, such as team members, managers, sponsors, customers, and vendors. Human factors can affect your project performance in various ways, such as communication, collaboration, motivation, skills, experience, availability, and productivity. Human factors can also introduce errors, biases, and inconsistencies in your EVM data collection, analysis, and reporting.
The effect of human factors on EVM metrics is miscommunication. If your EVM data is not accurate, consistent, or timely, you will not be able to communicate your project status and progress effectively to your stakeholders. For example, if your EV is based on subjective or incomplete measurements of work done, your SV will not reflect the true value of your project deliverables. Likewise, if your AC is based on inaccurate or delayed invoices or receipts, your CV will not reflect the true cost of your project resources. Miscommunication can result in confusion, conflict, and missed opportunities.
To avoid or minimize the causes and effects of cost and schedule variances in EVM, you need to use EVM formulas and examples correctly and consistently. EVM formulas help you calculate the key metrics that indicate your project performance, such as CV = EV - AC, SV = EV - PV, CPI = EV / AC, and SPI = EV / PV. EVM examples help you interpret and apply these metrics to your specific project context, such as CV > 0 means under budget, SV < 0 means behind schedule, CPI < 1 means low efficiency, and SPI > 1 means high productivity. By using EVM formulas and examples, you can identify and analyze the root causes of variances, evaluate the impact of variances on your project objectives, and implement corrective actions to improve your cost control skills.
-
Common causes of cost and schedule variances in EVM include scope changes, resource constraints, and inaccurate estimations. Effects encompass budget overruns, delays, and compromised project quality. In energy projects, such variances may arise from unexpected regulatory changes or supply chain disruptions, impacting project timelines and financial outcomes.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Corporate AccountingHow can you use earned value management (EVM) to identify potential cost overruns or schedule delays?
-
Software Project ManagementWhat are the most effective ways to analyze project cost variances with earned value management?
-
Earned Value ManagementHow do you handle schedule and cost variances in your work packages?
-
Cost PlanningWhat are the benefits and limitations of using earned value management (EVM) for cost control?