What are the main advantages and disadvantages of hot runner systems compared to cold runner systems?
Injection molding is a widely used technique for producing plastic parts with complex shapes and high quality. However, not all injection molding systems are the same. Depending on the design of the mold, there are two main types of runner systems: hot and cold. In this article, we will explain what are the main advantages and disadvantages of hot runner systems compared to cold runner systems, and how to choose the best option for your project.
-
Manoj ThakurPackaging Professional | PMP®| NPD | Procurement | Sustainability | Six Sigma Green Belt | 15 Years Exp |
-
Andres EstradaNetSuite Specialist | Leading Continuous Improvement Initiatives | WMS Implementation Expert
-
Allan Rodrigues∴ MSc. Eng. Mec. | Projeto de Peças Plásticas e Moldes de Injeção
Runner systems are the channels that connect the injection unit to the cavities in the mold. They are responsible for delivering the molten plastic to the right place and at the right temperature. Runner systems can be classified into two categories: hot and cold. Hot runner systems use heated components to keep the plastic in a molten state throughout the mold, while cold runner systems allow the plastic to cool and solidify in the runner channels.
-
Hot runner systems in injection molding function like streamlined highways, minimizing material waste and speeding up production. They result in smoother, higher-quality parts with intricate designs. Despite their advantages, they come with higher upfront costs and require careful maintenance. Additionally, not all materials are suitable for hot runners due to their sensitivity to heat. On the other hand, cold runner systems are simpler and more cost-effective initially, but they are less environmentally friendly and slower. The choice between the two depends on factors such as budget constraints, production volume, and part complexity, weighing the benefits of hot runners against their higher investment and maintenance requirements.
Hot runner systems have several advantages over cold runner systems, such as reduced material waste due to the lack of need for trimming or recycling the excess material, improved cycle time which increases the productivity and profitability of the process, and enhanced quality with less risk of defects like shrinkage, warping, or sink marks. This improves both the aesthetic and functional quality of the parts while also reducing the cost of raw materials and improving the environmental impact of the process.
-
The automation and efficiency inherent in hot runner systems significantly diminish the need for manual labor associated with part handling and post-processing, which not only slashes labor costs but also accelerates production timelines. Moreover, with fewer human interventions, the potential for contamination during the molding process is drastically reduced, ensuring higher purity and consistency in the final products. This streamlined approach not only enhances operational efficiency but also contributes to maintaining stringent quality standards, making hot runner systems a preferred choice for industries where precision and hygiene are paramount.
-
One of the biggest advantages of hot runner systems is the elimination of plastic scrap but also the opportunity to run parts on "auto" and without labor to separate sprues/trim gates. One molder I know of has made their business float by specializing in hot runner systems and running "lights out" where parts drop straight into packaging and boxes are indexed automatically without labor involved. QC checks the parts but in a generation that struggles to find and retain operators automation like this can be a major benefit.
However, hot runner systems have some drawbacks compared to cold runner systems, such as a higher initial cost due to the more complex and sophisticated components, like heaters and controllers. Maintenance and repair costs are also higher due to the additional electrical and mechanical parts. Furthermore, hot runner systems require more technical skill and experience to operate and optimize than cold runner systems, which can affect the learning curve and the quality control of the process. This can be a challenge for small or medium-sized projects with limited budgets.
-
Sem dúvida o investimento inicial com projeto, execução e manutenção da câmara quente assusta muito. Em alguns casos mais específicos onde é necessário troca de cor frequente eu alerto o cliente sobre o desperdício de material causado nesse processo, já que é muito mais complicado limpar os canais quentes.
-
Some suppliers may believe that when using a hot runner mold, they don't require highly skilled workers because the hot runner system is automatic. However, I believe that workers must possess a good understanding of molds and the injection molding process. Temperature control is particularly critical in this process, and operators must pay close attention to it to ensure optimal
When it comes to deciding which type of runner system is better for injection molding, there is no definitive answer as the choice depends on several factors. For example, larger and more complex parts may benefit from hot runner systems due to reduced material waste, cycle time, and quality issues. On the other hand, smaller and simpler parts may be more suitable for cold runner systems as they consume less material and energy. Additionally, the type and grade of plastic should be taken into account, as some plastics are more sensitive to temperature and pressure changes than others. Moreover, the volume and frequency of production should be considered, as higher volume and frequency of production may justify the higher initial and maintenance cost of hot runner systems in the long run.
-
Levo sempre para os clientes do escritório Projetos de Mestre que o uso de câmara quente é ideal para quem precisa de uma alta produção e ser competitivo no custo de material (produtos de grande volume e pouca margem). Outro caso são as peças que necessitam de uma boa qualidade ótica e cosmética. A opção por câmara quente deve ser feita desde que haja margem para diluição desses custos no produto.
If you decide to use hot runner systems for your injection molding project, here are some tips to help you get the best results. You should choose the right design and configuration of the hot runner system, depending on the shape, size, and number of cavities in your mold. Additionally, you need to control the temperature and pressure of the plastic for optimal results. To do this, use a reliable and accurate controller and sensor system. Lastly, it is important to clean and maintain the hot runner system regularly. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and recommendations for cleaning and maintaining the hot runner system using appropriate tools and materials to remove any residue or dirt from the components.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Manufacturing EngineeringHow can you use hot runner systems to improve injection molding?
-
Manufacturing OperationsHow can you use hot runner systems to improve injection molding quality?
-
Materials ScienceYou need to join metal parts for your industrial application. What is the most reliable adhesive?
-
Injection MoldingHow can valve gated molds improve cycle time and part quality in injection molding?