How do you compare TCPI with CPI and SPI to assess project health?
Earned value management (EVM) is a widely used method to measure and control project performance by comparing the actual work done, the planned work, and the budget. EVM uses several metrics to track and forecast project health, such as cost performance index (CPI), schedule performance index (SPI), and to complete performance index (TCPI). In this article, you will learn how to compare TCPI with CPI and SPI to assess project health and what they mean for over-budget and under-budget scenarios.
TCPI is a ratio that indicates the efficiency required to complete the remaining work of the project within the budget. It is calculated by dividing the budgeted cost of work remaining (BCWR) by the estimate at completion (EAC) or the budget at completion (BAC), depending on whether the project is expected to meet or exceed the original budget. A TCPI value of 1 means that the project can finish on budget with the current efficiency, while a value greater than 1 means that the project needs to improve its efficiency to finish on budget, and a value less than 1 means that the project has some slack to finish on budget.
-
The To-Complete Performance Index (TCPI) is a measure used in Earned Value Management (EVM) that indicates the level of performance required to complete the remaining work within the original budget or a revised budget. TCPI is calculated as the ratio of the remaining work to the remaining funds. The formula for TCPI when considering the Budget at Completion (BAC) is: \[ \text{TCPI} = \frac{BAC - EV}{BAC - AC} \] Where: - BAC = Budget at Completion - EV = Earned Value - AC = Actual Cost A TCPI value greater than 1 indicates that the project needs to perform better than planned to meet the budget, while a TCPI less than 1 suggests that the project can perform below the planned efficiency and still meet the budget.
CPI is a ratio that indicates the efficiency of the actual work done compared to the planned work. It is calculated by dividing the earned value (EV), which is the value of the work completed, by the actual cost (AC), which is the cost incurred to complete the work. A CPI value of 1 means that the project is on budget, while a value greater than 1 means that the project is under budget, and a value less than 1 means that the project is over budget.
-
The Cost Performance Index (CPI) is a measure of cost efficiency in a project, comparing the value of work performed to the actual cost incurred. It is a key EVM metric that helps assess whether the project is within its budget. The formula for CPI is: \[ \text{CPI} = \frac{EV}{AC} \] Where: - EV = Earned Value - AC = Actual Cost A CPI value greater than 1 indicates that the project is performing well in terms of cost, as it is spending less than planned. Conversely, a CPI less than 1 suggests cost overruns, meaning the project is spending more than planned for the work accomplished.
SPI is a ratio that indicates the progress of the actual work done compared to the planned work. It is calculated by dividing the earned value (EV) by the planned value (PV), which is the value of the work planned to be completed. A SPI value of 1 means that the project is on schedule, while a value greater than 1 means that the project is ahead of schedule, and a value less than 1 means that the project is behind schedule.
-
The Schedule Performance Index (SPI) is a measure of schedule efficiency in a project, comparing the amount of work actually completed to the amount of work planned. It is another critical EVM metric that helps determine if the project is on schedule. The formula for SPI is: \[ \text{SPI} = \frac{EV}{PV} \] Where: - EV = Earned Value - PV = Planned Value An SPI value greater than 1 indicates that the project is ahead of schedule, while an SPI less than 1 suggests that the project is behind schedule. SPI helps project managers identify timing issues early and adjust resources or schedules as necessary.
To compare TCPI with CPI and SPI, you need to consider the current status and the future outlook of the project. If the project is on track, both CPI and SPI should be close to 1, and TCPI should also be close to 1, indicating that the project can maintain its current efficiency and finish on budget and on time. If the project is over budget, CPI should be less than 1, and TCPI should be greater than 1, indicating that the project needs to improve its efficiency and reduce its costs to finish on budget. If the project is under budget, CPI should be greater than 1, and TCPI should be less than 1, indicating that the project has some room to spend more or finish earlier. If the project is behind schedule, SPI should be less than 1, and TCPI should be greater than 1, indicating that the project needs to speed up its work and increase its productivity to finish on time. If the project is ahead of schedule, SPI should be greater than 1, and TCPI should be less than 1, indicating that the project can afford to slow down or finish earlier.
-
To compare TCPI with CPI and SPI, one must look at these indices together to get a comprehensive picture of the project's health. If TCPI is significantly higher than CPI, it indicates that the cost performance needs to improve to meet the budget goals. Conversely, if TCPI is close to or lower than CPI, the project is on track or might even finish under budget. Similarly, if TCPI is higher than SPI, it suggests that the project needs to accelerate its performance to stay within the budget. In practical terms, a project with a high TCPI but low CPI and SPI is in trouble, as it indicates both cost and schedule inefficiencies that need urgent attention. Conversely, a project with low TCPI and high CPI and SPI values is likely doing well.
TCPI can help you adjust your project plan and expectations for over-budget and under-budget scenarios. For over-budget scenarios, you can use TCPI to calculate the new EAC based on the BCWR and the required efficiency. For example, if your BCWR is $50,000 and your TCPI is 1.2, your new EAC is $50,000 / 1.2 = $41,667, which is lower than your original BAC of $45,000. This means that you need to cut your costs by $3,333 to finish on budget. You can also use TCPI to determine how much you can increase your scope or quality without exceeding your BAC. For example, if your TCPI is 0.8, you can increase your BCWR by 20% without affecting your budget. For under-budget scenarios, you can use TCPI to calculate the new EAC based on the BCWR and the actual efficiency. For example, if your BCWR is $50,000 and your CPI is 1.2, your new EAC is $50,000 / 1.2 = $41,667, which is lower than your original BAC of $45,000. This means that you have saved $3,333 from your budget. You can also use TCPI to determine how much you can decrease your scope or quality without falling below your BAC. For example, if your TCPI is 1.2, you can decrease your BCWR by 20% without affecting your budget.
-
For over-budget scenarios, where the project is exceeding the budget (CPI < 1), the TCPI will be greater than 1, indicating the need for more efficient performance to meet the budget. The project team should focus on cost-saving measures, reducing waste, and increasing productivity to bring the TCPI closer to 1. In under-budget scenarios, where the project is spending less than planned (CPI > 1), the TCPI will be less than 1, suggesting that the project can afford to maintain or slightly reduce performance efficiency without exceeding the budget. This scenario allows for more flexibility in resource allocation and can be an opportunity to reallocate resources to other areas or future projects.
To improve TCPI and project efficiency and performance, there are various approaches depending on the root causes of the project issues and the available resources and constraints. These methods could include revising the project scope, schedule, or quality to meet stakeholder expectations, negotiating for more budget, time, or resources if feasible, applying risk management strategies to prevent or mitigate threats, implementing change management processes to control and communicate any changes in the project plan or environment, improving the project team's skills and motivation, and leveraging best practices, tools, and techniques to optimize project processes and deliverables.
-
Improving TCPI involves taking strategic actions to enhance performance efficiency. One approach is to conduct a thorough review of current project processes and identify areas where costs can be reduced without compromising quality. Implementing cost-saving measures, optimizing resource allocation, and improving workflow efficiency are key strategies. Additionally, ensuring that project team members have the necessary skills and training to perform their tasks efficiently can significantly impact TCPI. Regular monitoring and controlling of project activities through frequent performance reviews and timely corrective actions can also help improve TCPI.
-
In addition to the quantitative metrics of EVM, qualitative factors such as stakeholder communication, team morale, and risk management play a crucial role in overall project health. Effective communication ensures that all stakeholders are aware of project status and any issues that arise, allowing for collaborative problem-solving and decision-making. Maintaining high team morale can drive better performance and productivity, contributing positively to project outcomes. Risk management is another critical area to consider. Proactively identifying potential risks and having mitigation plans in place can prevent issues that might adversely affect project performance.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Project CoordinationWhat metrics do you use to evaluate the success of your scheduling process?
-
Project ManagementHow do you assess project progress using earned value analysis?
-
AccountingHow can you accurately calculate project variances?
-
Project ManagementHow do you manage project costs and budgets in your industry?