Brooklyn Preparatory School

Not to be confused with Brooklyn Preparatory High School.

Brooklyn Preparatory School, commonly referred to as Brooklyn Prep, was a highly selective Jesuit preparatory school founded by the Society of Jesus in 1908 in Brooklyn, New York. The school educated generations of young men from throughout New York City and Long Island until its closure in 1972. A new school of the same name now exists in the same borough.

Brooklyn Preparatory School Schola Praeparatoria Brooklyniensis
The building used by Medgar Evers College in 2022.
Address
1150 Carroll Street Crown Heights, Brooklyn New York City , New York United States
Coordinates	40°40′1″N 73°57′9″W
Information
Type	Private, all-male
Motto	Sanctitas, Scientia, Sanitas (Holiness, Knowledge, Health)
Religious affiliation(s)	Roman Catholic (Society of Jesus)
Opened	1908 (1908)
Closed	1972 (1972)
Oversight	Jesuit Province of New York
President	Rev. Eamon G. Taylor, SJ (1972)
Headmaster	Rev. John D. Alexander, SJ (1972)
Grades	9–12
Color(s)	Blue and white
Song	"Blue and White Victory March"
Athletics conference	CHSAA
Sports	Baseball, basketball, football, hockey, swimming, tennis
Team name	Eagles
Publication	The Brooklyn Prep Magazine Andros (literary magazine)
Newspaper	Blue Jug
Yearbook	Blue Book
Communities served	Brooklyn, Long Island
Graduates	8,500

History

The Prep was located on 1150 Carroll Street in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn, New York. The grounds and buildings are presently part of Medgar Evers College of the City University of New York (CUNY). Located next to the Prep was the Church of St. Ignatius Loyola, which was also run by the Jesuits and which was closed in 2011.

As a Jesuit institution, Brooklyn Prep was noted for its religious values, classical roots (e.g., Latin and Greek), and dress code (ties and jackets) – all part of its goal of turning out well-rounded, educated men. Most of its graduates matriculated to four-year colleges. For many years, the school offered a full,$1,800 four-year scholarship, to the winner of its annual "Diocesan Spelling Bee", which was open to all eighth grade male students from the Diocese of Brooklyn as well as the Diocese of Rockville Center. In 1961, the more than 150 entrants dwindled down to the Spelling Bee winner... Arthur Reilly, from St. Pascal Baylon School, in Saint Albans, New York. The "Prep" was part of a group of eight Jesuit secondary schools in New York and New Jersey (Regis, Xavier, Loyola, Fordham Prep, St. Peter's Prep, Canisius and McQuaid).

The school closed in 1972 but the 100th anniversary of the school was celebrated by alumni and former faculty in October 2008.

In 2003, New York Nativity began Brooklyn Jesuit Prep, a co-educational middle school. BJP operated in the former St. Teresa's School at Sterling Place and Classon Avenue in Crown Heights until 2020. BJP then moved to the former St. Vincent Ferrer school building at 37th and Glenwood in East Flatbush. BJP continues to provide Jesuit education for 5th through 8th grades. All students receive a substantial scholarship to attend.

Notable alumni

Among Brooklyn Prep's notable alumni are:

• Robert S. Bennett, 1957 – Washington, D.C., attorney
• William Peter Blatty, 1945 – author of The Exorcist
• Joseph Califano, 1948 – former Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare
• William P. Ford, 1953 [deceased] – international civil rights attorney*
• Jack Hofsiss, 1967 – director of The Elephant Man
• Joseph M. McLaughlin, 1950 – Senior Appellate Judge, Second Circuit
• John Musto, 1972 – composer, concert pianist; 1997 Pulitzer Prize in Music finalist
• Joe Paterno, 1944 [deceased] – football coach at Penn State for 45 years
• Joseph Roccasalvo, 1940 – author, academic, and retired priest
• John Sexton, 1959 – President of New York University
• Dr. George A. Sheehan, 1936 (deceased) – best-selling running and fitness expert
• Raymond Siller, 1956 – television writer, political consultant

Notable faculty

Noted faculty included:

• Rev. Thomas V. Bermingham, SJ – classical scholar; professor at Georgetown University and Fordham University who worked on The Exorcist
• Rev. Daniel Berrigan, SJ – peace activist; author and poet
• Rev. Edward B. Bunn – dean of Brooklyn Prep and later president of Loyola University Maryland and Georgetown University
• Rev. J. Charles Davey, SJ – first dean of Brooklyn Prep and president of Saint Joseph's University
• John C. Lawn – varsity basketball coach, who became Drug Enforcement Administration Administrator, COO of the New York Yankees, and CEO of The Century Council