Good in the midst of evil

A very moving and informative account of life and struggle in Germany, making it much clearer how the Third Reich came to be, despite frankly massive opposition. A truly scary time for those disposed to follow their consciences. This book is a fitting tribute to those people. The world unfurls accordingly as we each make our own decisions. Some big some small. Sobering thoughts for modern times still. This book has changed my view of the German people of WW2. It was very sensitively and ably read by Karen Cass. I really enjoyed it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A fantastic read. Many interesting people.

This has been one of favourite audio books to date.

I have studied the Nazi era for many years and this was a really refreshing take and I managed to learn a lot that I didn't already know. I'm definitely going to find further literature on Julius Leber and Ernst Thällman. The performance was delivered superbly.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Fascinating account

This is an extremely well researched and written book. It’s scope is wide yet the author captures the behaviour and experiences of many people. As she states very little was recounted of resisters from a left wing perspective and this provides interesting material alongside more commonly explored events.
Overall a great listen and read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An excellent book

A book that is well worth a read. Give it a try and I don't think you'll be disappointed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Lesson Learnt

Education for those of us who suspected there were many more nazis before the war than after. A little too much extraneous waffle, and more dramaric detail would have been enjoyed, but nevertheless an excellent read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Powerful.

Granted me a completely unique perspective of the German people during the war. Powerful. Imagine your country being taken over like Germany was taken over my the Nazis during the 30s. Unbelievable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting but troubling

I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this book. To many, the story of German resistance begins and ends with the July 20 plot and the failed coup attempt. The stories contained within this book go some way to adding depth and understanding to this subject. However, I do have some problems with the narrative. One fault is the simple perpetuation of the myth that the Reichstag fire was started by the Nazis as a pretext for mass arrests of communists. Richard J Evans has conclusively debunked this and all the evidence points to a lone wolf attack by Dutch communist, Marinus van der Lubbe as they German courts found at the time. The Nazis needed no such pretext. More grave, however is the charge that stems from the title, “The Good Germans.” The book, to my mind, reinforces the dichotomy that the Germans could be split in to two groups: Nazis = evil; ordinary Germans = good (and,by extension, resistors, or at least sympathetic to the resistance). This is very far from the truth. Without widespread approval, including at the ballot box, the Nazis would never have been able to go so far. The myth of the all knowing Gestapo has also been shown to be highly exaggerated. Within the Reich itself it was a much smaller organisation than might be imagined and relied heavily on denunciation for information. For ordinary Germans they may have feared the Gestapo and the concentration camps, but they were not directly affected by them. (Note: in countries occupied by the Nazis and the active resistance, both internal and foreign, the threat of the Gestapo and their methods of interrogation was all too real). This book shines great light on the inspirational resistance of Ernst Thälmann, Julius Leber and Fabien von Schlabrendorf among others, but it should not be forgotten that these people were in the tiny minority of Germans willing to oppose the Nazis. Statistics might be boring, but at least a chapter on putting these stories into a wider context might have been helpful.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

fascinating listen

fascinating listen the history of the Germans against the Nazi regime shows that not all germans are bad

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Stunning

How wonderful to have these extraordinary people brought into my awareness, the love letters are enduring and so very moving. The way humanity loves in the midst of fear and death, is surely our great redeemer.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The good Germans

In a world where everything is black or white, this book is timely. It lays to rest the myth that Germany followed Hitler blindly. This book reminds all those who believe that lie, of the thousands in camps, for their defiance, opposition or disregard of the Nazi tyranny, the executions and the waste. It is a deserved memorial to those brave Germans, known and unknown who sacrificed everything in the struggle for a better world

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!