User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites

This page requires updating because: it tests software predating June 2021. In doing so, you could add a timestamp to the page.

Please notify the uploader with {{subst:update-note|1=User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites|2=it tests software predating June 2021.}} ~~~~

SVG test suites

Summary

	librsvg 2.50	resvg 0.14.0	Inkscape 1.0	Batik 1.13; 1.14^{[clarification needed]}
Correctness according to the W3C test suite	0,662	0,831	0,745	0,801
cpu-time taken in the W3C test suite (512 px)	1m 46,776s	1m 04,490s	7m 57,465s	6m 51,560s
Correctness according to resvg test suite	0.754	0.956	0.729	0.703
Time measured by resvg test suite	4min 05sek	2min 30sek	46min 22sek	61min 29sek
Correctness with Wikimedia featured pictures	0.92	1.00
Time with Wikimedia featured pictures	5m 17,701s	4m 46,639s	15m 28,202s	11m 30,768s
time 2006-MediaWiki-collection (512px)	23.129s	9.551s	186.809s	87.313s
solved phab:-tasks relative to all tasks^[1]^{[clarification needed]}	0.55^[2]	0.88	0.78

commands

command	librsvg	resvg	Inkscape	Batik
width 512px	`-w 512`^[3]	`-w 512`^[4]	`-w 512`^[5]	`-w 512`^[6]
dpi 96	`-a -d 96dpi -p 96dpi`^[7]	`--dpi 96`^[8]	`-d 96`^[9]	`-dpi 96`^[10]
lang=de-AT, de, en	Unix $LANG environment^[11]	`--languages 'de-AT, de, en'`^[12]	Unix $LANG environment^[11]	`-lang`^[11] (not working)

which commands are used

used environment installations

#librsvg&inkscape&prerequieries
sudo dnf --refresh upgrade
if [ -f "/etc/debian_version" ]; then
 sudo apt install python3-pip cargo npm inkscape optipng scour librsvg2-bin
fi
if [ "$(grep -Ei 'fedora|redhat' /etc/*release)" ]; then
 sudo dnf install inkscape #inkscape
 sudo dnf install librsvg2 #librsvg
 sudo dnf install cargo #resvg
 sudo dnf install cabextract #for unpacking windows fonts
 sudo dnf install google-noto-\* #for google-noto-fonts (>1GB!)
 sudo dnf install python3-pip npm optipng python3-scour batik batik-rasterizer ImageMagick qt5-qtbase-devel harfbuzz-devel qt5-qtbase qt5-qtbase-devel qt5-qtsvg qt5-qtsvg-devel librsvg2-tools wxsvg wxsvg-devel #not shure if needed
fi
#batik
mkdir -p ~/prgm
cd ~/prgm
wget https://mirror.klaus-uwe.me/apache//xmlgraphics/batik/binaries/batik-bin-1.14.zip
unzip batik-bin-1.14.zip
#resvg
mkdir -p ~/Documents/GitDesktop/
cd ~/Documents/GitDesktop/
git clone https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg.git
cd resvg/
git config pull.rebase false #optional
git pull #optional
cargo build --release
./make-vendored.sh

fonts

https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg-test-suite/tree/master/fonts
sudo rpm -i https://downloads.sourceforge.net/project/mscorefonts2/rpms/msttcore-fonts-installer-2.6-1.noarch.rpm ; fc-cache -f -v

main

#!/bin/bash
export WIDTH=512
mkdir -p 4Batik${WIDTH} 3Ink${WIDTH} 2lib${WIDTH} 1Resvg${WIDTH} 3InkShell${WIDTH}
cp aa_resvg.sh 1Resvg${WIDTH}/aa_resvg.sh
cp aa_librsvg.sh 2lib${WIDTH}/aa_librsvg.sh
cp aa_Inkscape.sh 3Ink${WIDTH}/aa_Inkscape.sh
cp aa_batik.sh 4Batik${WIDTH}/aa_batik.sh
cp aa_InkShell.sh 3InkShell${WIDTH}/aa_InkShell.sh
cd SVG
#for file in *.svg
# do
# mv -- "$file" "${file// /_}"
#done
for file in *.svg
 do
 cp "$file" ../4Batik${WIDTH}/"$file"
 cp "$file" ../3Ink${WIDTH}/"$file"
 cp "$file" ../2lib${WIDTH}/"$file"
 cp "$file" ../1Resvg${WIDTH}/"$file"
done
cd ..

date
cd 1Resvg${WIDTH}
echo $(pwd)
time taskset -c 0 ./aa_render.sh &> aa_re.txt
cd ..
date
cd 2lib${WIDTH}
echo $(pwd)
time taskset -c 0 ./aa_render.sh &> aa_lib.txt
cd ..
date
cd 3Ink${WIDTH}
echo $(pwd)
time taskset -c 0 ./aa_render.sh &> aa_Ink.txt
cd ..
date
cd 4Batik${WIDTH}
echo $(pwd)
time taskset -c 0 ./aa_render.sh &>aa_batxt
cd ..
date
cd 3InkShell${WIDTH}
echo $(pwd)
./aa_render.sh &> aa_Ink.txt
cd ..
date

librsvg

#!/bin/bash
date
for file in *.svg
 do
 echo & #Add a empty line to split the output
 echo $file &
 rsvg-convert "$file" -w ${WIDTH} -a -d 96 -p 96 >"${file%.svg}_librsvg.png"
done
date

resvg

#!/bin/bash
date
for file in *.svg
 do
 echo & #Add a empty line to split the output
 echo $file &
 ~/Dokumente/GitDesktop/resvg/target/release/resvg "$file" -w ${WIDTH} "${file%.svg}_rendersvg.png"
done
date

Inkscape (start for each image)

#!/bin/bash
date
for file in *.svg
 do
 echo & #Add a empty line to split the output
 echo $file &
 inkscape "$file" -w ${WIDTH} --export-type="png"
 mv "${file%.svg}.png" "${file%.svg}_Inkscape.png" &
done
date

Inkscape (start only once)

#!/bin/bash
date
for file in *.svg
 do
 echo "file-open:${file}; export-type:png; export-width:${WIDTH}px; export-do;" >> aa_toInkscape.txt
done
echo quit  >> aa_toInkscape.txt
date
 time taskset -c 0 inkscape --shell --actions="$(cat aa_toInkscape.txt)"
date

Batik

#!/bin/bash
date
for file in *.svg
 do
 echo & #Add a empty line to split the output
 echo $file &
 java -Djava.awt.headless=true -jar ~/prgm/batik-1.14/batik-rasterizer-1.14.jar -w ${WIDTH} "$file" -d "${file%.svg}_batik.png"
done
date

Differences that are no mistake

Different Antialising
Different font-fallback
90dpi or 96dpi, see User:JoKalliauer/SVG_units, this can be fixed for some render e.g. resvg; librsvg 2.52 librsv2.52 will change from 90dpi to 96dpi

W3C SVG 1.1 test suite

https://www.w3.org/Graphics/SVG/Test/20110816/

SVG	librsvg	resvg	Inkscape	batik	chrome	firefox	svgnet	wxsvg	qtsvg
correctness 2	0,662	0,831	0,745	0,801	0,866	0,855	0,614	0,193	0,418
user sys time (natural resolution)	13m 23.399s	0m 42.104s	22m 55.256s	70m 16.007s
time (300px)	13m 12,446s	1m 7,044s
time (512px)	14m 43,146s	1m 12,591s	21m 14,825s (4m 13.46s^[13])	29m 46,446s
time (512px)	1m52,417s

Where resvg is superior to librsvg

	SVG	vdiff
color-prop-05-t
coords-viewattr-04-f
filters-conv-01-f
filters-conv-02-f
filters-conv-04-f
filters-composite-04-f
filters-diffuse-01-f
filters-image-01-
filters-image-03-f
filters-image-04-f
filters-image-05-f
filters-light-05-f
filters-specular-01-f
linking-a-08-t
linking-a-09-b
linking-a-10-f
masking-path-04-b
masking-path-07-b
masking-path-10-b
masking-path-11-b
painting-control-04-f
painting-control-06-f
painting-stroke-10-t
pservers-grad-13-b
pservers-grad-17-b
pservers-grad-20-b
pservers-grad-21-b
render-groups-01-b
render-groups-03-t
shapes-intro-02-f
shapes-polygon-03-t
struct-cond-overview-02-f
struct-cond-overview-03-f
struct-cond-overview-04-f
struct-frag-05-t
struct-image-01-t
struct-image-04-t
struct-image-05-b
struct-image-06-t
struct-image-08-t
struct-image-10-t
struct-image-13-f
struct-image-14-f
struct-image-15-f
struct-image-17-b
struct-image-19-f
struct-symbol-01-b
struct-use-01-t
struct-use-12-f
styling-elem-01-b
styling-pres-01-t
text-align-04-b
text-bidi-01-t
text-deco-01-b
text-path-01-b
text-path-02-b
text-spacing-01-b
text-text-04-t
text-text-05-t
text-text-06-t
text-text-07-t
text-text-09-t
text-text-12-t
text-tspan-01-b
text-tspan-02-b

Where librsvg is superior to resvg

	SVG	vdiff
filters-displace-02-f
filters-light-03-f
filters-light-04-f
filters-turb-02-f
filters-overview-01-b
filters-overview-02-b
filters-overview-03-b
struct-frag-04-t
styling-css-04-f
text-tref-02-b

Where both fail

	SVG	vdiff
color-prof-01-f
filters-composite-05-f
filters-displace-01-f
filters-light-01-f
filters-light-02-f
filters-offset-02-b
masking-path-06-b
painting-render-01-b
painting-render-02-b
struct-cond-overview-05-f
struct-image-02-b
struct-image-03-t
struct-image-07-t
struct-image-09-t
struct-image-12-b
struct-image-16-f
struct-image-18-f
struct-use-04-b
struct-use-05-b
struct-use-06-b
struct-use-07-b
struct-use-13-f
styling-css-05-b
styling-css-09-f
styling-css-10-f
styling-pres-05-f
text-align-05-b
text-align-06-b
text-fonts-03-t
text-fonts-04-t
text-fonts-202-t
text-fonts-203-t
text-fonts-204-t
text-intro-02-b
text-intro-03-b
text-intro-05-t
text-intro-09-b
text-intro-10-f
text-text-01-b
text-tref-01-b
types-basic-02-f

resvg test suite

1338 files from https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg-test-suite/tree/master/tests, uploaded in Category:Rendersvg_test_suite.

SVG	librsvg 2.50	resvg 0.14.0	Inkscape 1.0	Batik 1.13; 1.14	Chromium r818858	Firefox 83	SVG.NET 3.0.102	wxSVG 1.5.11
correctness^[14]	0.754	0.956	0.729	0.703	0.886	0.872	0.450	0.254
time	4min 05sek	2min 30sek	46min 22sek	61min 29sek
time (300px)	4m 26,674s	2m 14,276s	27m 17,977s	45m 1,809s
time (512px)	6m 13,054s	2m 35,135s	38m 5,628s (17m 8.889s^[13]/ 2m 22.970s^[15])	63m 36,648s

^{[clarification needed]}

all Images

User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites/all Images

Category:Featured pictures on Wikimedia Commons - vector

141 files in https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Featured_pictures_on_Wikimedia_Commons_-_vector

This category represents the most qualitative SVG-files on Commons. Different font-fallbacks are not considered as mistake.

SVG	librsvg 2.50	resvg 0.14.0	Inkscape 1.0	batik 1.14
correctness	0.92	1.00
real time (limited to 1CPU)	5m 17,701s	4m 46,639s	15m 28,202s	11m 30,768s
real time (300px)	3m 44,533s	0m 50,908s	3m 37,714s	8m 29,825s
time (512px)	4m 28,886s	1m 15,307s	5m 9,164s (2m 27,598s^[13])	10m 8,168s

User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites/Featured details

test files by User:Glrx

User:Glrx might be one of the experts about special SVG-features and details about SVG-standard, they are known for contributing useful test files.

Supporting SVG 2.0 features is not considered as a mistake, even if rendered as SVG 1.1 would be different. Since SVG 2.0 is not released, so such features do not count as mistakes, even if implemented wrong.

librsvg 2.50.3 - 2.54.3	resvg 0.14.0 - 0.22.0	Inkscape 1.0.2 - 1.2	Batik 1.14
1 alignment-baseline 2 dominant-baseline 3 textLength 4 phab:T11420 textPath is not supported	1 alignment-baseline 2 dominant-baseline 3 textLength	1 alignment-baseline 2 no Chinese fallback-font 3 text-anchor	1 alignment-baseline 2 dominant-baseline

Left 2 wrong Right 2 wrong Right 3 wrong Right 4 wrong		Left 2 wrong Left 3 wrong Right 1 wrong Right 2 wrong Right 3 wrong Right 4 wrong	nonquadratitic viewBox not supported Left 2 wrong Left 3 wrong Right 1 wrong Right 2 wrong Right 3 wrong Right 4 wrong
	undefined behavior for SVG1.1 phab:T228321, resvg, w3c

selected files from Category:Pictures showing a librsvg bug

This files are known to be difficult to render and are relevant features on commons. However here a comparison about correctness might be missleading.

see Librsvg_bugs for most important ones

see Template:C for simple minimal working examples

textPath

There exist no renderer and no browser (at least neither Chrome nor Firefox) that fully suppport textPath: e.g:

librsvg does not support it at all(!)
resvg not in combination with textLength
Inkscape supports negative offsets wrong
batik chrashes sometimes, here it is difficult to find out what's wrong

User:JoKalliauer/SVG_test_suites/textPath

User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites/textPath

files showing a resvg-bug

This files are known to be difficult to render and are relevant features on commons. However here a comparison about correctness might be missleading, since they are taken from resvg Bugreports .

Known resvg-issues and workarounds

User:JoKalliauer/SVG test suites/resvg Issues details

requested files by others

Note: You are allowed to edit this page!

Here everyone can add svg-files, which they want to check renderings by different software engines. Generally it should only be valid SVG 1.1-files.

SVG

resvg

librsvg

Ink

batik

Template:Vertical header

Renderers

Tested:

w:librsvg, a small, simple viewer to preview how SVG files will look when rendered by MediaWiki
resvg, one of the fastest and most correct SVG renderers^[16], implemented in Rust
Inkscape, which also supports some Inkscape-specific (non-standard) SVG features
Apache Batik, an SVG toolkit implemented in Java

Others (not tested here):

svg-explorer-extension, a free software extension for Template:W that generates thumbnails for SVG files
svgexport, a Node.js rasterizing module
CairoSVG, a Python converter using Cairo
ImageMagick, a leading free software imaging software suite
SVG.NET, a cross-platform C# library which can render SVG
Qt SVG, a C module for Qt
wxSVG, a C library to create, manipulate and render SVG files with the wxWidgets toolkit
svglib, a Python library
Aspose.SVG, a commercial SVG library for .NET
GPAC Project on Advanced Content, for animated SVG
Gecko, Mozilla Firefox's engine
WebKit, the engine of Apple's Safari browser
Blink, Chromium's engine
- chrome-svgrender, a wrapper around Google Chrome (headless) to render SVG files like Chrome would
KSvg, part of the discontinued KHTML browser engine, formerly used by Konqueror
Trident, Microsoft's deprecated browser engine
Prince, a commercial converter to PDFTemplate:Clarify
skr canvas (This project is in pre-release stage.)

References

↑ mw:User:JoKalliauer/phab/wikimedia-svg-rendering
↑ This number is a bit unfair since all bugs are c-librsvg2.40-bugs
↑ https://helpmanual.io/help/rsvg-convert/
↑ https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339
↑ https://inkscape.org/de/doc/inkscape-man.html
↑ https://xmlgraphics.apache.org/batik/tools/rasterizer.html
↑ https://helpmanual.io/help/rsvg-convert/
↑ https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339
↑ https://inkscape.org/de/doc/inkscape-man.html
↑ https://xmlgraphics.apache.org/batik/tools/rasterizer.html
↑ ^a ^b ^c phab:T40010#7032149
↑ https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339
↑ ^a ^b ^c without restarting inkscape
↑ https://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg#svg-support
↑ removing File:test_suite_resvg_e-feImage-015.svg and File:test_suite_resvg_e-feImage-016.svg
↑ User:JoKalliauer/SVG_test_suites

[1] w:User:JoKalliauer/phab/wikimedia-svg-rendering

[2] This number is a bit unfair since all bugs are c-librsvg2.40-bugs

[3] ttps://helpmanual.io/help/rsvg-convert/

[4] ttps://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339

[5] ttps://inkscape.org/de/doc/inkscape-man.html

[6] ttps://xmlgraphics.apache.org/batik/tools/rasterizer.html

[7] ttps://helpmanual.io/help/rsvg-convert/

[8] ttps://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339

[9] ttps://inkscape.org/de/doc/inkscape-man.html

[10] ttps://xmlgraphics.apache.org/batik/tools/rasterizer.html

[langGlrx-11] :T40010#7032149

[12] ttps://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg/issues/376#issue-859203339

[continuous-13] without restarting inkscape

[14] ttps://github.com/RazrFalcon/resvg#svg-support

[15] removing File:test_suite_resvg_e-feImage-015.svg and File:test_suite_resvg_e-feImage-016.svg

[16] User:JoKalliauer/SVG_test_suites

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]