I think the same. Depending on the genre, atmosphere, even the nature of the character itself allows you to create a silent hero and this will be appropriate and logical. Problems begin where the other characters literally ignore the main character or do not ask a logical question like "Why don't you answer?" and we just look at their dialogues among themselves or one-sided monologues
That's convention. You know how when you overhear a phone conversation it's usually just one side, and you have to imagine the rest? It often becomes a plot point, or at least a stylistic element, in movies. It can be the same with letters, which is an old literary convention. Lets the viewer, or reader, imagine what the other side said, and become more involved in the story. Often it's a lot more interesting than trying to write lots of banal replies without boring the audience.
Imagining what the protagonist would say isn't bad, but often I'm really curious to know who I'm actually playing as, especially if earlier the story says that the protagonist has a personality, character, desires, or any other attributes of a personality. There is a feeling that the game forcibly suppresses the personality of the protagonist . Often, the phrase about a silent but comfortable protagonist hides the fear of not living up to the expectations of a large number of players. Previously, a similar trick was used due to lack of budget, for uselessness in the genre, or vice versa, in order to create a duality and mystery of the protagonist, as in Little Nightmares. It's a good tool, but now it often seems out of place or misused out of habit. It's a little disappointing how big companies use it to increase sales, not wanting to take risks, and indie developers picked up this trend, not really wanting to work on the character, leaving everything to the imagination of the players. Sometimes it even seems to me that the very concept of "protagonist" is slowly degrading into something faceless, created only for the player to take his place
I disagree that this is a cost-saving fad from big-money publishers, or even a fad at all. It was very common if not the norm for many years across many genres, especially when storage space for frivolous text was severely limited, and digitized speech was an expensive novelty that sounded terrible anyway. Over the years, text became trivial to include, while voice acting is still expensive. If anything, protagonists that speak have become more common since the early days, not less, especially in games that aren't fully voiced. There's no real financial incentive not to write some plain text; it's done for stylistic reasons. Meanwhile, in fully-voiced games, you may have the budget to voice, say, 500 lines of dialogue; the pressure here is to keep the total script to 500 lines, not to silence the protagonist specifically. At most, doing so might be marginally convenient. It certainly isn't a bullet point feature to boost sales.
I don't see any evidence that there has been a large-scale shift in the industry towards protagonists who should speak no longer doing so. That's a very strange claim to make.
It’s worth mentioning that I don’t focus too much on voice acting, I prefer text communication, it’s also easier to implement. If the problem was only in it, then this is no problem, everything is in order, but the same thing happens with text communication in games, and this is really strange for me. The hero going through a huge adventure that he doesn't react to like he doesn't care is what really bothers me lately
Good point. The silent-protagonist trope predates games with full voiceover. Heck, it predates games with graphics. So now it can create cognitive dissonance. I didn't think of that.
Hotline Miami is an interesting game, as the character makes the decisions to be bloodthirsty (and the game's checkpoints feed into this lack of control). Additionally, the plot twists need to convey a number of meanings simultaneously.
Perhaps a voiced protagonist could work; but it's extremely difficult. Content writing is a difficult artform.
this protagonist is silent extreme demon