Nationalism in Antiquity

Some scholars of nationalism support the existence of nationalism in antiquity. This school of thought differs from modernism, the predominant school of thought on nationalism, which suggests that nationalism developed largely after the late 18th century and the French Revolution.^[1]^[2] Theories on the existence of nationalism in antiquity belong to the primordialist (or perennialist) paradigm.

Judeo-Christian roots

For many non-modernists, nations have emerged from the Judeo-Christian tradition. John Alexander Armstrong was one of the first modern scholars to argue that nations have pre-modern roots and that their formation was helped by religious institutions locally. However, Armstrong acknowledges "persistent group identity did not ordinarily constitute the overriding legitimisation of polity formation", unlike contemporary nationalism, which presupposes the "right of individuals to [...] establish territorial political structures corresponding to their consciousness of group identity".^[3]

Tom Garvin wrote that "something strangely like modern nationalism is documented for many peoples in medieval times and in classical times as well," citing the ancient Jews, the classical Greeks and the Gaulish and British Celts as examples.^[4]^{[full citation needed]} The Great Jewish Revolt against Roman rule (66–73 CE) is often cited by scholars as a prominent example of ancient Jewish nationalism.^[5] Adrian Hastings argued that Jews are the "true proto-nation", that through the model of ancient Israel found in the Hebrew Bible, provided the world with the original concept of nationhood which later influenced Christian nations.^[6]

Anthony D. Smith wrote that the Jews of the late Second Temple period provide "a closer approximation to the ideal type of the nation [...] than perhaps anywhere else in the ancient world", adding that this observation "must make us wary of pronouncing too readily against the possibility of the nation, and even a form of religious nationalism, before the onset of modernity".^[7] Other scholars, such as Doron Mendels, Steven Grosby, and Aviel Roshwald, also argue for the rise of a kind of nationalism among ancient Jews. David M. Goodblatt believes that Jewish nationalism appears in the Second Temple period (5th–1st century BC).^[8]

Azar Gat claims a Jewish nation has existed since antiquity and that the creation of imagined communities was made possible not only by secularisation and the rise of print capitalism in modern era, but could also be produced earlier by the spoken word and via religious rituals.^[9] Gat does not agree with the modernist view that pre-modern multi-ethnic empires were ruled by an elite indifferent to the ethnic composition of its subjects. In fact, almost all of the empires were based on a dominant ethnic core, while most ethnic communities were too small and weak to have their own independent state.^[10]

Criticisms

George Vasilev finds scholarly equivalence between Ancient Israel and contemporary nationalism guilty of perpetuating methodological nationalism, naturalising supposedly hereditary governing institutions back to ancient times. Government bureaucracy in antiquity did not "aim to recreate culturally populations in the image of an ethnic or national ideal" and continuity drawn between the past and present by scholars like Grosby and Roshwald, he argues, is "spurious because the ancient and medieval political actors [...] were not functional equivalents of contemporary states".^[11] Vasilev continues:

sovereigns did not rule in the name of 'the people', but rather in the name of religion or civilisation. The empires, dynastic kingdoms, city-states and tribal confederacies that went to war did so over the balance of power between them or to bring a desired successor to the throne, but not to achieve ethnic and national aggrandisement.^[12]

References

^ Smith, Anthony D. (2007). Nationalism (2nd ed.). Cambridge: polity. ISBN 978-0-7456-5128-6.
^ Schwyzer, Philip (2016-06-02). "Nationalism in the Renaissance". Oxford Handbooks Online. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199935338.013.70. ISBN 978-0-19-993533-8. Retrieved 2020-06-12.
^ Armstrong, John Alexander (1982). Nations Before Nationalism. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press. p. 4.
^ Tom Garvin, “Ethnic Markers, Modern Nationalisms, and the Nightmare of History,” in Kruger, ed., ¨ Ethnicity and Nationalism, p. 67.
^ Goodblatt, David, ed. (2006), "Theoretical Considerations: Nationalism and Ethnicity in Antiquity", Elements of Ancient Jewish Nationalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 3, 11–13, doi:10.1017/cbo9780511499067.002, ISBN 978-0-521-86202-8, retrieved 2024-06-14
^ Hastings, Adrian (1997). The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 186–187. ISBN 0-521-59391-3.
^ Smith, Anthony D. (1993). National Identity. Ethnonationalism in comparative perspective (Reprint ed.). Reno Las Vegas: University of Nevada Press. pp. 48–50. ISBN 978-0-87417-204-1.
^ Weitzman, Steven (2008). "On the Political Relevance of Antiquity: A Response to David Goodblatt's Elements of Ancient Jewish Nationalism". Jewish Social Studies. 14 (3): 165–172. ISSN 0021-6704. JSTOR 40207028.
^ Storm, Eric (2018). "A New Dawn in Nationalism Studies? Some Fresh Incentives to Overcome Historiographical Nationalism". European History Quarterly. 48 (1): 113–129. doi:10.1177/0265691417741830. ISSN 0265-6914. PMC 6195252. PMID 30443098.
^ Gat, Azar; Yakobson, Alexander (2013). Nations: The Long History and Deep Roots of Political Ethnicity and Nationalism. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-107-00785-7.
^ Vasilev, George (2019). "Methodological nationalism and the politics of history-writing: how imaginary scholarship perpetuates the nation". Nations and Nationalism. 25 (2): 499–522. doi:10.1111/nana.12432., p.509
^ Vasilev, George (2019). "Methodological nationalism and the politics of history-writing: how imaginary scholarship perpetuates the nation". Nations and Nationalism. 25 (2): 499–522. doi:10.1111/nana.12432., p.509-510

[Anthony_Smith-1] Smith, Anthony D. (2007). Nationalism (2nd ed.). Cambridge: polity. ISBN 978-0-7456-5128-6.

[OxfordHB-2] Schwyzer, Philip (2016-06-02). "Nationalism in the Renaissance". Oxford Handbooks Online. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199935338.013.70. ISBN 978-0-19-993533-8. Retrieved 2020-06-12.

[3] Armstrong, John Alexander (1982). Nations Before Nationalism. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press. p. 4.

[4] Tom Garvin, “Ethnic Markers, Modern Nationalisms, and the Nightmare of History,” in Kruger, ed., ¨ Ethnicity and Nationalism, p. 67.

[5] Goodblatt, David, ed. (2006), "Theoretical Considerations: Nationalism and Ethnicity in Antiquity", Elements of Ancient Jewish Nationalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 3, 11–13, doi:10.1017/cbo9780511499067.002, ISBN 978-0-521-86202-8, retrieved 2024-06-14

[6] Hastings, Adrian (1997). The Construction of Nationhood: Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 186–187. ISBN 0-521-59391-3.

[7] Smith, Anthony D. (1993). National Identity. Ethnonationalism in comparative perspective (Reprint ed.). Reno Las Vegas: University of Nevada Press. pp. 48–50. ISBN 978-0-87417-204-1.

[8] Weitzman, Steven (2008). "On the Political Relevance of Antiquity: A Response to David Goodblatt's Elements of Ancient Jewish Nationalism". Jewish Social Studies. 14 (3): 165–172. ISSN 0021-6704. JSTOR 40207028.

[9] Storm, Eric (2018). "A New Dawn in Nationalism Studies? Some Fresh Incentives to Overcome Historiographical Nationalism". European History Quarterly. 48 (1): 113–129. doi:10.1177/0265691417741830. ISSN 0265-6914. PMC 6195252. PMID 30443098.

[10] Gat, Azar; Yakobson, Alexander (2013). Nations: The Long History and Deep Roots of Political Ethnicity and Nationalism. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-107-00785-7.

[11] Vasilev, George (2019). "Methodological nationalism and the politics of history-writing: how imaginary scholarship perpetuates the nation". Nations and Nationalism. 25 (2): 499–522. doi:10.1111/nana.12432., p.509

[12] Vasilev, George (2019). "Methodological nationalism and the politics of history-writing: how imaginary scholarship perpetuates the nation". Nations and Nationalism. 25 (2): 499–522. doi:10.1111/nana.12432., p.509-510

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

Judeo-Christian roots

Criticisms

See also

References