The Political Compass is a website soliciting responses to a set of 62 propositions in order to rate political ideology in a spectrum with two axes: one about economic policy (left–right) and another about social policy (authoritarian–libertarian).[1]
 | |
Type of site | Political self-test, political blog |
|---|---|
| Available in | English, Bulgarian, Czech, German, Spanish, French, Italian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Russian, Turkish |
| Created by | Wayne Brittenden[1] |
| Editor | Wayne Brittenden[1] |
| URL | politicalcompass |
| Commercial | No |
| Registration | No |
| Launched | 20 December 2000[2] |
| Current status | Active |
History
editThe Political Compass website was established by political journalist Wayne Brittenden.[3]
On July 2, 2001, an early version of the website appeared on the web server of One World Action.[4] The creators of The Political Compass acknowledged intellectual influences such as Wilhelm Reich and Theodor Adorno for their contributions to the field.[4]
Political model
edit
The underlying theory of the political model used by The Political Compass is that political ideology may be better measured along two separate, independent axes. The economic (left–right) axis measures one's opinion of how the economy should be run.[1] In economic terms, the political left is defined as the desire for the economy to be run by a cooperative collective agency, which can mean a sovereign state but also a network of communes, while the political right is defined as the desire for the economy to be left to the devices of competing individuals and organizations.[6] The test's propositions lead the individual undertaking the test to wonder about things like "Is military action that defies international law sometimes justified?", "Should mothers have demanding careers?", "If economic globalisation is inevitable, should it primarily serve humanity or multinational corporates?"[7]
The other axis (authoritarian–libertarian) measures one's political opinions in a social sense, regarding the amount of personal freedom that one would allow. Libertarianism is defined as the belief that personal freedom should be maximised, while authoritarianism is defined as the belief that authority should be obeyed. This makes it possible to divide people into four, colour marked quadrants: authoritarian left (red in the top left), authoritarian right (blue in the top right), libertarian right (yellow or purple in the bottom right), and libertarian left (green in the bottom left). The makers of the Political Compass say that the quadrants "are not separate categories, but regions on a continuum".[8]
Reception
editSeveral prominent individuals in academia and media have voiced criticisms of the Political Compass test.
The academic William Clifton van der Linden says that the Political Compass uses a method called dimensionality reduction to try to make its results more dependable. According to him, dependable results is practice that is "roundly criticized" by scholars because it fails to give accurate results. Van der Linden uses scholarly sources to support his analysis of the reliability of Voter Advice Applications, such as the Political Compass. These sources include research by Gemenis and Kostas (2013) from Acta Politica, Otjes and Louwerse (2014) from Electoral Studies, and Germann, Mendez, Wheatley, and Serdült (2015) from Acta Politica.[9]
Daniel J. Mitchell, an economist for Foundation for Economic Education, critiques the Political Compass Test for its placement of historical figures and politicians, such as Adolf Hitler being classified on the left side of the horizontal axis and Margaret Thatcher's proximity to Joseph Stalin and Hitler on the vertical axis. He also expresses disappointment with his own placement, feeling he should have scored stronger on the right for economic issues and more libertarian on social issues. Mitchell disagrees with the test's placement of well-known individuals, such as Milton Friedman being rated as less libertarian on economics and Benito Mussolini being placed as far right, while Mitchell says that he opposed capitalism. He finds Hillary Clinton's classification as right-leaning on economic policy and Donald Trump being ranked as more authoritarian than Robert Mugabe, Mao Zedong, and Fidel Castro to be nonsensical.[10]
Encyclopedia Britannica has highlighted that the scientific basis for these models has frequently been questioned. Specifically, the Political Compass has faced criticism for allegedly propagating libertarian ideas.[11]
Author Brian Patrick Michell takes issue with the positioning of ideologies and the framing of economic freedom on the horizontal axis. Michell criticizes the political compass for placing American libertarians on the far right of the economic freedom scale, suggesting it implies economic freedom is solely linked with right-wing ideology. He also questions the accuracy of the compass's representation of ideologies, highlighting the possibility of communal fascism in the upper left and neoliberal fascism in the upper right, which he believes oversimplifies complex political ideologies.[12]
British journalist Tom Utley criticizes the phrasing of some questions on the test, finding them irritating and difficult to answer accurately. He highlights the complexity of political views and the inadequacy of condensing them into simplistic labels. He cites an example of that he identifies as libertarian Right on the political compass, placing him in a similar position to Charles Kennedy, despite their ideological differences.[13]
J. C. Lester PhD alumnus of the London School of Economics, writing for the Journal of Social Philosophy in 1996, opined that the compass is a positive tool that provides clarity in understanding political positions, particularly in navigating the complexities of modern ideological divisions. Lester described the compass as more nuanced than the traditional left-right spectrum, and specifically praising the compass for its ability to clarify the placement of libertarianism, which he argues is often misunderstood or ambiguously positioned within political discourse.[14]
Similar models
editSeveral other multi-axis models of the political spectrum exist, sharing similarities with The Political Compass. One notable example is the Nolan Chart, devised by American libertarian David Nolan. Additionally, comparable charts were presented in Albert Meltzer and Stuart Christie's "The Floodgates of Anarchy" in 1970,[15] and in the Rampart Journal of Individualist Thought by Maurice C. Bryson and William R. McDill in 1968.[16]
r/PoliticalCompassMemes is a subreddit dedicated to humorous criticism of ideologies, where users identify their ideologies with user flairs based on The Political Compass.[17]: 8 In June 2022, the subreddit was used in a study by researchers at Monash University to predict users' political ideologies based on their digital footprints.[17]: 1
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ a b c d LiCalzi O'Connell, Pamela (4 December 2003). "Online Diary". The New York Times. Retrieved 14 July 2023.
- ^ "PoliticalCompass.org – WHOIS, DNS, & Domain Info – DomainTools". WHOIS. Retrieved 25 December 2020.
- ^ O'Connell, Pamela LiCalzi (4 December 2003). "ONLINE DIARY". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 12 November 2012. Retrieved 4 February 2024.
- ^ a b Mitchell, Brian Patrick (2007). Eight Ways to Run the Country. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 143. ISBN 978-0-275-99358-0.
- ^ "The Political Compass – Crowd Chart". PoliticalCompass.org. 11 October 2013. Retrieved 1 November 2013.
- ^ "The Political Compass – Frequently Asked Questions – 16". PoliticalCompass.org. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- ^ Dasgupta, Sucheta (27 August 2022). "Welcome to the political compass' third dimension". Deccan Chronicle. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- ^ "The Political Compass – Frequently Asked Questions – 20". PoliticalCompass.org. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- ^ Van der Linden, W. C. (2019). Disrupting Democracy? Voting Advice Applications and political participation in the Digital Age (Doctoral dissertation, University of Toronto). Retrieved from https://tspace.library.utoronto.ca/bitstream/1807/95953/3/van_der_Linden_William_C_201906_PhD_thesis.pdf (p. 5).
- ^ Daniel J. Mitchell Foundation for Economic Education. (2018, May 18). The Political Compass Test. Retrieved March 22, 2024, from https://fee.org/articles/the-political-compass-test/
- ^ "Political spectrum | Definition, Chart, Examples, & Left Versus Right | Britannica". www.britannica.com. 19 March 2024. Retrieved 22 March 2024.
- ^ Michell 2011, p. 6.
- ^ Utley, Tom (6 June 2001). "I'm v. Right-wing, says the BBC, but it's not that simple". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 14 July 2023.
A lot of the questions in the test are very irritatingly phrased and impossible to answer properly, with only these four options available: 'strongly agree', 'agree', 'disagree' and 'strongly disagree.'
- ^ Lester, J. C. (1996, September). The political compass (and why libertarianism is not right-wing). Journal of Social Philosophy, 27, 176-186. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9833.1996.tb00245.x
- ^ Christie, Stuart; Meltzer, Albert (1970). "Party Lines and Politics". The Floodgates of Anarchy. Binghamton, New York: PM Press. ISBN 0-900707-03-8. Retrieved 14 July 2023 – via The Anarchist Library.
- ^ Bryson, Maurice C.; McDil, William R. (Summer 1968). "The Political Spectrum: A Bi-Dimensional Approach" (PDF). Rampart Journal of Individualist Thought. 4 (2). Santa Ana, California: Rampart College: 19–26. Retrieved 14 July 2023 – via Mises Institute.
- ^ a b Anantharama, Nandini; Angus, Simon D.; Kitchener, Michael; Raschky, Paul A. (2022). "Predicting Political Ideology from Digital Footprints". arXiv:2206.00397 [econ.GN].
External links
edit