Work Text:
Scar was trying his very best to be normal about the newest hermit.
He really was!
But the thing is: he was too good-looking.
And not only that, he was charming too!
Or at least he was on the few interactions they had.
Oh and he also seemed to have a good humor and to build well – yeah, he had only build two small things but- they sure were pretty!
Basically, Scar couldn't stop thinking about him. “Which is a very normal reaction to meeting someone new”, Scar tried to assure himself.
Just like building a pineapple under the sea for him was a normal thing to do! “Eh, I've certainly seen people doing worse in this server”, he once again tried to assure himself as he placed the last few blocks. “The Squidward House simply demands a Sponge Bob House, so I'm happy to do it! It's a good sever-welcoming present as well…”
He was doing it in the early hours of the morning, reckoning it was his safest moment to do it whiteout getting caught – he didn't know Grian enough to assume how long he'd be away from his base. So the early hours it was! He could sleep later, building this and not getting caught was more important.
Unfortunately, it was all for nothing.
Having a conduit by his side meant he didn't need to breath, but ot wasn't exactly a water-breething potion, which allowed for talking, opening his mouth would still result in swallowing salt water or even drowning.
That became clear when he turned around with leafs on his hands, saw Grian very much awake and observing him from his starter base, and promptly open his mouth in surprise, swallowing a lot of unwanted sea water.
And thats how Grian would probably remember him for the rest of eternity. Brilliant.
From that moment on, Scar could only remember someone touching and pulling his upper body and then he as suddenly inside Grian's base coughing water.
“Oh my Void, are you okay?”, he heard Grian worriedly asking.
After a few coughs, Scar managed to nod, hunched over the floor.
He felt quite stupid. Grian had already saw him drowning in a miserable pound and now he saw him trying to drink ocean water. How pathetic.
“I'll grab drinkable water”, he heard Grian say as he finally managed to sit and breathe more steadily.
Slowly, Scar managed to drink the water Grian had brought. The fresh water helping his hurt throat and fast-beating heart.
“Thank you”, he managed to say after calming down.
“No problem. I'm sorry for scaring you”, Grian answered.
“You did nothing! You were literally just standing at your base.”
“Yeah but-”
“But nothing!”
They stayed in silence a few seconds. Scar tried to clear his mind enough to find something to say, but it was still foggy after the shock.
“So…”, Grian started, “you were building Sponge Bob's House?”
Scar felt his cheeks getting warm. “Yeah… It's- It's a sever-welcoming gift! I saw your Squidward's house and- I don't know, I thought it was a fun idea. I understand if you don't like it, though! Feel free to destroy it! Or I can destroy it for you, so you don't-”
“No!”, Grian interrupted. “You are not destroying it, I love it!”
That certainly helped Scar's agitated nerves.
“I might build Patrick's rock next”, he said with a smile.
“And what a beautiful smile.”, Scar thought.
“I'm happy you like it”, he said out loud. “So, how are you liking hermitcraft so far?”
“Oh it's so fun!”, Grian said. “Everyone has been so friendly- I mean, you just built a whole pineapple just to go along with my conduit! Oh and just yesterday-”
Scar tried his best to pay attention to Grian's every word, even letting out some “wows!” and “amazing!” as he told him about going into a temple with Xisuma and about creating a game called “Tag”.
But it was hard concentrating when his mind started to focus on how pretty Grian was and how kissable his lips were and how good those lips would look around Scar's dick and-
Wait, actually, that brings another of Scar's concerns: Grian hadn't even set up his Kink Profile yet.
It was standard practice in Hermitcraft since they were a really sex free server. Most hermits were frolicking around most often then not and so the Kink Profile was an important thing for everyone.
Basically, it was a list of kinks – not every single one, as that would be a bit much, but the were a lot of important umbrella terms – and you can check if they are a Yes, a No or a Maybe for you – it also has a differentiation for receiving or giving, depending on the kink.
It helped people to know what to expect or not from every hermit, but more importantly it helped with consent in cases of exhibitionism, for example. If a couple wants to be exhibitionist in the shopping district, they should check if there isn't a hermit that checked the “doesn't want any sex interactions at all” box.
Unfortunately, Grian's profile was still blank. No ‘yes’ and no ‘no’. Which left Scar wandering if it was ok or not for him to make an advance.
“So, I noticed you didn't fill your Kink Profile”, Scar said before he could even fully comprehend what he was saying.
“Oh no.”, he thought, “I said that out loud. I actually said that out loud.”
“Ah… Yeah…”, Grian said, blushing.
“I'm sorry”, Scar said. “I shouldn't have said that- at least not out of nowhere”, he forced a chuckle, hoping it would light the mood a bit more, “It's just- well it's just for your own health being, really. To protect you and- and stuff.”, Scar tried to resume. He was pretty sure that sitting through an explanation of the Kink Profile, as well as the Light System, was standart practice to join Hermitcraft, so surely there was no need to repeat it to Grian.
“No, yeah! I know. It's just-”, Grian said as the red on his cheeks intensified. “I actually don't know what I like.”
“You… huh?”, was all Scar managed to reply.
“I don't have much experience.”, he confessed, the deep red on his face not going away. “And I don't even know what a lot of those words mean.”
“Well, you don't need to have experienced everything in other to fill your Profile… I can also help you with any words you don't know the meaning! I'm not very good with words but it’d probably be fine-”
“Yeah, I- I know I don't need to experience everything, but I also feel like I have no experience at all!”
“…are you a virgin?”, Scar couldn't help but ask.
“No!”, Grian answered quickly. “But, I- okay, I only had sex with one person before. And every time was fine but there also wasn't a lot into it.”
“I see.”, Scar said, something inside of him wanting to go after the person that apparently didn't put in the effort Grian deserved. “Hey, maybe I can help you!”
“Y-you- w-what?”, Grian asked uncertainly.
“I can help you! We can go over the list and I will help you figure out what you like and what you don't. And I promise I will make it very pleasurable!”
“…you are offering to fuck me?”
“Yeah!”, Scar answered with maybe too much enthusiasm. “If you are okay with it, of course.”
“I… Yeah. I think I'm okay with it. As long as you are okay with it.”
“I'm more than okay with it”, Scar said as he gave his best calming smile.
“…okay, then. We can start whenever you want, I guess.”
“Is now a good time for you?”
“Now? Are you sure? You, like, almost died like half an hour ago.”
“I'm fiiiine”, Scar said with a dismissive hand gesture.
“O-okay, then… Let's do it.”
“I'm sorry, I think I need more enthusiasm from you.”
Grian let ou a chuckled, stiff shoulders loosing just a bit. “Let's do it!”
“Yeah! That was better! Okay, let's see where to start”, Scar said, moving to grab his communicator and opening the Kink Profile. “Okay, the first kink we have is anal. This is an umbrella term, because there are a lot of butt-stuff, so its more an ‘are you open to it?’ and you should inform if, like, you are not into it or whatever. Have you ever had anal?”
“…no.”
“Okay, would you like to test it right now?”
“…yeah.”
“Would you like to be on the receiving end or the giving end?”
“…I guess receiving? I don't know much about it, I don't think I'd do a good job giving.”
“Okay, that’s fair! And you can always test giving at another moment, when you feel more confident!”
“…yeah, that sounds good.”
“Okay, can you show me your bed, good sir? I think it'd be more comfortable there.”
“This way.”, Grian said as he got up from the floor and started to lead the way to his bed.
“It's just a single bed, I hope that's okay.”
“It is!”, Scar answered. “Now why don't you sit down and get comfortable. Do you have any lube?”
“Y-yeah, there was one on the ‘new-server kit’ Xisuma handed out. I think I put it in that chest.”
“Oh, I'm always thankful for that kit.”, Scar said, already moving to the close by chest Grian had pointed to. Sure enough, the kit was easy to find inside it.
Scar felt a shiver running through his body as he turned back and saw that Grian had already removed his shirt. “Fuck, he's beautiful”, he thought for the hundredth time since Grian joined the server.
“Maybe this is a good time to tell you I'm trans”, Grian said biting his lips and seeming nervous. Scar's eyes traveled down to Grian's top surgery scars which he hadn't noticed before. “Is that okay for you?”
“Why wouldn't it be?”
At that, Grian visibly relaxed.
“Okay, do you promise you will tell me anytime you don't like or are not comfortable with something?”, Scar asked.
“Yes.”, Grian answered, already sounding a lot more secure, if not eager.
“So, Red for Stop. Yellow to check in. Green to keep going. Is that okay for you? Wanna add a safe word?”
“No, that's great!”
“Great!”, Scar said as he placed the lube on Grian's bedside table. “So… Can I kiss you?”
“Yes.”, Grian answered. His voice was barely a whisper, full of desire.
Scar moved so he was in front of Grian. Their height difference was already noticeable when they were both standing, but with Grian sitting while Scar was standing, their difference made things a bit awkward at first, with Scar needing to hunch to reach Grian's lips. Still, they managed to share a good kiss. Tame, at first, as they both adjusted to one another.
Soon, Scar sat in Grian's lap, one leg to each side of the smaller man, which made them both more comfortable to make the kiss deeper. They explored each others mouths with dedication as Grian slowly became confident enough to explore Scar's body with his hands.
Scar felt Grian's hands on his butcheeks, trying to pull the bigger man to himself, and knew he should progress to the next part. He felt Grian had relaxed enough and, if the exploration of his body was indication enough, he also wanted more than kisses.
Scar's hands traveled to the button of Grian's pants and slowly pulled their kiss apart. “Can I take off your pants?”
Grian agreed, but only after letting out a small protest sound when their mouths separated. Scar felt a smile forming in his face as he realized Grian was apparently one to make the most sweet of sounds.
His smile only intensified after removing Grian's pants, underwear going along. He stood there for a few seconds doing nothing but look, because he couldn't stop admiring the beautiful body in front of him.
“Like what you see?”, Grian boldly asked.
Scar felt a tug of happiness in his heart over the simple fact that Grian already felt comfortable enough to make those sorts of comments. Not to mention being comfortable enough to be completely naked after him. Of course, the stubborn pink in his cheeks didn't go away, but that was to be expected.
“I like it a lot”, Scar answered.
Tossing Grian's pants to the side, Scar approached him once again, this time kneeling in front of him.
Grian's legs involuntary tried to close, but he forced them open. With a smirk, Scar helped his legs to stay open, putting one hand on each leg.
The shiver Grian gave as Scar began to kiss his inner thigh made Scar go just a little more crazy. He wouldn't be able to describe how much he wanted to fuck that man, have him shaking with pleasure in his arms. He also knew he needed to take it slow. Grian said he wasn’t a virgin, but he also said he was inexperienced. Slow and steady was the best way to begin their adventures.
Scar was having a grand time kissing and sucking Grian's thigh, pulling delicious sounds from the smaller man – and he hadn't even got to the best part yet! Which, now, coming to think of it…
“By the way”, Scar said, pulling a way just enough so he could look into Grian's eyes, “what would you like me to call everything?”
“Huh?”, Grian answered with the most confused face.
“I mean like… Clit? Dick? Pussy? Cunt?”
“Oh. Ah… I don't know. Never thought much about that.”
“You said you weren't a virgin, didn’t your previous partner…?”
“I don't think he cared that much.”
Scar frowned. He didn't know who that bastard was but he wanted to have a few words with him. “Well, we can experiment with that as well. I'll try different names and you tell me which ones you like the most and which ones you don't like. Sounds good?”
“As long as you go back to what you were doing: yes. That sounds great.”
Scar gave him one last smirk before obeying his demands. “Very well, good sir. I will go suck your dick right now!”
“Scar~”, Grian moaned as Scar's month found it's way to his dick. Grian's hands entangled themselves on the brunette's hair, trying to pull him impossibly closer.
Scar's tongue had it's way with Grian's dick for a few seconds before one of Scar's fingers tentatively touched Grian's hole.
Scar knew that wasn't the star of the night, that they were supposed to experiment anal, but he needed Grian to be the most relaxed possible. And so he was determined to have him orgasming at least once before anal penetration. It was also a challenge to himself – who was not really used to Grian's anatomy – to see if he could make him orgasm without penetration.
So, his finger stayed right outside Grian's hole, despite Grian's hip movements clearly waiting him to enter. He used the finger to gather a bit of slick so circling Grian's dick would be easier.
“Please”, Grian pleaded.
He pleaded so prettily that Scar relented. Fine, there will be penetration for that hole. But only with his tongue.
The intrusion made Grian gasp in pleasure. It only took a few movements of Scar's tongue and a light press in his dick to make Grian shiver with his first orgasm.
It lasted a few seconds, and Scar used that time to reach for the lube he left on the bedside table.
“Fuck, Scar. That was… Wow.”
“That's a good thing I hope”
“Yes. Very good. It has never been so good.”, Grian said a bit breathlessly.
Well, if Scar already wanted to have a few words with that mysterious person Grian has been previously, now he wanted to throw hands.
Scar gave Grian's thigh an affectionate kiss. “Do you feel like keeping going?”
“Fuck yeah I want more”, Grian said in one breath.
Scar laughed. His dick painfully ached in his pants.
“Okay, I will start stretching you. It might be a bit painful at first, but you need to tell me if it feels like it's too much okay? Please, tell whenever it hurts okay?”
“Okay, Scar. T-thank you for worrying that much.”
Scar frowned. “Grian, this is literally the bare minimum.”
He saw something on Grian's eyes. A flesh of… worry? Shame? Reflection? Scar couldn't pin point it exactly.
Grian shook his head, like when one does to stop thoughts. “Shall we continue?”
“Of course, my good sir”, Scar answered, giving Grian's thigh another small kiss as if that was a final dot on his sentence. He moved to open the lube bottle and pored a good amount of it in his hand. He knew it was good lube – Xisuma would never cheap out on that – but he also knew this situation called for more lube than just enough lube.
He went back to kissing and sucking Grian's inner tight just like he had earlier, managing to make him make the same whimpering sounds from earlier. He decided to adventure a little higher as well, this time, going to Grian's abdomen and making the man lay down on the bed, which gave Scar better access to his back hole.
Still pampering Grian's body with kisses and light bites, Scar reached to one of Grian's hands. His other hand traveling down Grian's body. He reached his slit and the light touch made the blonde shiver. That wasn't Scar's final stop, though, so he kept going until he reached it.
As Scar made circling motions on his rim, Grian tensed up a bit. “Color?”, Scar asked.
“…green. I'm just a bit tense.”
“Don't be. I'll make it good, I promise.
Grian visibly relaxed. A few more light touches on the outside of Grian's hole and Scar finally felt it would probably be fine to enter.
He entered just the very tip of his finger, but it still made Grian gasp loudly, body tensing, his hole becoming intensely tight around Scar's finger. That was to be expected, of course. He didn't press too hard on Scar's hand, though, and he would take that as a good sign.
“Relax for me, babe.”
Grian did his very best to obey, which allowed Scar's finger to enter him a bit more. It took some time, but eventually his hole finger managed to enter. Scar didn't move more, letting the blonde's body adjust to it.
“Kiss me, Scar, please!”, he pleaded and Scar was happy to attend. The angle was a bit awkward, with Scar not wanting to move his finger, but they made it work.
After some good moments of Grian distracted by the kiss, Scar figured it would probably be fine for him to slowly start moving his finger. There was a bit of a reaction from Grian, but the sound he made definitely sounded like one of pleasure.
“I think I'm ready for more”, said Grian, with a voice that sounded like a gasp.
“You sure, G?”
“Please.”
Scar wasn't strong enough to deny such a beautiful plead.
Still, he took the entering of the second finger as slow as the entering of the first.
Grian's beautiful moans were turning Scar crazy, but he was determined to take it very slow.
Eventually, he did manage to enter a third finger, his dick acheing as if it knew that soon – soon! – he might be able to enter Grian's body.
They kept kissing throughout the hole stretching process, only breaking it off when Grian needed to moan too badly.
“Scar, I think this is enough.”
Scar tried to ignore the twinge of disappointment that filled him. It was wrong to be so, of course, it was Grian's right to want to stop at any moment and-
“I'm stretched enough.”, Grian said before Scar could finish his thoughts. “I need you inside. Your dick! Please. Please fuck me!”
Oh.
Oh, he could do that happily.
“You sure, G? I'm… I'm quite big, maybe we should stretch you just a bit more.”
“I'm sure, Scar. Please!”
Mumbling a few ‘okays’, Scar slowly took his fingers out, gaining a whine from Grian. He rushed to take his pants and underwear, leaving his proud penis to jump out. And the dick was impossibly hard after so much time focusing on Grian's pleasure.
“Oh. Wow. Okay. Yeah, maybe you were right about needing to stretch a bit more.”
Scar let out a laugh. “We can do that-”
“No, Scar”, interrupted Grian. “I don't even care if I'm not stretched enough, I need you inside right now.”
Scar's dick twitched in anticipation. “Fuck, Grian is hot”, Scar thought as he reached for the lubed he had left on the floor. Once again, he pored a good amount on his hand, but now it all went to his dick.
Scar moved so he was finally lined-up in front of Grian's hole, one hand on one of Grian's knees, trying to help him keeping his legs open, the other on his on dick, so he could line-up perfectly.
“You'll tell me if it's too much, right?”
“Scar, if you don't get in right the fuck now I will kill you!”
“Okay! Okay, jeez!”, he said with a happy smile on his face.
With his hand's help, Scar entered just the tip of his dick. It made Grian tremble all over, his hole squeezing Scar's dick so much Scar actually feared he might come immediately, like an inexperienced school boy.
“I need you to relax, G.”, he said with a raspy voice.
It took Grian a few seconds, but he managed to make his body relax. It still took them a few minutes to get Scar to bottom out.
“We still did it, though.”, Scar thought while marveling the view of where his and Grian's body connected.
“You good, G?”
“Yes”, he gasped. “Just give me a few seconds.”
“Of course!”
It didn't take too long before he signaled Scar could start moving. He went really slow at first. Torturing his own body in name of Grian's comfort. He couldn't hold the slow pace once Grian screamed “faster!”, though.
Still, he didn't go at his maximum speed just yet, preferring to up the speed slowly.
When he was almost at full speed, he moved one of his hands to Grian's dick, making the man shiver with pleasure once more. It didn't take long before his whole body trembled with his second orgasm.
“C-can I keep going? I'm close.”, Scar asked, wanting to make sure it was okay for him to keep fucking Grian even after he reached his climax.
“Yes, Scar! Keep fucking me!”, he practically screamed, his mind seemed to still be a little fuzzy with pleasure.
“Fuck, I'm coming! I'm coming!”, Scar announced, “C-can I come inside you?”
“Yes! Yes! Come inside!”, Grian excitedly agreed.
It didn't take Scar more than two pumps before he came fast and hard inside Grian. Maybe it was because of how much he had to wait before giving his own dick some attention, but he was almost sure that he had never spilled so much cum before. Seeing his cum dripping so prettily of Grian's hole almost made him get hard again on the spot. Almost. But not really. It would take him a few minutes at least.
Tiredly, he fell by Grian's side on the bed.
“That was… Amazing. Thank you, Scar.”
“No, thank you.”
“Me?”, Grian let out a chuckle, “I did nothing!”
“Well, you trusted me enough to do this. And it was amazing.”
“…I guess. Still. Thank you.”
“Thank you.”
“Thank you.”
“Thank y-”
“Okay, that's enough.”, Grian interrupted. Both of them laughed and shared one last languid kiss to settle the matter. “Do you still have some energy? I would love to take you on my pussy.”
“Maybe in some five minutes, but- I can't take your pussy, I just took your ass!”
“And?”
“Oh, G! I see I need to teach you a lot more than I expect… You aren't supposed to have vaginal penetration after anal penetration! It gets yucky! Can get you an infection and stuff!”, Scar didn't know the proper terms and science, but at least he knew it was wrong.
“Oh. Danm. I guess some other day, then.”
“Yeah… I'll happily do it another day.”, Scar said as he leaned for another kiss. “By the way, I can't believe you still have the energy for more after all that!”
Grian laughed. “It's because I really liked it.”
Scar gave him a sweet smile. “You don't know how happy I am to hear that.”, one last kiss was shared before Scar started to make movements to get up. “Now, let's go. Let's get you cleaned! This is another important lesson, by the way! You always need to clean yourself after sex.”
After a some protest, Grian finally got up so Scar could help cleaning and teaching him a thing or two about after care.