got me sobbing

your very right its never too late

huh thats a very interesting review. i was always under the impression that this game has a very grim and depressing ending

cool beans

why be a good person when i can just insult you on the internet?

Thanks OP. Appreciate the review, and the uplifting life lesson all in one. Kudos. May we strive to be better people and make 2021 a year of redemption.

(2/2) The conversation with the nun was not meant to be a theological exegesis, nor a systematic philosophical thesis on what constitutes virtue or sin. They are simple archetypes representing either side of the line dividing the human heart, conversing in a manner perhaps more suitable to their character, time, and place (in a western video game ). It's the narrative of the anti-hero, and injecting a little morality into an otherwise edgy drama at least offers us a glimpse of hope that we, too, are worthy of salvaging whatever scraps of grace fate allows us. That it's never too late to make different choices and become someone different than we were, so no matter what we've done there's still potential to redeem what we thought was lost time. Though we disagree in part, your opinion caused me to think and consider the themes presented throughout the game, because they seemed to me genuinely heartfelt and mindful. Cheers to health in mind, body, & spirit.

(1/2) To despingator, a lot of your critique is valid, but it struck me that your evaluation is made in cynical fashion, as much one-sided as you implied the original review is. Love your paraphrase of Solzhenitsyn, by the way, and I won't presume any ignorance on your part of Jung's concept of the shadow every human harbors within their being, situated alongside their higher conscience (both at times interchangeable). The integration of these various aspects of mankind could be interpreted as a form of redemption that you alluded to. "Grace," with the capitalization you granted it, inclines me to make certain assumptions about how much meaning you imbue the term with. Nevertheless, the rhetorical question immediately following this statement about who or what qualifies "good" nullifies your previous declaration concerning matters of both real redemption and the conception of Grace.

I too love Arthur Morgan. You and I are gonna have to fight, Seki.

Yes, redeem your murders by letting small fish back to water! It will absolve your sins! ;)