Play game
Arrival's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| Overall | #7 | 2.649 | 3.679 |
| Sound | #7 | 2.880 | 4.000 |
| Originality | #7 | 2.777 | 3.857 |
| Fun | #7 | 2.263 | 3.143 |
| Accessibility | #8 | 2.675 | 3.714 |
Ranked from 7 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Comments
Just tried the updated game and level 1 is indeed fixed. Level 2 seems fixed also and is actually pretty fun to play imho.
On level 3 though, the game gets buggy. First off it repeats the level 2 prompt. And sometimes the panning of the beep changes unexpectedly i.e. when traveling on the z axis, the sound tends to pan from left to right abnormally, and even if my distances on all axes are less than 0.5 m, the sound is still panned far right when I touch down and I crash.
But I really like the concept and where it's going! My only real complaints are:
1. The inability to interrupt the computer voice. In general, when I press keys, I'd like status messages which are speaking to be interrupted. This would be useful in cases where I only care about the beginning of the message i.e. I only care that my speed is 300 something, I don't care about the rest of it, yet I am forced to listen to it before I can check other things in the game's current state.
2. Numbers after decimal places are a little weird, as they are not spoken in digits but are grouped like non-decimal numbers. That can make things a little daunting to take in, especially with the non-interruptable speech prompts.
Another suggestion I have is to implement support for NVDA, a popular screen reader for the blind. Using the NVDA controller client dll, it is possible for applications to tell NVDA to speak any information needed. It is often used in audio games to save the trouble of handling recorded voice prompts. It also offers three other advantages: NVDA speech can easily be interrupted as desired, numbers can be sent as is without processing them to fit pre-recorded numbers, and the user can use the voice and speaking rate they prefer. In a game like Arrival, I think a brisk speaking rate on a voice that you're comfortable with would make it easier to take in and process all the information you need to keep track of.
Anyway, those are just my thoughts/suggestions, they are not at all intended to be annoying/difficult :). I really hope you continue this. If you do, I wish you the best of luck and I look forward to trying future updates!
Hi.
I love the presentation here, the grim takes by station control and your commander, wonderful sence of the world.
The audio is also great, with the music and spoken dialogue.
However, I'm afraid the gameplay and game design are really letting this one down.
Firstly, the specification of numbers and coordinates. Often, by the time coordinates were spoken, it was already too late, especially when coming in on approach, indeed the audio beacon could be used far more than it is.
Why there isn't a single key press to get x. y and z coordinates I don't know, ditto with speed, indeed the thrust system with 5 being neutral took me a while to work out.
However, the major problem in the game, the game is literally impossible!
After half an hour of trying, I still had not completed the training mission.
I tried coming in on speed 3, then throtling down. I died.
I tried coming in on speed 4, then changing to speed 5 when I was one coordinate away, this left me hanging in space at speed zero, and one touch of the thrusters caused me to die, indeed by the time I got the proximity warning it was already too late to pull up.
I tried coming in at speed 4, then changing to speed 6 when I was one coordinate away, and again, I was just hanging outside at zero, and one touch of 4 and I died!
The thrusters seem to accelerate and decelerate way too quickly, especially with the clunky, three key press input to change your thrust level, and three key press input to check anything.
I really don't like having such a downer on the game, since the concept is interesting, the presentation very nice, and the audio (for all that it felt that the speech and beacons weren't used correctly), is really good.
however I'm afraid after that many unsuccessful attempts the game has gone beyond what is fun.
I would hevily suggest streamlining the interface so that thrust can be changed a lot more quickly, as well as getting far easier ways of reporting information.
Several other audiogames have simulated fine tuned vehicular control, EG, Tube sim, the Japanese game dreamy train, the flight sim eurofly, or the combat flight sim zero sight, so it might be worth examining the details they've used, EG easier ways of distance reporting, since all of those titles (even the very difficult zero sight), were far less problematic than arrival.
For more info on these and other audiogames, please visit www.audiogames.net.
I'm really sorry to have such a downer on the game, I genuinely appreciate the work that's gone into this, and I'm quite aware games development isn't easy, I also really hope that development will continue in the future, since we definitely need more detailed audio space games.
Hey!
Thank you for the feedback. Unfortunately due to a lot of last minute changes, I missed the bug as we wanted to release this ASAP. It is now fixed and level 2 is now accessible!
This page didn't work. The link to your game page.