Jeff Antalik

Amazing Narrator

Revisado: 06-09-21

Narrator does a masterful job. I recently listened to a radio interview of Norman Maclean from 1976 shortly after the book was released… narrator sounds exactly they way he did; same cadence.

The last story about the rancher and the cook is a real hidden Gem; so glad to have found it.

Fans of ‘A River Runs Through It’: be sure to check out ‘Home Waters’ just released by Norman’s son John Maclean. He paints the full picture of his Uncle Paul’s life and untimely death.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

The Real Paul Maclean and Much More

Revisado: 06-07-21

Having seen the movie and read the book many times, I was always fascinated by the character of Paul Maclean. I was searching the internet a while back to find out more information about his life when I came across an article that mentioned this book was coming out. I set a reminder and purchased the audiobook on its June 1 release date.

First off, how utterly fascinating to meet up with old characters from the original book and in a nonfiction environment! ‘Home Waters’ refers back to the original book and movie on a regular basis. To be reacquainted with the critical elements and characters of the classic novella through the perspective of Norman Maclean’s son John is a revelation. The book is meticulously researched and a completely unvarnished account of the facts as known. The author includes some really fascinating background topics as well as poetic passages relating to family and nature.

With regard to the real Paul Maclean, the book does not disappoint. “Mystery always clung to Paul” and “some answers” are “forever beyond reach” but John Maclean delves deeply into the real life of his uncle, to the extent that is known. Turns out Paul was much more of a lost soul than was represented in the original book or movie. What a shame that such a talented, loved person seemed to spend a good deal of his time “looking for trouble”, which, in all likelihood, tragically caught up with him. One wonders how much the author’s life would have been enriched if Uncle Paul had been in it. Like all tragedies involving someone taken too soon, family members, friends, and future generations are robbed of what could have been.

The book is so much more than a revisitation of ‘A River Runs Through It’. The history of the family’s Seeley Lake cabin, the harrowing trips through the Dearborn River backcountry, the full analysis of shadow casting, the fate of the Big Blackfoot River after the movie release, Norman Maclean’s writing struggles later in life… so many fascinating topics and passages; all meticulously and painstakingly researched with complete authenticity.

Interesting, Paul’s legendary prowess as a fly fisherman is frequently referenced but not covered in detail. In fact, there is some debate as to if “shadow casting” even works to catch fish.

Going back and forth through time visiting the real characters and events that shaped ‘A River Runs Through It’ from the perspective of Norman Maclean’s son and Paul Maclean’s closest living relative is a truly unique treat for admirers of the original story.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 4 personas

Worth the Time

Revisado: 12-06-20

Enjoyable listen. Great narrator and fun western feel. Supernatural element is unique. The reluctant hero draws you in and makes you root for him.
Interesting concept.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

Thorough, Valuable Information

Revisado: 11-19-20

I’ve always enjoyed survival equipment and Les’ TV show. This complete guide did not disappoint. I find myself listening again and again while doing things around the house or before bed. There are many pointers that apply to everyday life as well as any survival situation. Les is very sincere in imparting a lifetime of survival wisdom in one place. This book is no-nonsense; no cheesy humor to detract from the valuable insights provided. One great tip that he really hammers home is the value of knowledge provided by locals and those that have actually been to the places that you are planning to explore. Books and the internet are no substitute for knowledge gained through actual experience, especially in remote locations.

Packed with wisdom, I highly recommend this audio book. Les does a great job of narrating and his passion and expertise really come through. Well worth the time and investment.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

You will not stop listening

Revisado: 08-12-20

Absolutely spellbinding; will catch your attention and never let you go. Very interesting, honest narration by young guy that gets swept into this whole fascinating saga. Reminds me of Ronan Farrow with catch and kill .... heroic standing up to a propaganda machine at huge personal cost when no one else has the courage or duty to do what’s right.
Authentic, down to earth narration... very cool musical interludes... flawlessly produced.

I will remember this tale for a long long time and really admire Tyler’s fearlessness and refusal to give in.

Very sad that his Grandfather was unwilling or incapable of supporting him through almost all of his ordeal. I have faced this with my own aging parents... they are blind to certain realities and will cling to their invalid beliefs despite a mountain of evidence indicating otherwise; a very unfortunate side of human nature.
Seems that this piece has been really well received as it should. Well worth 4 hours of your time

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña