Jump to content

Robert Forster (musician)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
For other people named Robert Forster, see Robert Forster (disambiguation).

Robert Forster
Three-quarter shot of a 55-year-old man sitting on a chair, he is singing into a microphone and playing his guitar. The guitar also has a microphone. He wears dark clothes and has short hair.
Forster performing at Dombrowsky Bookstore, Regensburg, Germany in December 2012
Background information
Birth nameRobert Derwent Garth Forster
Born (1957-06-29) 29 June 1957 (age 67)
Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
GenresPop, country, indie rock
Occupation(s)Musician, music critic
Instrument(s)Vocals, guitar
LabelsBeggars Banquet, Shock, Concubine, Yep Roc
Websiterobertforster.net

Robert Derwent Garth Forster (born 29 June 1957) is an Australian singer-songwriter, guitarist and music critic. In December 1977 he co-founded an indie rock group, The Go-Betweens, with fellow musician Grant McLennan. In 1980, Lindy Morrison joined the group on drums and backing vocals, and by 1981 Forster and Morrison were also lovers. In 1988, "Streets of Your Town", co-written by McLennan and Forster, became the band's highest-charting hit in both Australia and the United Kingdom. The follow-up single, "Was There Anything I Could Do?", was a number-16 hit on the Billboard Modern Rock Tracks chart in the United States. In December 1989, after recording six albums, The Go-Betweens disbanded. Forster and Morrison had separated as a couple earlier, and Forster began his solo music career from 1990.

Forster's solo studio albums are Danger in the Past (1990), Calling from a Country Phone (1993), I Had a New York Girlfriend (1995), Warm Nights (1996), The Evangelist (2008), Songs To Play (2015), Inferno (2019) and The Candle and the Flame (2023). Allmusic's Stewart Mason described him, as having "a knack for crafty pop songs along with the brooding ballads he contributed to the Go-Betweens' albums, and his solo career has shown a healthy mix of the two styles". From 2000 to 2006, The Go-Betweens reformed and issued three more studio albums before Grant McLennan died on 6 May 2006, of a heart attack. In May 2001 "Cattle and Cane", from The Go-Between's Before Hollywood (1983) was selected by Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA) as one of the Top 30 Australian songs of all time. In 2008, 16 Lovers Lane (1988) was highlighted on Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) TV's The Great Australian Albums series as a classic example of 1980s rock music. Forster began writing as a music critic in 2005 for national current affairs magazine The Monthly and a columnist for its sister publication The Saturday Paper in 2014.

For his debut solo album, Danger in the Past, Forster was backed on vocals by Karin Bäumler of German pop group, Baby You Know. In the early 1990s Forster and Bäumler married, the couple has two children.

A portrait of Forster, by the artist known as what, won the 2019 Doug Moran National Portrait Prize.[1]

Biography

[edit]

Robert Derwent Garth Forster was born on 29 June 1957 and grew up in Brisbane.[2][3] His father was a fitter and turner, and his mother taught physical education.[4]: 77  He attended Brisbane Grammar School in Spring Hill, where he started to learn guitar and wrote poetry.[4]: 78–9  In 1975, he formed The Mosquitoes with Stephen Hollingsworth and the following year he was in The Godots with Malcolm Kelly.[5] In 1976 Forster met Grant McLennan in drama classes in his second year at the University of Queensland, they were both fans of Bob Dylan and the New York music scene.[3][4]: 79–80  Forster enjoyed music by Mott the Hoople, Patti Smith, Ry Cooder, and The Velvet Underground.[6] In December 1977, the pair co-founded an indie rock group, The Go-Betweens, with Forster on guitar and McLennan on bass guitar, and both as singer-songwriters.[7][8] Later Forster also provided keyboards and McLennan took up guitar.[8]

The Go-Betweens

[edit]

In May 1978 Forster's first recorded work was the group's debut single, "Lee Remick", released in September that year on the Able Label.[7][9] It was a paean to the Hollywood actress of the same name.[6] Forster later recalled "I didn't have a girlfriend or any sort of romantic side to my life ... I wanted to write a love song. But who was I in love with? No-one. I had to find someone and I found Lee Remick".[6] He also wrote the B-side, "Karen", as an ode to the university's library staff, "[t]here was kindness in the library, then you walk out of the library into the harsh real world".[6][10] Forster then wrote their second single, "People Say".[11] According to Australian musicologist, Ian McFarlane, both singles were "sparsely produced, poorly played yet passionately performed folksy, post-punk pop songs. They were sunny, catchy and hopelessly romantic, earning the band immediate local and international acclaim".[7]

In November 1979 The Go-Betweens relocated to London, they re-released their early material and followed with another single on the Scottish label Postcard Records entitled "I Need Two Heads" which was also written by Forster.[7][12] It peaked at No. 6 on the United Kingdom Independent Charts.[7] The group remained in UK for almost a year but ran out of money and needed a drummer, so they returned to Brisbane.[13] By November 1980 Lindy Morrison (ex-Xero) had joined the group on drums and backing vocals.[7][8][13] By 1981 Forster and Morrison were also lovers, she later remembered "Robert never took part in any group discussions ... He would not stay in the house if there were other people present ... he and I would have cups of tea on the verandah and debate the place of politics in art".[6]

As a member of The Go-Betweens he contributed to all their studio albums, Send Me a Lullaby (February 1982), Before Hollywood (May 1983), Spring Hill Fair (September 1984), Liberty Belle and the Black Diamond Express (March 1986), Tallulah (June 1987) and 16 Lovers Lane (September 1988).[7][8] Forster and McLennan wrote most of the tracks for the band's albums and alternated lead vocal duties. By December 1989 the group disbanded; Forster and Morrison had separated as a couple earlier and Forster began his solo music career from 1990. Back in 1982, The Go-Betweens' Forster, McLennan and Morrison had recorded, "After the Fireworks", as a collaboration with The Birthday Party's Nick Cave on vocals, Mick Harvey on piano and Rowland S. Howard on guitar.[14][15] It was released that year as a single under the band name, Tuff Monks, on Au Go Go Records.[14]

The Go-Betweens breakup

[edit]

After the disbandment of The Go-Betweens, Forster relocated to Germany in 1990 and recorded his debut solo album, Danger in the Past, in Berlin.[16][17] It was produced by Harvey (Anita Lane) and issued on Beggars Banquet Records.[5][16] Allmusic's Ned Raggett found the album showed "literate, understated rock & roll" with his "gently cracked, high vocals" and "setting and maintaining a variety of moods from sudden energy to soft rumination".[17] In November he issued a single, "Baby Stones", from the album.[16] Also that year he provided guitar for German pop group Baby You Know's debut album, To Live Is to Fly.[5][18] Karin Bäumler featured on violin and vocals on To Live Is to Fly.[18] Bäumler also provided vocals for Forster's Danger in the Past.[17] Forster and Bäumler married in the early 1990s.[6][19]

By 1993 Forster had returned to Brisbane to record his second solo album, Calling from a Country Phone, at Sunshine Studios with members of local pop group, Custard.[5][16] It was produced by Forster and issued on Shock Records and Beggars Banquet in June.[5][16] A single, "Drop", had appeared a month ahead of the album.[16] For touring he formed Robert Forster's Silver Backwash with David McCormack on guitar, Robert Moore on bass guitar and Glenn Thompson on drums.[5][16] Although described as a "bustling country-pop" album by McFarlane,[16] according to Allmusic's Greg Adams its "folk-rock sound ... recalls Felt's Me and a Monkey on the Moon more than ... Nashville".[20] Forster also produced his third solo album, I Had a New York Girlfriend, which is a collection of cover versions recorded in Melbourne in 1994.[5][16] Raggett felt it was "an interesting and at times defiantly anti-hip visit through a surprising, entertaining selection of songs".[21]

By 1995 Forster had formed a three-piece group, Warm Nights, with Thompson and Adele Pickvance on bass guitar.[22] Late that year Forster and McLennan performed together in Brisbane and the duo were accompanied by Pickvance and Thompson.[22] Forster denied it was a tribute show: "anyone that did the Australian Go-Betweens Show would be tighter ... people that start those [tribute] bands generally play a lot tighter than the bands that they're honouring or copying or whatever".[22] In May the following year the same line-up performed at Les Inrockuptibles's 10th anniversary celebration in Paris.[23]

Forster's next solo album, Warm Nights, was recorded in London in 1996 and produced by Edwyn Collins (The Proclaimers, Vic Godard, A House) – Collins also provided guitar alongside a five-member brass section.[5][16][24] The rhythm section were Pickvance and Thompson. It appeared in September that year and McFarlane described it as "a laid-back collection of summery pop".[16] Raggett found it is "a touch less obviously country-pitched in comparison – more of the deft, understated rock/pop".[24] The album's lead single, "Cryin' Love", included a music video which McFarlane states is "one of the most entertaining film clips for the year".[16] In mid-1997 Forster and McLennan briefly reformed The Go-Betweens for a series of gigs in the UK and Ireland.[16][25]

The Go-Betweens reformation

[edit]

In 2000, after both Forster and McLennan had each recorded four solo albums, The Go-Betweens reformed with Pickvance, to create a new studio album, The Friends of Rachel Worth, they were assisted by Janet Weiss (Sleater-Kinney, Quasi) on drums and backing vocals and Sam Coomes (Quasi) on keyboards.[5][13][26] It was issued in September with Bäumler credited for string arrangements, and production duties shared by Coomes, Forster, McLennan and Weiss.[27] Allmusic's Hal Horowitz praised their "[p]oetic, languid, spoken/sung vocals similar to Lou Reed weave between lovely melodies whose appeal unfolds with repeated listens";[26] however it "sounds more like a combination of two solo albums rather than one from a cohesive unit".[26] The Village Voice's critic, Robert Christgau, described them as "rather than lyric poets, as I once thought, Forster and McLennan are better conceived as short-story writers, with the concreteness and forward motion of voices and music compensating for imagistic technique and low word count".[28] He declared that Forster's tracks "are the catchiest and most fetching tracks on the album, taking up surfing dreams, a fond and funny envoi to Patti Smith, and a life-swapping fable that when you think about it may be a love song after all".[28]

Forster is shown in upper half, left profile. He is standing, singing into a microphone and playing an electric guitar. Some musical equipment is visible behind him. His shirt is light coloured and he wears dark pants.
Forster performing at All Tomorrow's Parties, Mt Buller, Victoria, on 10 January 2009.

The Go-Betweens line-up of Forster, McLennan, Pickvance and Thompson (he had rejoined in 2001) issued two more studio albums, Bright Yellow Bright Orange (2003) and Oceans Apart (2005),[13] Allmusic's Stewart Mason described Forster as having "a knack for crafty pop songs along with the brooding ballads he contributed to the Go-Betweens' albums, and his solo career has shown a healthy mix of the two styles".[29] Grant McLennan died on 6 May 2006 of a heart attack, aged 48.[30][31]

Solo career

[edit]
Robert Forster performing at King George, Cologne (Germany), on 10 November 2017.
Robert Forster performing at King George, Cologne (Germany), on 10 November 2017.

In July 2007, Forster resumed his solo music career with live performances over four nights at the Queensland Music Festival. He picked three songs co-written with McLennan, including "Demon Days", which is the last track the pair wrote together, and recorded them alongside his own material for his first solo album in 11 years, The Evangelist, which was released on 26 April 2008 through Yep Roc Records.[13][32] It had been recorded with Pickvance and Thompson at Good Luck Studios, London, from September to November 2007 (except a track, "A Place to Hide Away"). Allmusic's Thom Jurek noted that Forster "has never been this direct before, so unadorned and honest, and yes, vulnerable without the mask of his gift to weave a story, even in first person, and make himself seem a narrator".[33]

Music journalism

[edit]

Since May 2005, Forster has had a parallel career as a music critic, he began writing for the Australian magazine, The Monthly and its sister publication The Saturday Paper in 2014.[34] Previously he had virtually no print experience, with only a column on hair care for a fanzine in the 1980s to his credit.[35] He was asked by then-editor of The Monthly, Christian Ryan, to write a regular column.[34] Forster later recalled "[m]usic journalism was something that always interested me but only as a reader. I thought about music and I would almost run ideas through my head when I listened to a record or saw a concert, but I never put any of thoughts to paper".[34] On 25 October 2006 Forster won the Pascall Prize for Critical Writing for his columns.[36] In 2009 he collated some of his critiques, written from 2005 to 2009, on international artists The Rolling Stones, Nana Mouskouri, Neil Diamond and Cat Power as well as Australian acts Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, Mark Seymour and Paul Kelly.[37] It was published as The 10 Rules of Rock and Roll: Collected Music Writings 2005–09 on Black Inc books.[37]

Musical legacy

[edit]

In May 2001, "Cattle and Cane", co-written by Forster and McLennan,[38] from The Go-Between's Before Hollywood (1983), was selected by Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA) as one of the Top 30 Australian songs of all time.[39] In 2008, 16 Lovers Lane (1988) was highlighted on Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) TV's The Great Australian Albums series as a classic example of 1980s rock music.[40] On 25 June 2010, the Brisbane City Council celebrated the opening of the Go Between Bridge with a concert featuring performances by Forster, Angus & Julia Stone, Josh Pyke and Bob Evans.[41] In May 2013 Forster performed at Primera Persona, Barcelona, he was backed by local indie musicians, Part Company.[42] He described his writing to Time Out Barcelona's Marta Salicrú "[m]y work is very autobiographical – I'm a singer-songwriter ... My songs reflect on and talk about my life and how I've lived it. But I'm not one of those lyricists who explains everything. My stories aren't obvious. There are some singer-songwriters who say too much".[42] His repertoire included new songs, which he hoped to record.[42]

Bibliography

[edit]
Articles
  • "The Exford Dregs," The Monthly, 11, April 2006
  • "A True Hipster," The Monthly, 14, July 2006
  • "Modern Times and Times Before That," The Monthly, 17, October 2006
  • "The Coronation of Normie Rowe," Meanjin, volume 65, number 3, 2006, pp. 48–52.
  • "Love Goes to a Building on Fire," The Monthly, 21, March 2007, pp. 58–60.
  • Forster, Robert (April 2009). "Thoughts in the middle of a career". The Monthly. 44: 62–64. Retrieved 31 October 2014. Reviews Paul Kelly's Songs from the South and Songs from the South Volume 2.
Books

Discography

[edit]

Solo albums

[edit]
Title Details
Danger in the Past
  • Released: 1990
  • Label: Beggars Banquet
  • Format: CD, cassette
Calling from a Country Phone
  • Released: 1993
  • Label: Beggars Banquet
  • Format: CD, cassette
I Had a New York Girlfriend
  • Released: 1994
  • Label: Beggars Banquet
  • Format: CD, cassette
  • Reissued in 2024 as Beautiful Hearts on Needle Mythology[44]
Warm Nights
  • Released: 1996
  • Label: Beggars Banquet
  • Format: CD, LP
The Evangelist
  • Released: 2008
  • Label: Capitol
  • Format: CD, LP, digital
Songs to Play
  • Released: 2015
  • Label: Tapete
  • Format: CD, LP, digital
Inferno
  • Released: 2019
  • Label: Tapete
  • Format: CD, LP, digital
The Candle and the Flame
  • Released: 3 February 2023[45]
  • Label: EMI Music Australia
  • Format: CD, digital

Compilation albums

[edit]
Title Details
Intermission: The Best of the Solo Recordings 1990-1997
(with Grant McLennan)
  • Released: 2007
  • Label: Beggars Banquet / EMI
  • Format: CD, Cassette

Other appearances

[edit]

With Go-Betweens

[edit]

Filmography

[edit]

Awards

[edit]

ARIA Music Awards

[edit]

The ARIA Music Awards is an annual awards ceremony held by the Australian Recording Industry Association. They commenced in 1987.

Year Nominee / work Award Result
2008 The Evangelist Best Adult Contemporary Album Nominated
2016 Songs to Play Best Adult Contemporary Album Nominated

Queensland Music Awards

[edit]

The Queensland Music Awards (previously known as Q Song Awards) are annual awards celebrating Queensland, Australia's brightest emerging artists and established legends. They commenced in 2006.[46]

Year Nominee / work Award Result (wins only)
2008[47] "From Ghost Town" Published song of the Year Won

References

[edit]

Citations

[edit]
  1. ^ Convery, Stephanie (29 October 2019). "Doug Moran prize 2019: mysterious artist 'What' wins $150,000 for Robert Forster portrait". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 30 October 2019.
  2. ^ "'Baby Stones' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Retrieved 19 June 2013.[permanent dead link‍]
  3. ^ a b "Biography". Robert Forster Official Website. Retrieved 19 June 2013.
  4. ^ a b c Stafford, Andrew (2006). Pig City: From The Saints to Savage Garden (2nd ed.). Brisbane: University of Queensland Press. pp. 1, 77–93, 115, 141–3, 207, 238, 241, 246, 323–324, 344, 348, 356. ISBN 978-0-702-23561-0.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i Holmgren, Magnus. "Robert Forster". Australian Rock Database. Passagen (Magnus Holmgren). Archived from the original on 5 August 2011. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  6. ^ a b c d e f Dalton, Bruce (14 July 2007). "Me and My Shadow". The Courier-Mail. Queensland Newspapers (News Corporation). p. 1. Retrieved 19 June 2013.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g McFarlane 'The Go-Betweens' entry. Archived from the original on 29 August 2004. Retrieved 19 June 2013.
  8. ^ a b c d Holmgren, Magnus; Warnqvist, Stefan. "The Go-Betweens". Australian Rock Database. Passagen (Magnus Holmgren). Archived from the original on 21 September 2012. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  9. ^ "'Lee Remick' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Retrieved 20 June 2013.[permanent dead link‍]
  10. ^ "'Karen' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Retrieved 20 June 2013.[permanent dead link‍]
  11. ^ "'People Say' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Retrieved 20 June 2013.[permanent dead link‍]
  12. ^ "'I Need Two Heads' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Retrieved 20 June 2013.[permanent dead link‍]
  13. ^ a b c d e Nimmervoll, Ed. "Go-Betweens". Howlspace. White Room Electronic Publishing Pty Ltd. Archived from the original on 31 December 2012. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  14. ^ a b Nichols, (2003), 'Tuff Monks' entries pp. 93, 114–115.
  15. ^ McFarlane 'The Birthday Party' entry. Archived from the original Archived 9 August 2004 at the Wayback Machine on 9 August 2004. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  16. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m McFarlane 'Robert Forster' entry. Archived from the original on 28 August 2004. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  17. ^ a b c Raggett, Ned. "Danger in the Past – Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  18. ^ a b "To Live Is to Fly – Baby You Know". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  19. ^ Blackman, Guy (10 July 2005). "Happy Families". The Age. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  20. ^ Adams, Greg. "Calling from a Country Phone – Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  21. ^ Raggett, Ned. "I Had a New York Girlfriend – Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  22. ^ a b c McKenzie, Simon (1995). "The Australian Go-Betweens Show: Forster Interview". Time Off. Street Press Australia. The Go-Betweens Archive. Archived from the original on 28 April 2012. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  23. ^ Fevret, Christian (22 May 1996). "The Go-Betweens – Les destins amis". Les Inrockuptibles. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  24. ^ a b Raggett, Ned. "Warm Nights – Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  25. ^ Lappin, Tom (1 June 1997). "Part Company – Again". The Go-Betweens Archive. Archived from the original on 28 April 2012. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  26. ^ a b c Horowitz, Hal. "The Friends of Rachel Worth – The Go-Betweens". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  27. ^ "The Friends of Rachel Worth – The Go-Betweens: Credits". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  28. ^ a b Christgau, Robert (17 October 2000). "A Long Short Story: The Go-Betweens". The Village Voice. Josh Fromson. Robert Christgau. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  29. ^ Mason, Stewart. "Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 20 June 2013.
  30. ^ Christgau, Robert (9 May 2006). "Grant McLennan, 1957–2006". The Village Voice. Village Voice Media (Josh Fromson). p. 1. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  31. ^ Mengel, Noel (8 May 2006). "Band founder dead at 48". The Courier Mail. Retrieved 8 May 2006.[dead link‍]
  32. ^ "Yep Roc Records – Artist Info". 4 June 2008.
  33. ^ Jurek, Thom. "The Evangelist – Robert Forster". Allmusic (Rovi Corporation). Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  34. ^ a b c Black Inc (28 October 2009). "An Interview with Robert Forster, Author of The 10 Rules of Rock and Roll". The Inc. Blot. Black Inc (Morry Schwartz). Retrieved 22 June 2013.
  35. ^ Zuel, Bernard (25 October 2006). "Praise for a pencil pusher". The Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 4 May 2008.
  36. ^ Sheddon, Iain (26 October 2006). "Prize for Go-Between at a critical point in his career". The Australian. News Limited. Archived from the original on 14 November 2007. Retrieved 10 April 2007.
  37. ^ a b c "The 10 rules of rock and roll : collected music writings 2005–09 / Robert Forster". National Library of Australia. Retrieved 21 June 2013. This is a roller-coaster ride through the history and present of popular music, from The Rolling Stones, Nana Mouskouri and Neil Diamond to Cat Power, Antony and the Johnsons and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, and covering such Australian mainstays as Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, Mark Seymour, Paul Kelly and the Countdown spectacular.
  38. ^ "'Cattle and Cane' at APRA search engine". Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Archived from the original on 30 August 2009. Retrieved 22 June 2013.
  39. ^ Kruger, Debbie (2 May 2001). "The songs that resonate through the years" (PDF). Australasian Performing Right Association (APRA). Archived from the original (PDF) on 30 October 2008. Retrieved 22 June 2013.
  40. ^ "SBS takes Great Australian Albums to MIPCOM 08". Special Broadcasting Service (SBS). 8 October 2008. Archived from the original (PDF) on 26 August 2012. Retrieved 22 June 2013.
  41. ^ "The Go Between Bridge concert". Secret Sounds?. National Library of Australia. 2010. Retrieved 21 June 2013. Poster promoting the concert to celebrate the opening of the Go Between bridge in Brisbane, Queensland, Friday, June 25, 2010. The poster includes a colour image of a vinyl record behind an arch shape, representing the bridge. Text includes details of the event. The performers featured in the concert include Angus & Julia Stone, Robert Forster, Josh Pyke and Bob Evans.
  42. ^ a b c Salicrú, Marta (3 May 2013). "Robert Forster performs in Primera Persona". Time Out Barcelona. Time Out. ISSN 1711-7976. Retrieved 22 June 2013.
  43. ^ "The Go-Betweens : history, lyric, songbook : the songs of Robert Forster and Grant McLennan". National Library of Australia. Retrieved 21 June 2013.
  44. ^ "Robert Forster Beautiful Hearts". Needlemythology.com. Retrieved 29 June 2024.
  45. ^ "The Candle and the Flame". JB Hi-Fi. Retrieved 19 November 2022.
  46. ^ "About the Queensland Music Awards". Queensland Music Awards. Retrieved 21 March 2021.
  47. ^ "Past Winners 2008". Queensland Music Awards. Retrieved 25 March 2021.

Sources

[edit]
General
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Robert_Forster_(musician)&oldid=1231643264"