How do you design a fair and engaging loot box system for your game?

Loot boxes are a popular and controversial way of monetizing your game. They are randomized rewards that players can buy or earn by playing. They can contain anything from cosmetic items, to power-ups, to rare weapons. But how do you design a loot box system that is fair and engaging for your players, and profitable for your business? Here are some tips to help you create a loot box system that works for your game.

1 Know your audience

Before you decide what kind of loot boxes to offer, you need to understand your target audience and their preferences. What kind of game are you making, and what kind of players are you attracting? Are they casual or hardcore, competitive or cooperative, young or old, male or female? What are their motivations for playing, and what are their expectations for rewards? Different types of players may have different reactions to loot boxes, and you need to tailor your system to suit them.

Add your perspective

Abdul R.

Operational Security | Risk Analyst | IT Specialist | eDiscovery | GRC
Research is key. It's one thing going through data or other partially relevant information via Google or utilising other search engines. But you have to really see how end users interact with real-world loot box systems. Utilising platforms such as YouTube or getting hands-on with games that align with what you're working on will definitely give you insight into what works and what doesn't. Data comes from the players, and that's who you need to engage with or watch, to see the audience you may end up encountering as opposed to just targeting.
Like
Report contribution
Ifeanyi Ejindu

Founder @ The Confidant | CEO @ Skillseeds Limited | Growth Specialist | Business Analyst | Project Manager | Software Engineer | Product Manager
It's one thing going through data or other partially relevant information via Google or utilising other search engines. But you have to really see how end users interact with real-world loot box systems. And, know tour audience. research is key. you won't make everyone happy with one general direction, so maybe a personally catered approach to that specific player might work best .
Like
Report contribution
Darren Morrison

Regional Service Supervisor (East Coast) | Maritime Professional | Full Time Learner| Part Time Dreamer
I would structure a loot box based on the activity level of the player . Their frequency in the game and their level of skill. You want to reward loyal players , you don't want to give already skilled players too much of an advantage but you always want to bait some casual players to be more engaged and want to return . Loot boxes don't always have useful items which is understandable but if one has to acquire several loot boxes to maybe have a couple useful items, they may feel cheated. You won't make everyone happy with one general direction, so maybe a personally catered approach to that specific player might work best .
Like
Report contribution

2 Balance your economy

One of the biggest challenges of designing a loot box system is balancing your game economy. You need to make sure that your loot boxes are not too expensive, or too cheap, or too generous, or too stingy. You need to find the sweet spot that makes your players feel satisfied, but also tempted to buy more. You also need to consider how your loot boxes affect the gameplay and the progression of your players. You don't want to make your game too easy or too hard, or create a pay-to-win scenario that alienates your players.

Add your perspective

Utkarsh K.

IT Ops Intern@Aditya Birla FRL | Web Ops Engineer@PARA | Google CSJ Facilitator | Google DSC Technical Lead | MERN Stack Developer | Content Writer |
To design a fair and engaging loot box system, balance your in-game economy by: Ensuring Fair Value: Provide valuable items and clearly define item rarity. Showing Odds: Transparently display probabilities of obtaining different item rarities. Rewarding Useful Items: Avoid junk; ensure even common items are valuable and balance power. Gathering Feedback: Regularly collect and use player feedback to make adjustments. Offering Free and Paid Options: Allow players to earn loot boxes through gameplay and offer paid alternatives without overshadowing the earnable ones. This approach keeps the system fair, engaging, and trustworthy.
Like
Report contribution

3 Be transparent and ethical

Another important aspect of designing a loot box system is being transparent and ethical with your players. You need to disclose the odds of getting different items from your loot boxes, and avoid any misleading or deceptive practices. You also need to respect the laws and regulations of different countries and regions, and comply with any age restrictions or parental controls. You don't want to face legal issues or public backlash for your loot box system.

Add your perspective

4 Add variety and value

To make your loot box system more appealing and engaging, you need to add variety and value to your loot boxes. You need to offer different kinds of loot boxes, with different themes, contents, and prices. You need to make sure that your loot boxes contain items that are relevant, useful, and desirable for your players. You also need to provide alternative ways of acquiring items, such as crafting, trading, or earning through gameplay. You don't want to make your loot boxes boring or redundant.

Add your perspective

5 Test and iterate

Finally, you need to test and iterate your loot box system before you launch it, and after you launch it. You need to gather feedback from your players, and analyze the data from your sales and retention. You need to measure the impact of your loot box system on your game performance, and adjust it accordingly. You also need to keep updating and improving your loot box system, and adding new items and features. You don't want to make your loot boxes stale or outdated.

Add your perspective