Wikipedia

Islamic views on prisoners of war

Islamic views on prisoners of war encompass teachings from the Qur'an and hadith as well as later regulations developed in Islamic jurisprudence.

The historical legal principles governing the treatment of prisoners of war, in shar'iah, Islamic law, (in the traditional madhabs schools of Islamic jurisprudence), was then a significant improvement[citation needed] over the pre-existing norms of society during Muhammad's time (see Early reforms under Islam). Men, women, and children may all be taken as prisoners of war under traditional interpretations of Islamic law. Generally, a prisoner of war could be, at the discretion of the military leader, freed, ransomed, exchanged for Muslim prisoners, or kept in bondage.[1] In earlier times, the ransom sometimes took an educational dimension, where a literate prisoner of war could secure his or her freedom by teaching ten Muslims to read and write.[2][3] Some Muslim scholars hold that a prisoner may not be ransomed for gold or silver, but may be exchanged for Muslim prisoners.[4]

Primary sources

edit

Qur'an

edit

The Qur'an explicitly allows Muslims to take prisoners during war (47:4).[5] There is no verse in the Qur'an permitting enslavement of prisoners (but see section below on Islamic jurisprudence).[6]

Al-Qardawi, an Egyptian Muslim scholar born in 1926, adds in light of the verses below (4:75-76), that the Islamic state should go to war to rescue non-Muslim minorities if they require help of the state and if the Islamic state is able to rescue them:

Would not you fight in the way of God for al-mustad‛afīn (the oppressed socially weak Muslims) from men, women and children who pray: Our Lord! Take us from this city of the oppressive people and appoint for us from Your side a guardian and appoint for us from Your side a protector. Those who have believed fight in the way of God and those who disbelieve fight in the way of Satan, so fight the allies of Satan; surely the plot of Satan is weak. -Quran 4:75-76[7]

Muhammad's life

edit

Many of the Islamic rules regarding prisoners of war ("POWs") come in the aftermath of the Battle of Badr, in which Muslims captured 43[7]-70 enemy combatants.[5] At the time, Muslims didn't have rules to deal with POWs.[5] Muhammad ordered the prisoners be accommodated in the Prophet's Mosque or in houses of his companions, as they were the safest places in Medina at the time.[5] Muhammad's famous instruction to his companions, with respect to the Badr POWs, was: "Observe good treatment towards the prisoners."[8][5][6]

One of the POWs, Abū ‛Azīz ibn ‛Umayr ibn Hāshim, later stated: "They (Muslim fighters) brought me from Badr, and when they ate their morning and evening meals they gave me the bread and ate the dates themselves in accordance with the orders that the apostle had given about us. If anyone had a morsel of bread he gave it to me. I felt ashamed and returned it to one of them but he returned it to me untouched."[7] Other Badr POWs reported being treated similarly.[5] Another POW, Al-Abbas, was undressed when brought into captivity; so Muhammad found a shirt for him to wear.[5] These practices would then set the precedent that POWs should be fed, clothed and sheltered adequately.[7]

During his life, Muhammad made it the responsibility of the Islamic government to provide food and clothing, on a reasonable basis, to captives, regardless of their religion.[additional citation(s) needed] If the prisoners were in the custody of a person, then the responsibility was on the individual.[9][additional citation(s) needed]

Historically, Muslims routinely captured large number of prisoners. Aside from those who converted to Islam, most were ransomed or enslaved.[10] Pasquier writes,

It was the custom to enslave prisoners of war and the Islamic state would have put itself at a grave disadvantage vis-a-vis its enemies had it not reciprocated to some extent. By guaranteeing them [male POWs] humane treatment, and various possibilities of subsequently releasing themselves, it ensured that a good number of combatants in the opposing armies preferred captivity at the hands of Muslims to death on the field of battle.[11]

According to accounts written by Muhammad's followers, after the Battle of Badr, some prisoners were executed for their earlier crimes in Mecca,[3] but the rest were given options: They could convert to Islam and thus win their freedom; they could pay ransom and win their freedom; they could teach 10 Muslims to read and write and thus win their freedom.[12] William Muir wrote of this period:

In pursuance of Mahomet's commands, the citizens of Medîna, and such of the Refugees as possessed houses, received the prisoners, and treated them with much consideration. “Blessings be on the men of Medina!” said one of these prisoners in later days; “they made us ride, while they themselves walked: they gave us wheaten bread to eat when there was little of it, contenting themselves with dates.”[13]

— William Muir, The Life of Mahomet

Executing prisoners

edit

During the conquest of Mecca, Muhammad ordered "‘slay no wounded person, pursue no fugitive, execute no prisoners."[5] Based on this many of his companions and jurists argued it was impermissible to execute POWs, yet those who disagreed pointed to three POWs Muhammad ordered be executed.[5] After the Battle of Badr, Muhammad sentenced Uqbah ibn Mu‛ay to death for his crimes against Muslims in Mecca. Abū ‛Azzah al- Jumaḥ, was also captured at Badr and set free on the condition that he would never fight against Muslims again. When he was captured fighting Muslims at the Battle of Uhud, he was executed. Abdullah B. Khatal was a Muslim who had killed a slave and then defected to the enemy; when Khatal was captured at the conquest of Mecca, he was executed.[5]

Other sources

edit

During his rule, Caliph Umar made it illegal to separate related prisoners of war from each other, after a captive complained to him for being separated from her daughter.[14][additional citation(s) needed]

These principles were also honoured during the Crusades, as exemplified by sultans such as Saladin[additional citation(s) needed] and al-Kamil. For example, after al-Kamil defeated the Franks during the Crusades, Oliverus Scholasticus praised the Islamic laws of war, commenting on how al-Kamil supplied the defeated Frankish army with food:[15][additional citation(s) needed]

Who could doubt that such goodness, friendship and charity come from God? Men whose parents, sons and daughters, brothers and sisters, had died in agony at our hands, whose lands we took, whom we drove naked from their homes, revived us with their own food when we were dying of hunger and showered us with kindness even when we were in their power."[16]

Islamic jurisprudence

edit

Upon capture, the prisoners must be guarded and not ill-treated.[17] Islamic law holds that the prisoners must be fed and clothed, either by the Islamic government or by the individual who has custody of the prisoner. This position is supported by the verse 76:8 of the Quran. The prisoners must be fed in a dignified manner, and must not be forced to beg for their subsistence.[18] Muhammad's early followers also considered it a principle to not separate prisoners from their relatives.[14]

And they give food in spite of love for it to the needy, the orphan, and the captive,

[Saying], "We feed you only for the countenance of Allah; no reward do we desire from you, nor thanks.

- Qur'an 76:8-9

After the fighting is over, prisoners are to be released freely, with some prospect of survival, or exchanged. The prisoners are not to be forced to convert to Islam.[19] The freeing or ransoming of prisoners by Muslims themselves is highly recommended as a charitable act.[17] The Qur'an also urges kindness to captives[20] and recommends, their liberation by purchase or manumission. The freeing of captives is recommended both for the expiation of sins[21] and as an act of simple benevolence.[22][23] However, the Quran also permits certain forms of punishments against certain captives, such as those who are deemed as waging war against Islam, disbelievers, adulterers and fornicators.[24]

Women and children

edit
See also: History of slavery in the Muslim world

According to the authentication of Muslim scholars, women and children prisoners of war cannot be killed under any circumstances, regardless of their faith,[10] but that they may be enslaved, freed or ransomed. Women who are neither freed nor ransomed by their people were to be kept in bondage and referred to as ma malakat aymanukum (slaves) to give them their rights to survive peacefully, and they could not be left astray.

Some modern Islamic extremist groups have taken slaves, including women and children. Abubakar Shekau, the leader of Boko Haram, a Nigerian extremist group, said in an interview, "I shall capture people and make them slaves" when claiming responsibility for the 2014 Chibok kidnapping.[25] Shekau has justified his actions by appealing to the Quran saying "[w]hat we are doing is an order from Allah, and all that we are doing is in the Book of Allah that we follow".[26] In October 2014, in its digital magazine Dabiq, ISIL explicitly claimed religious justification for enslaving Yazidi women. Specifically, ISIL argued that the Yazidi were idol worshipers and justified the sexual slavery of the captured non-muslim victims as a permissible manner of enjoying the spoils of war.[27][28][29][30][31][32] ISIL appealed to apocalyptic beliefs and "claimed justification by a Hadith that they interpret as portraying the revival of slavery as a precursor to the end of the world."[33][34][35][36][37][38]

Men

edit

One traditional opinion holds that executing prisoners of war is strictly forbidden; this is the most widely accepted view, and one upheld by the Hanafi madhab.[39]

However, the opinion of the Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali and Jafari madhabs is that adult male prisoners of war may be executed.[40] The decision for an execution is to be made by the Muslim leader. This opinion was also held by the Muslim judge, Sa'id bin Jubair (665-714 AD) and Abu Yusuf, a classical jurist from the Hanafi school of jurisprudence.[4] El Fadl argues that Muslim jurists adopted this position largely because it was consistent with the war practices of the Middle Ages.[39] Muhammad Hamidullah, while reminding that execution in such cases was exceptional and depending on many factors, further states that beheading was discouraged: "unanimity was reached among the Companions of the Prophet not to behead prisoners of war. In short, capital punishment for prisoners of war is only permissible in extreme cases of necessity and in the higher interests of the State."[41]

Most contemporary Muslim scholars prohibit altogether the killing of prisoners and hold that this was the policy practiced by Muhammad.[42][better source needed] The 20th-century Muslim scholar, Sayyid Abul Ala Maududi states that no prisoner should be "put to the sword" in accordance with a saying[which?] of Muhammad.[43]

Yusuf Ali, another 20th-century Muslim scholar, while commenting on verse 9:6, writes,

Even those the enemies of Islam, actively fighting against Islam, there may be individuals who may be in a position to require protection. Full asylum is to be given to them, and opportunities provided for hearing the Word of Allah...If they do not see their way to accept Islam, they will require double protection: (1) from the Islamic forces openly fighting against their people, and (2) from their own people, as they detached themselves from them. Both kinds of protection should be ensured for them, and they should be safely escorted to a place where they can be safe.[44]

Maududi further states that Islam forbids torturing, especially by fire, and quotes Muhammad as saying, "Punishment by fire does not behoove anyone except the Master of the Fire [God]."[45][43]

Quoting from the sources, Muhammad Munir, from the Department of Law of the International Islamic University, Pakistan, says that early religious authorities standing against the execution of POWs at all include 'Ali b. Abi Tãlib, Al-Hasan b. al-Hasan al-Basrl (d. 110/728), Hammãd b. Abi Sulaymän (d. 120/737), Muhammad b. Sirin (d. 110/728), Mujãhid b. Jabr (d. 103/721), 'Abd al-Mãlik b. 'Abd al-'Azïz b. Jurayj (d. 150/767), 'Atâ' b. Abi Rabãh (d. 114/732) and Abû 'Ubayd ibn Sallãm,[46] while later scholars favouring the same opinion include Muhammad b. Ahmad al-Qurtubl (d. 671/1272), who cites 47:4 in proposing the impossibility of execution if the letter of the Qur'an is followed.[47] Ibn Rushd (d. 863/1198) is also quoted: "[A] number of jurists did not permit executing the prisoners of war. Al-Hasan b. Muhammad al-Tamïmï (d. 656/1258) stated consensus (ijma) of the Companions on this view."[48] He further said that the rare executions were more due to the crimes they committed before the captivity than their status of POW itself. A well known case which is relevant in this regard is that of 'Abd Allah b. Khatal, who was one of the few people who were not granted immunity at the conquest of Mecca. A group of people "could have been punished by a tribunal should there have been one at the time”. But he was the only one executed for what we would today call high treason (as he collected tax money from Muslims before defecting and fighting them).[49] He also said that "in the first one hundred years of Islamic military history, that is, from the time of the Prophet (peace be upon him) till the time of Caliph 'Umar b. 'Abdul 'Aziz, there were only six or seven such cases, even if we were to accept the spurious reports of such executions."

Prosecuting prisoners

edit

In Islamic law, prisoners of war may be tried, convicted and punished for crimes beyond the belligerency itself.[6] However, they may not be punished merely for being belligerents.[6]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ Tafsir of the Qur'an by Ibn Kathir [1]
  2. ^ Shirazi, Imam Muhammad. The Prophet Muhammad - A Mercy to the World. Createspace Independent Pub, 2013, p. 74.
  3. ^ a b The Story of the Prisoners of the Battle of Badr : Shaykh Safi ur-Rahmaan Mubarakfoori [2]
  4. ^ a b 'Abu Yusuf Ya'qub Le Livre de l'impot foncier,' translated from Arabic and annotated by Edmond Fagnan, Paris, Paul Geuthner, 1991, pages 301-302) Abu Yusuf (d. 798 CE)
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Mekky, Omar (2023). Islamic Jihadism and the laws of war: a conversation in international and Islamic law languages. Oxford ; New York, NY: Oxford University Press. pp. 99–101. ISBN 978-0-19-888836-9. OCLC 1373608759.
  6. ^ a b c d Weeramantry, C. G. (1994). Islamic jurisprudence: an international perspective (Repr. of the ed. 1988 ed.). Houndmills: Macmillan. pp. 135–136. ISBN 978-0-333-44668-3.
  7. ^ a b c d Al-Dawoody, Ahmed (2011). The Islamic law of war : justifications and regulations (1st ed.). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. p. 59. ISBN 978-0-230-11160-8. OCLC 662407348.
  8. ^ Al-Dawoody, Ahmed (2011). The Islamic law of war: justifications and regulations. Palgrave series in islamic theology, law, and history (1st ed.). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 138–141. ISBN 978-0-230-11160-8.
  9. ^ Maududi (1967), Introduction of Ad-Dahr, "Period of revelation", p. 159.[incomplete short citation]
  10. ^ a b Crone, Patricia (2004). God's Rule: Government and Islam. Columbia University Press. pp. 371–372. ISBN 9780231132909.
  11. ^ Roger DuPasquier. Unveiling Islam. Islamic Texts Society, 1992, p. 104
  12. ^ "The Life of Muhammad The Prophet". Archived from the original on 2007-02-06. Retrieved 2007-02-10.
  13. ^ Muir, William (1861). The Life of Mahomet (Volume 3 ed.). London: Smith, Elder and Co. p. 122. Retrieved 22 October 2019.
  14. ^ a b Naqvi (2000), pg. 456[incomplete short citation]
  15. ^ Judge Weeramantry, Christopher G. (1997). Justice Without Frontiers. Brill Publishers. p. 136. ISBN 90-411-0241-8.
  16. ^ Judge Weeramantry, Christopher G. (1997). Justice Without Frontiers. Brill Publishers. pp. 136–7. ISBN 90-411-0241-8.
  17. ^ a b Nigosian, S. A. (2004). Islam. Its History, Teaching, and Practices. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. p. 115.
  18. ^ Maududi (1967), introduction of Ad-Dahr, "Period of revelation", pg. 159
  19. ^ Al-Dawoody, Ahmed (2011). The Islamic law of war : justifications and regulations (1st ed.). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. p. 79. ISBN 978-0-230-11160-8. OCLC 662407348.
  20. ^ (Quran 4:36, Quran 9:60, Quran 24:58)
  21. ^ (Quran 4:92, Quran 5:92, Quran 58:3)
  22. ^ (Quran 2:177, Quran 24:33, Quran 90:13)
  23. ^ Lewis 1990, page 6. All Qur'anic citations are his.
  24. ^ (Quran 5:33 Quran 48:29 Quran 24:2 Quran 22:19-22 Quran 9:73)
  25. ^ Lister, Tim (6 May 2014). "Boko Haram: The essence of terror". CNN. Archived from the original on 2014-05-13. Retrieved 13 May 2014.
  26. ^ Ferran, Lee (5 May 2014). "Boko Haram: Kidnappers, Slave-Owners, Terrorists, Killers". ABC News. Archived from the original on 2014-12-19. Retrieved 2014-12-18.
  27. ^ "Islamic State Seeks to Justify Enslaving Yazidi Women and Girls in Iraq". Newsweek. Reuters. 13 October 2014. Archived from the original on 2014-11-01. Retrieved 3 November 2014.
  28. ^ Allen McDuffee, "ISIS Is Now Bragging About Enslaving Women and Children," Archived 2017-08-30 at the Wayback Machine The Atlantic, Oct 13 2014
  29. ^ Salma Abdelaziz, "ISIS states its justification for the enslavement of women," Archived 2017-06-21 at the Wayback Machine CNN, October 13, 2014
  30. ^ Spencer, Richard (13 October 2014). "Thousands of Yazidi women sold as sex slaves 'for theological reasons', says Isil". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 2018-04-09. Retrieved 3 November 2014.
  31. ^ "To have and to hold: Jihadists boast of selling captive women as concubines," Archived 2017-08-29 at the Wayback Machine The Economist, Oct 18th 2014
  32. ^ By AFP, "ISIS jihadists boast of enslaving Yazidi women," Archived 2014-11-29 at the Wayback Machine Al Arabiya, October 13, 2014
  33. ^ Nour Malas, "Ancient Prophecies Motivate Islamic State Militants: Battlefield Strategies Driven by 1,400-year-old Apocalyptic Ideas," Archived 2014-11-22 at the Wayback Machine The Wall Street Journal, Nov. 18, 2014 (accessed Nov. 22,2014)
  34. ^ Amelia Smith, "ISIS Publish Pamphlet On How to Treat Female Slaves," Archived 2014-12-16 at the Wayback Machine Newsweek, 12/9/2014
  35. ^ Greg Botelho, "ISIS: Enslaving, having sex with 'unbelieving' women, girls is OK," Archived 2014-12-16 at the Wayback Machine CNN, December 13, 2014
  36. ^ Katharine Lackey, "Pamphlet provides Islamic State guidelines for sex slaves," Archived 2017-09-21 at the Wayback Machine USA Today, December 13, 2014
  37. ^ Carey Lodge, "Islamic State issues abhorrent sex slavery guidelines about how to treat women," Archived 2014-12-16 at the Wayback Machine,Christianity Today, 15 December 2014
  38. ^ Adam Withnall, "Isis releases 'abhorrent' sex slaves pamphlet with 27 tips for militants on taking, punishing and raping female captives," Archived 2015-09-25 at the Wayback Machine The Independent, 10 December 2014
  39. ^ a b El Fadl (2003), pg. 115
  40. ^ El Fadl (2003), pg. 116
  41. ^ Muhammad Hamidullah, Muslim Conduct of State, Muhammad Ashraf (1945), pp. 208-209
  42. ^ Hashmi (2003), pg. 145
  43. ^ a b Maududi (1998), p. 34
  44. ^ Ali (1991), p. 498
  45. ^ Prohibition of punishing people with fire, Musnad Ahmad
  46. ^ Muhammad Munir, "Debates on the Rights of Prisoners of War in Islamic Law" in Islamic Studies, Vol. 49, No. 4 (Winter 2010), p. 469
  47. ^ Muhammad Munir, "Debates on the Rights of Prisoners of War in Islamic Law" in Islamic Studies, Vol. 49, No. 4 (Winter 2010), p. 473
  48. ^ Muhammad Munir, "Debates on the Rights of Prisoners of War in Islamic Law" in Islamic Studies, Vol. 49, No. 4 (Winter 2010), p. 470
  49. ^ Muhammad Munir, "Debates on the Rights of Prisoners of War in Islamic Law" in Islamic Studies, Vol. 49, No. 4 (Winter 2010), p. 472

Notes

edit
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Islamic_views_on_prisoners_of_war&oldid=1253646007"