How do you enforce a buy-sell agreement in case of a breach or default?
A buy-sell agreement is a contract that specifies how the ownership of a business will be transferred in case of certain events, such as death, disability, retirement, or divorce of a partner. It can also include provisions for resolving disputes, valuing the business, and funding the buyout. But what if one of the parties breaches or defaults on the agreement? How can you enforce your rights and protect your interests? Here are some steps you can take to deal with a buy-sell agreement violation.
The first step is to identify the nature and extent of the breach or default. You need to review the terms and conditions of the agreement and determine which ones have been violated. For example, a breach could occur if a partner sells or transfers their shares to a third party without the consent of the other partners, or if they fail to pay their share of the buyout price. A default could occur if a partner becomes bankrupt, incapacitated, or disqualified from the business. You also need to gather evidence and documentation to support your claim and assess the impact of the breach or default on the business.
-
Assess the financial stability of the breaching party immediately. Implement key metrics, like liquidity ratios and debt service coverage ratios, to predict potential future breaches. Leverage performance bonds or surety bonds as financial guarantees. Use third-party audits to ensure unbiased compliance verification. Finally, consider renegotiating terms to mitigate risks.
The next step is to communicate with the other party and try to resolve the issue amicably. You can send a notice of breach or default, outlining the facts and the remedies you seek, and request a response within a reasonable time frame. You can also propose a negotiation or mediation process to reach a mutually acceptable solution. Communication can help you avoid costly and lengthy litigation and preserve the relationship with the other party, if possible.
-
In addressing a breach in a buy-sell agreement, proactive communication with the involved party is essential. This step, which involves sending a detailed notice of breach and suggesting remedies within a defined period, serves dual purposes. Firstly, it opens a pathway for amicable resolution, potentially avoiding litigation. Secondly, this communication process can generate crucial evidence, such as debt acknowledgment, which might be advantageous in court if the dispute escalates. Thus, engaging in dialogue not only seeks resolution but also strategically prepares for possible legal proceedings.
-
Use an escrow agent to manage disputed funds, ensuring security while negotiations occur. Implement a pre-agreed conflict resolution clause in your agreement to streamline mediation. Leverage KPIs like response times and settlement ratios to measure effectiveness. Employ an industry-specific mediator with proven success rates to facilitate fair resolutions and maintain professional relationships.
If communication fails or the breach or default is too serious to be resolved informally, you may need to seek legal advice and action. You can consult a lawyer who specializes in buy-sell agreements and business law, and explore your options and strategies. Depending on the circumstances, you may be able to sue for damages, specific performance, injunction, rescission, or termination of the agreement. You may also be able to enforce any security interests, arbitration clauses, or liquidated damages provisions in the agreement. Legal action can help you enforce your rights and obligations, but it can also be expensive, time-consuming, and risky.
-
Let us assume that an event triggers a breach in the contract. One of the immediate steps should be to go through the documents in place that govern said agreement. Standard contract templates usually have a 'breach of terms' clause. Compare your clause with the event. Does it match the requirements to be classified as a breach of contract? If so, does the contract allow you to take any precautionary or prohibitory steps to gain immediate relief (legally)? If not, the first step should always be to peacefully hash it out with the breaching party. My honest advice: Litigation should be a last resort as it takes even more money, energy and time with no guarantee of quick respite. What do you say? Makes sense? :)
The final step is to review and update the agreement to prevent future breaches or defaults. You may need to revise or clarify some terms and conditions, such as the valuation method, the buyout price, the triggering events, or the dispute resolution process. You may also need to update the agreement to reflect any changes in the business, the market, or the law. Reviewing and updating the agreement can help you avoid ambiguity, confusion, and conflict, and ensure that the agreement reflects your current needs and goals.
-
One way that this can be done is to have a 'Term clause' in the agreement that allows for amendments. This gives one leeway to review and change the agreement before renewal. Free and easy solution: STEP 1 : Google "Boilerplate clauses" STEP 2 : Ensure that your contract has all the relevant ones covering you. STEP 3: Pat yourself on the back for a job well-done!
-
If the LLC members or shareholders are willing to review the existing Operating Agreement or Shareholders Agreement before any such conduct occurs, I recommend that they consider the following: having the revised or amended agreement contain provisions for: (a) non-binding mediation before litigation, (b) an option to the company to buy-out the spouse of the member or shareholder who is being divorced to ward off the spouse acquiring the member's or shareholder's interest in the company, (c) a right of the company or the members or shareholders to match any third-party offer to purchase interest in the company (
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Private EquityHow can you ensure that your private equity exit agreement is enforceable?
-
PartnershipsWhat do you do if your partnership fails?
-
SubcontractingHow do you deal with subcontractor insolvency, breach, or termination?
-
Contract ManagementWhat are some of the key clauses or provisions that you include in your contracts to reduce contract risks?