Work Text:
"Ugh!" Lucy groaned tossing her things on the counter and slamming her door shut. "What was Levy thinking!?" She glared at the shiny pink bag that had been thrown with her purse.
"A gift for me? Shouldn't you be giving this to Gajeel?" Lucy had laughed when Levy handed her the Valentine's present.
Levy had chuckled while Lucy pulled out the tissue paper. "Oh, don't worry about Gajeel, I'll be giving him plenty."
Lucy had flushed a little at her comment, but the flush only grew darker at the gift. "Love... Chocolate?" Lucy's eyes had widened. "One serving equals two hours of fun- this is an aphrodisiac!"
Lucy scoffed at the memory. She knew it was just a joke, but really, what was she supposed to do with this? She grumbled further, opening her fridge to get something to eat, only for her temper to take another hit. "NATSU!" she shouted, discovering just how much he'd eaten the night before. "I guess I'm getting groceries!" She complained, stomping back to grab her purse and leaving the apartment again.
~~~
"Hi Lucy!" Natsu shouted, climbing in through her window, looking around for the girl. "Lucy?" he questioned when he didn't see her, sniffing the air to find that she wasn't home.
He shrugged, unbothered. She'd be home at some point. And this gave him a chance to raid her cupboards. If there was anything left, that is. Bounding into the kitchen, a bright pink bag caught his attention, the shiny hearts announcing its use for Valentine's Day. "To Lucy", he read off the tag, grumbling. Some guy thought he could give Lucy a Valentine's gift? Lucy deserved way more than whatever these random dudes could offer.
He shook the contents out of the bag, finding a lot of tissue paper, and... A chocolate bar! Natsu snickered. Maybe this guy wasn't so bad; at least the situation got Natsu a treat. Tearing into the packaging, Natsu didn't think twice before chomping down the whole bar, strolling back into the living room to enjoy it.
~~~
Lucy sighed as she unlocked the door and strode into the apartment, setting the food down on the counter and starting to put it away.
"Lu...cy...?" She heard a groan from the living room.
"Natsu?" she questioned, putting the food down again and finding her friend. "You sound terrible, what's- Natsu!" Lucy darted to him, curled up on her couch without a shirt, breath heavy and sweat dripping down his body. "Are you sick? Do you have a fever?" She pressed her hand to his forehead to gauge his temperature, but was taken aback when he let out a pleasured gasp and moaned at her touch. Pulling her hand away and wiping his sweat off on her shirt, Lucy frowned.
And that's when she noticed the wrapper on her floor in front of him. The packaging from the "love chocolate".
"Oh my god," she gasped, picking up the wrapper and shaking it in the hope that she was wrong and that it was still intact, but alas. The entirety of the aphrodisiac had disappeared, most likely to Natsu's stomach. "Natsu, did you eat this!?"
"Huh...?" He blearily groaned, opening his eyes to try and focus on whatever Lucy was holding, but his swimming vision made it difficult. "Your chocolate, oh yeah... I did..." he slurred. "'m sorry if ya wanted that... Can buy you more if ya want..." He mumbled, adjusting the way he lay, revealing to Lucy a large strain at the front of his pants. Lucy flushed as it hit her how much of a feverish horny daze he was in.
"Natsu, do you know what's happening right now?"
He wearily shook his head, "Not- not exactly," he replied, voice husky and dry as his breath came out in pants and his fingers awkwardly twitched, wanting desperately to grab Lucy and pull her against him and do all sorts of other things to her. Of course he knew what he was feeling- he was a healthy adult, he knew what sexual urges were and he definitely knew he felt them for Lucy. But why he felt like this right now? And so intensely that he could barely think? He didn't have a clue.
"That chocolate was an aphrodisiac! It was a joke gift from Levy!"
"Afro-wha?"
Lucy cursed at the fact she had to explain further.
"Aphrodisiac. It's... Well... It's um... somethingthatmakesyoureallyhorny!" she blurted out in a half-whisper. Natsu groaned in both understanding and confirmation of his condition. Lucy bit her lip as she watched his body tremble, his hips shaking as if they longed for something to be moving against. She'd known for a long time that her feelings for him ran deep, and even longer that he was quite attractive. Despite the awkward situation, this whimpering, horny mess in front of her was straight from her most pleasant of dreams and she couldn't help the way her body reacted, liquid heat seeping from her core.
Natsu's senses were in overdrive. The only thing he could concentrate on was her voice, her vision, her scent. Just Lucy, Lucy, Lucy. As he whiffed a particularly heavy scent from her, his eyes shot wide open again, focusing on the way her lip was caught between her teeth, growl emanating from his throat before he could consciously react. His mouth started to water, begging to taste the source of that scent as he gazed intensely at her.
His heated stare, pupils dilated and shaky, sent another wave of heat curling through her, in turn pulling another groan from Natsu as those darkened eyes flicked down her body and back up to her wide-eyed expression.
Lucy jumped up, breaking their trance. "I'll go figure out how to reverse the effects!" she squeaked, darting out to the kitchen without another word, taking the accursed chocolate's wrapper with her. "Okay, Lucy, calm down, you acting like this is not helping the situation!" she scolded herself. But her legs kept trembling, core hot and throbbing as she rubbed her thighs together unconsciously. "He's only looking at you like that because of the aphrodisiac!" she continued, lightly slapping her cheeks. "He could probably wait it out, right? I mean one serving was two hours, that's not that long... And one serving is probably the whole bar, right?" Lucy scanned the back panel of the wrapper. Her stomach dropped. "Every bar contains... 8 servings. He ingested enough for sixteen hours!?" The wrapper didn't say anything about reversing the effects, and Lucy felt tears line her eyes. Her best friend was in such a delirious, probably painful state and it was all her fault. She frantically searched her purse for her lacrima, ringing Levy's and praying to God she and Gajeel hadn't started their Valentine's plans yet.
"Come on, pick up pick up pick up- Levy oh thank god! Natsu ate the entire bar of chocolate!"
There was a beat before Levy started cackling in amusement.
"Levy! This isn't funny! Can the effects be reversed?"
"Not that I know of," Levy answered, to Lucy's dismay. "The aphrodisiac will wear off with time and leave him completely normal though, he'll be perfectly healthy. Gajeel always is."
Lucy squeaked. "It'll take all day and night for it to get out of his system, though! He's a horny mess in there, Levy, what am I supposed to do!?"
"Enjoy it?" Levy suggested with a giggle. "Come on, you two have been dancing around each other for ages. Maybe this is what you need to make that jump."
"You. Are. Not. Helping!" Lucy shouted, ending the call and slamming the lacrima on the table. Lucy sighed, rubbing her temples, bracing herself for what came next.
"Natsu?" she gently called, approaching the couch again. He responded with a whimper of her name, and Lucy twinged in guilt at how much she enjoyed the sound. "So... Levy doesn't know how to reverse the aphrodisiac. You could either wait it out..." he whined at that. "Or we could go see if Porlyusica knows of something to do?"
Natsu vehemently shook his head. "I'll wait... How long could it take?" he let out a sound that was probably meant to be a laugh, but came out more like a whine.
Lucy fidgeted with her fingers. "The whole bar could take over half a day to wear off..."
Natsu grumbled in frustration, Lucy blushing harder at the way the front of his pants were twitching, the erection inside begging for relief.
"Would you..." Lucy paused, took a breath, and started again. "Do you want me to leave?" she questioned, standing up.
Natsu's eyes flashed with panic as he grabbed her hand, the touch sending more fire through both their veins. "No! Please..." he mumbled. "If you're comfortable staying... I mean..."
"Okay," Lucy nodded, sitting back down, gently squeezing his hand. "I'm okay with staying... Since it's you."
Natsu's heart swelled at her statement, pleased to feel warmth from something besides the aphrodisiac. He gulped, nodding back. "Okay..." he rasped.
"I'm gonna go get you some water, and then if you're alright with it, we can sit on the couch together? Figure out something to distract you from... That?" She cocked her head towards his tent, Natsu nodding in reply, thankful for the offer of a drink as he realized just how dry his mouth was from his panting. Lucy left toward the kitchen and Natsu moaned uncomfortably as his body urged him to chase after. She was quick to return with a glass, helping Natsu sit up and letting him gulp it down, the cool liquid doing little to simmer the raging heat inside him.
"Thank you," Natsu mumbled, scooting over to make sure Lucy had space to sit while he lounged across the rest of her couch. "For everything."
Lucy didn't know how else to respond, and simply said, "you're welcome."
They sat in silence for a few moments, neither sure how to continue. Natsu gnawed at his tongue to prevent the groans and moans that wanted to leak out with every new wave of arousal while she blushed profusely with every little twitch of his body. He craved her touch, wanted to get down on his knees and beg for her, but he could never do that and take advantage of her kindness. So he compromised with himself.
"Lucy, could we..." he mumbled. "Could we do that thing like on the train? When you help me fall asleep?"
"When you lay in my lap and I run my fingers in your hair?" she asked, Natsu confirming with a nod. She smiled at him, sending another twitch through his cock. "Of course, if you think it'll help." She sat up, motioning for him to rest his head on her thighs, Natsu's eyes bugging out a bit as he really looked at them, her full legs hardly hidden by the miniskirt bunched up at her hips. Natsu gulped again but didn't deny his urge any longer, laying his head across the pillow of her lap. He mumbled out another thanks when she brought her fingers to his hair, combing through the strands with practiced ease, her touches leaving fire in their wake. He moaned openly, rubbing his cheek against her skin, the soft, creamy flesh warm against his face, and the source of her sweet, sweet smell so close by.
Lucy squeaked as he continued rubbing his face against her legs, quietly apologizing to him for the small yank she gave his hair in her surprise. Her core involuntarily clenched around the aching nothingness as her desire kept climbing higher. She watched as his nose flared, his mouth falling slightly open as he let out more groans.
She threw her head to the side as she continued playing with his hair, unable to watch him any longer if she wanted to keep her wits. Unfortunately for her sanity, now she had view of his hips, thrusting lightly against her couch in seek of friction. Lucy was entranced by the sight, fingers tingling and core throbbing again as her brain summoned musings of those hips moving against her. She didn't think Natsu even realized what he was doing, pleasured noises tumbling freely from his throat, his breath hot on her thigh, coming from the mouth that rested so close and yet so far from where she wanted it.
"Ngh- ah~!" Natsu suddenly cried out, hips stuttering as his eyes squeezed shut, his whole body jerking once, twice, three times before relaxing against her again. A blush rose to Lucy's cheeks as she realized what happened. She stared slackjawed at his face, having imagined in her dreams the expression he'd make when he orgasmed, but finding the real thing to be a thousand times better.
Natsu's breath came out in pants again as his body stilled and his heart rate slowed, brain struggling to catch up through the haze. He jolted when it finally did, dawning on him what he'd just done.
"Lucy, I-" he croaked, turning his face up to her but covering his eyes with his arm in embarrassment. "I'm sorry, I didn't mean to-"
"Do you want to take your pants off?" Lucy interrupted. "That can't be comfortable."
He pulled his arm away to gape up at her, a gorgeous vision in pink as she blushed, avoiding his eye contact. "Huh?"
Her cheeks burned brighter. "You- you don't have to if you don't want to, of course, I just... I'm telling you that I'm okay with that. You being naked, I mean."
Natsu gulped as he weighed his options. She was right, even his loose pants had felt impossibly restrictive to his erection, and now that there was sticky cum all over the inside of them? That just made it all the more unpleasant. Not to mention how sweat-soaked everything was from his excessive perspiration. "Yeah, I... Can I? Are you sure you'd be comfortable?"
She finally met his gaze, nodding assuredly. "Yes. I'm sure."
He didn't let himself argue anymore, desperate to be rid of the irritating clothes. Standing up on shaky legs for just long enough to shimmy his boxers and pants, groaning as they passed over his still-hard dick, he collapsed back on the couch, missing the feel of her pillowy thighs. "Thanks," he mumbled against her skin, his erection bobbing as another wave of her scent hit his nose.
She stifled a whimper when she felt his lips speak his gratitude on her thigh. "N-no problem," she stuttered, struggling to look away from his cock. She'd seen it plenty before, albeit accidentally, but never while it was fully erect. Though she had nothing to compare it to, it seemed like it was big. Would something that large even fit inside her?
Lucy tore her eyes to the other direction. This wasn't about her; it was about Natsu and this situation he'd unwittingly wandered into.
"So good..." Natsu mumbled, lips still against her thigh. "Smell so good..."
Whatever blush had managed to dissipate seared right back onto Lucy's skin. Her body was continuously leaking her arousal at this point, every new wave of her scent sending another twitch through Natsu's body and right back through her in a seemingly never ending cycle of torturous pleasure. Hesitantly, she brought her fingers back to his hair, her hands desperate to be on him in some way.
"Nngh..." Natsu shifted uncomfortably as the throbs through his center started feeling painful again. "Gah... Ugh, I..." His brain was struggling to determine what it wanted to say. "Lucy!" was the only thing clear in his mind, and his mouth responded in turn - repeating her name over and over in desperate mumbles.
"Can I touch you?" Lucy blurted out, cursing to herself when she realized she had. "I'm sorry, I just- I want to help you feel good. I want to touch more than just your hair if you'll let me."
He tried to say 'no'; she'd already done so much for him, how could he ask for more?
"Please," he whined pathetically, erection already twitching in anticipation.
Lucy nodded, hand trembling in nervousness and also excitement as she pulled it from his hair and determined what she would do. In her dreams, she'd always imagined them kissing feverishly, her hands tugging at his hair before feathering their way down his body until she was palming his dick, but kissing him felt too... Intimate, somehow. So she started by brushing her fingers across his bare chest, exploring the muscular grooves and numerous scars formed by years of battle. Natsu let out gasps and grunts at her ministrations, mouth slightly agape, a canine pulling at his lip.
When her hands reached his dick, she paused for a second, giving Natsu a chance to rescind permission, before hesitantly running a finger from top to bottom, exploring the hot appendage and then gently clasping her hand around the tip. "Ah!" Natsu shouted as his hips jumped up insistently, pushing his dick further into her hand.
Lucy pulled away, taken aback, Natsu letting out an inadvertent frustrated groan in response. "I'm- okay-" he grunted out. "Just surprised me. Your... Your hand is soft. It- it feels really nice..."
Lucy let out a breath she didn't know she was holding as her body tingled pleasantly from the complement. "Okay," she replied. "Um... Could you sit up?" This is kind of uncomfortable," she requested, referring to the way she had to stretch to reach his dick while his head still lay in her lap.
"Oh, yeah, whatever you need!" he blurted, not wanting Lucy to have any sort of discomfort with this, be it physical or emotional. He sat up to let her move, cock twitching when she sat on her knees next to him, leaning slightly over his lap to study him.
Lucy watched curiously as his erection bobbed, muscles at the bottom twitching while thick veins pulsed with every pump of blood. There was some residue left from the cum that had spilled into his pants, and some new precum was beading from the tip. Taking her thumb and swirling the fluid around, Natsu let out another loud groan as she played with his sensitive head. "It feels different from how I imagined..." she murmured. "The skin is almost... Soft..."
"Hgh-" Natsu grunted, arousal spiking as she talked. "You've- you've imagined it?"
Lucy's flush deepened when she realized she'd admitted that aloud, furrowing her brow and keeping her gaze on his erection instead of his face. "Yeah, I mean- everyone gets curious about that! You've probably imagined what, um, a vagina feels like, haven't you?"
Natsu gulped, face also reddening. "Well... Yeah..." He didn't specify that he'd imagined what her vagina felt like. Lucy gently wrapped her hand around him, experimentally bringing it up and down his shaft. "You-" Natsu choked. "You can squeeze a little harder..." he told her, sheepishly looking away, struggling to keep his sanity as she played with him.
"Like this?" she asked, wrapping her fingers slightly tighter.
"Like this," Natsu grunted, looking back down and placing his hand around hers, squeezing to the firmness he enjoyed, and started moving their hands up and down like he'd done by himself numerous times. He let more moans fall from his throat as she nodded her understanding, pulling his hand off of hers and continuing the motions, her eyes still trained intensely on his dick.
She found herself incredibly pleased by the noises tumbling from Natsu's mouth as she jerked him off, her thighs rubbing together to relieve the pulsing between them. His cock kept twitching, more precum spilling from his tip and lubricating her hand's motions.
Natsu's panting grew heavier, heart rate accelerating as he neared his climax. "Lucy, I- gah- hnng- Lucy-" he tried to warn her of the impending mess, but he could do little more than gasp and snarl. So when his dick suddenly twitched again and multiple thick, white streams shot out, Lucy was taken by surprise.
The tension in his body released, and Natsu collapsed against the couch in a slouch, closing his eyes to relieve the intense spottiness swimming in his vision while his chest heaved as he tried to breath.
His eyes shot open again when his brain started functioning. "Lucy, I'm so sorry!" he apologized, guilted by the way arousal swam through him when he saw her, his cum all over her hand and dripping down the front of her shirt. "Oh god, I tried to warn you, it just felt so good and I..."
His brain short circuited when she brought her hand up to her mouth and licked some of his cum off. She hummed curiously. "It tastes... Salty. It's not good, but it's not quite bad, either," she described, reaching to the coffee table for tissues to clean up the rest of the cum on her hand.
"You just-"
Her cheeks turned red again. "I was curious."
Natsu gulped, his lasting erection twitching again. "That was hot," he let out without thinking. Before either of them had a chance to react to his blurted statement, he continued. "Your shirt, shit I'm sorry."
Lucy looked down, grimacing at the state of her blouse. "I should probably rinse this out before it dries. Um..." She fiddled with the hem as she stood up. "Could I just... Be shirtless? In case that happens again?"
Her words hit Natsu like a punch to the gut. His eyes widened and his mouth fell open, another wave of heat shooting through him at the idea of Lucy's boobs. "You're okay with that?" he croaked, mouth suddenly dry again.
Lucy nodded. "Yeah. It wouldn't be the first time you've seen them. Heck, you've already felt them up a couple times. And I'd rather not risk... Your cum... getting on another shirt." Lucy smiled warmly at him. "I'm gonna go clean up. I'll be back soon."
"Okay," he lamely responded.
Time seemed to slow for every second she wasn't by him. He listened intently to her actions in the bathroom, turning the faucet on and rinsing out her shirt, while his body tingled, craving her presence, bracing himself for the shirtless goddess that would be coming back soon, but not soon enough.
The moment she walked back through the threshold and toward the couch, his brain fogged over, staring dumbly at her naked breasts, cock twitching erratically. He didn't know if that tiny excuse for a skirt was making his brain function worse or better than if she'd just been fully naked. The way it taunted him, giving him a glimpse of her tantalizing thighs and enticing hips, but kept him from seeing all of her made him want to rip it off so he could gaze upon her nude glory.
Lucy burned brightly at the way his intense eyes flicked across her body, drinking her in as a satisfied, dopey smile settled on his lips. "You've seen them before..." She mumbled, looking away, fiddling with her fingers to stop herself from crossing her arms over her breasts in her nervousness.
"Yeah," he murmured huskily. "Doesn't mean they're not worth staring at." Lucy's blush dusted across her chest as she gave into the urge to cover it, flustered by his compliment. "Hey, you don't have to do that, Lucy..." Natsu grabbed her arm gently and pulled her next to him on the couch. "You're gorgeous... But if you don't want me to look, I- I won't."
"It's not that I don't want you to..." she admitted. "I'm just... This is all new to me, and I'm a little nervous. But it's okay, I swear. I'm glad to do this with you."
He gulped, desire spiking again as he tried to rationalize her words, not wanting to believe it as any sort of confession beyond the immense trust she had in him as her friend. "I've never done anything like this, either. And as awkward as, um, the constant boner is, I uh- I'm glad I'm doing this with you, too." He gently rubbed her hand with his finger, wanting to throw an arm around her shoulder but unsure if that skinship would be okay with her at this moment.
"Thank you," she said, smiling warmly at him before leaning against his shoulder, sending another noticeable twitch through the dick he was trying to ignore.
But Lucy would bring his full attention to it. "Wha- what are you doing!?" he asked when he felt her fingers approach his erection.
"Well, you're not... Soft, yet... I'm still helping you, aren't I?" She asked, fidgeting with her fingers again as she waited for his answer.
He gulped. "Um, yeah, okay, whatever you want."
She nodded, and brought her hand to him again, gently wrapping her fingers near the tip to let her thumb graze his sensitive head, pleased with the sounds he let out. She stroked him a few times, exploring his cock with her fingers again. It didn't take long for more precum to spill onto her fingers, reminding her of the taste she'd gotten earlier.
"I'm gonna... Try something," Lucy said, sliding off the couch and onto her knees in front of him. He nodded dumbly and watched with bated breath as she held him, before slowly bringing her mouth to the side of his dick and carefully licking a path from bottom to top.
His hips jumped up as he gasped. "Lucy, you-" He choked on his spit and tossed his head back, hand coming to his mouth to muffle the embarrassing noises he made when she opened her lips and brought the tip of his dick inside her mouth. Her tongue swirled around his head, and Natsu did everything in his power to prevent his hips from bucking up and pushing himself further into her mouth. She pulled off, leaving a gentle kiss at his tip and exploring the rest of his erection with soft kisses and curious licks. When she wrapped her lips around him again, taking him into her mouth, she pushed herself further, taking as much of him in as she could until his tip grazed her throat, pulling a light gag from her and causing her eyes to brim with tears.
But Natsu's reaction made it all worth it. Lucy couldn't help but smile around his cock, the way Natsu moaned and whimpered and called her name while he struggled to keep his hips from moving made her arousal spike higher. Core throbbing a little painfully from her heightened desire but lack of stimulation, Lucy couldn't help but shove a hand into her panties, finding her clit and rubbing it carefully, while her other hand went to her breast, twisting and pulling at her nipple while she whimpered and moaned around his cock.
With her noises shooting pleasant vibrations through his dick, Natsu gazed back down at Lucy and nearly lost his mind. She stared lovingly up at him, eyes moist from her infrequent gags, spit leaking from her lips and lubricating his cock for her subtle movements, and her hands bringing herself pleasure. Taking a cheek into his hand and watching her close her eyes and lean into his hold, Natsu didn't even have the chance to think before he was groaning her name and spilling his cum in her mouth, Lucy moaning as his cock twitched and his hot fluid coated her tongue.
"Fuck, Lucy, that was... Fuck..." He grumbled, aftershocks still running through his body while he waited for the room to stop spinning. He felt Lucy pull off his dick, and Natsu fumbled to find something for her to spit into until watching her swallow his cum. "Fuck..." he growled at the proud, cocky smile on her face. Where had his blushing, nervous, best friend gone? "God, I lov-" he slapped a hand over his mouth, catching himself before the words could tumble out. He watched her eyes widen and her smile fall, and he cleared his throat. "God, I loved that," he blurt out instead of what he truly wanted to say. There was a flash of... Something across her expression for a split second before she put a smile back on.
"I'm gonna go get some water," she rasped, throat sore from the mild mistreatment she'd given it, and Natsu twinged in guilt that she'd done it all for his pleasure. "I'll get you some, too."
"No!" he shouted, a little too loudly. "You sit down, I'll get the water!" he grinned, wanting to do at least that much for her. "And I can throw those in the washing machine," he added, grimacing with a gesture toward his soiled pants from where they'd ended up on the floor earlier. She was taken aback, though smiled and obliged. He stood up on shaky legs, but bounded in when he got his bearings. He felt Lucy's gaze follow after him, and he couldn't help but smile in pride.
"Here you go!" he said, handing her the glass when he came back, before sitting back down and gulping his own. They sat in comfortable silence as Lucy adjusted herself to lean against his shoulder, smiling, and Natsu was determined to be content. While his erection was still going strong, they had done enough that it wasn't quite so painful as it had been, and he wasn't quite as delirious as before. As much as he wanted to do more to explore with Lucy, he would not push her any farther.
And then he remembered what she'd been doing as she pleasured him with her mouth, and the fact that she'd given him three orgasms and he hadn't given her one. He would be pushing her a little farther, after all, if she let him.
"Lucy, I wanna eat you out," he told her naturally, his sudden, intense need to get her off removing any embarrassment he might've had.
"What!?" Lucy shot up off his shoulder, skin colored pink again. She'd just been considering jerking him off again, and his words took her by surprise. "This- this is about you getting pleasure, not me!" she stuttered.
He sat up, gazing intensely into her eyes as her blush deepened from his stare. "Making you feel good would be giving me pleasure," he told her seriously. "Please let me."
She gulped. She'd imagined his mouth on her numerous times, even earlier when his head had been in her lap. But to actually let it happen? She hadn't shaved in a while, what if he thought it was gross? What if she smelled? What if-
"Please, Lucy," he begged, desperation in his eyes.
"Okay," she nodded, hesitantly, glancing away from him. "But if I smell, or if it's gross, you don't-"
He shook his head with a disbelieving chuckle. "Lucy, let me stop you right there. You smell fucking incredible, it's been making my mouth water all damn night. And there is no way I would ever find you gross. Not like this," he told her, stare unwavering as he spoke carefully and assuredly, wanting Lucy to know he wasn't kidding around. "And you just had your mouth on my dick," he laughed, trying to ease her. "My dick's gotta be way grosser than any part of you could ever be. If you didn't think it was gross to suck my dick, why on earth would I find it gross to lick your pussy?" She blushed harder at his use of such crude language. "But if you don't want me to, I won't. I won't do anything you're not comfortable with."
She smiled, her eyes crinkling with the stinging of happy tears, heart elated by the utter respect and, at the very least, friendly love he had for her. "Okay. Yes, you can, um... Eat me out..." The truly excited grin that split his lips warmed her. She'd heard tale of guys that never went down, mostly from Cana, and she supposed those stories had stuck with her as what to expect. But Natsu was always breaking her expectations, wasn't he? Of course he'd be eager to make her happy; he was there for her in every other regard, why wouldn't he be, here and now?
"I'm gonna make you feel so good," Natsu promised, determined, getting on his knees in front of her as she'd done for him. He tucked his fingers into the waistband of her skirt, glancing back up to her for permission. Once she nodded, he eagerly lifted her hips just enough to pull down her last pieces of clothing and toss them across the room, Lucy gasping in surprise as he reminded her of his strength.
Natsu gazed with hooded eyes at her weeping center as he set Lucy back down, excited smile still on his lips. Holding her thighs open, he leaned closer, taking in her scent, his cock jumping excitedly. It was... A little strange, being able to study such an intimate part of her so close, he mused. But hell if he'd complain. His most wonderful dreams of late had involved quite a bit of this particular part of her, but he'd never really known what to picture. His imaginings of Lucy's vulva were blurry, uncertain shapes based on the descriptions he'd heard and little he'd accidentally seen, but the blonde curls and wet folds in front of him now were most certainly going to haunt those dreams for the rest of his days. As if the rest of tonight wasn't already going to, he smirked to himself.
"Would you stop staring!?" Lucy squeaked, fighting with herself to keep her legs open despite her embarrassment.
He jumped, as if he'd been pulled out of a trance. "Yeah, sorry, Lucy," he chuckled shakily. Sliding a hand off her thigh, Natsu curiously slipped a finger along her folds, memorizing the feeling of her moist skin as she shuddered above him. "You're so wet..." he murmured in amazement.
"Making you feel good made me feel good," she mumbled.
Natsu smiled at the way she mirrored his own words. As he gently explored, his finger poked into her hole, Lucy shifting a little uncomfortably at the shallow penetration, Natsu's eyes dilating and a whine tumbling out when he realized what he'd discovered. Pulling his finger away, Lucy blushed furiously when he put it in his mouth, humming as he licked her fluids off. "Delicious..." he groaned. "I want more." His hot breath on her core was the only warning she had before his tongue was on her, lapping at her wetness clumsily, but oh-so-pleasantly.
"Ngh- Natsu!" Lucy gasped when his tongue swiped across her clit.
"Heh, found it," he chuckled, looking closer and seeing the little nub of flesh he'd heard was the key to women having a good time. He pressed a kiss to it before gently licking at it again and again while his strong hands forced her legs still as she unconsciously tried to pull away from the pleasure. Lucy gasped, grabbing at his hair, Natsu groaning with every accidental tug she gave it. She felt her clit pulse with every beat of her heart as she involuntarily clenched and unclenched around nothing, her walls craving something to fill them.
"Na-natsu-" she stuttered.
"Hm?" he questioned, sending vibrations through her as he wrapped his lips around her clit and sucked lightly, making Lucy shake.
"Can you- please- I-" she groaned, struggling to find the words when Natsu's tongue started exploring again.
"What do you need, Lucy?" he mumbled.
"Your- your fingers, can you- can you put your fingers inside?"
Natsu groaned headily. "Of course, whatever you want..." He shifted his hold on her, letting go of one of her legs to make use of his hand, only for it to immediately wrap around his shoulder and cause a chuckle to pass his lips. He pulled his mouth away from her, studying the movements of his finger against her skin. He carefully slid along her folds, amazed again by her wetness as she whimpered. Rubbing his finger against the hooded nub of flesh he discovered earlier, he grinned at her shuddered moans and the way her legs shook.
"Natsuuuu..." she whined, and Natsu couldn't help but groan as his cock bobbed at her desperation.
"Yeah, sorry, okay. I just like explorin' ya."
"Well, explore inside," she mumbled, cheeks bright, part of her tempted to swat his hand away and take care of herself if he didn't hurry up. He was usually reckless and launching head first into things without thinking, why was he being so slow and careful right now!?
Lucy gasped when his finger finally went down to her opening, poking carefully inside until she felt his knuckle breach, and suddenly his whole, thick, long finger was inside her, Lucy whimpering at the light stretch her virgin walls felt.
Natsu gulped, body warming when the thought came to him that he was inside her. "Now- now what?" he asked carefully, heart pounding at the pulsing around his finger, trying not to think too hard about how the tight, wet warmth would feel around another part of him.
Whining as she clenched around his finger, wiggling her hips as much as she could while his arm still held her down, Lucy replied, "Move it- in and out. Please."
He obliged with another deep gulp, in awe of the way her flesh fluttered around his finger as he pulled it out and pushed it back in, slowly and carefully. "Faster..." she whimpered. He nodded dumbly, moving a little quicker. Rubbing the pad of his finger against her walls, he smiled when he found a spot that made her gasp and wiggle even more, and focused his attention there. "Ngh- Natsu, I need-" she groaned. "I need more!"
"More?" he rasped.
"Yes, I just-" Lucy let out a whimper when he kept rubbing against that spot inside of her, but it wasn't enough. "Use two fingers, and- and use your tongue on my clit again."
Natsu moaned, never imagining before that Lucy instructing him in her pleasure would be so goddamn sexy. "Of course, Lucy." He let his middle finger join his index's exploration, lightly rubbing around her hole, goading it into allowing his second finger inside her. He pulled his finger out until just the tip was inside, then pressed the new one against her, gently, patiently pushing inward.
But Lucy didn't want patience. Taking Natsu by surprise, she thrust her hips forward, taking his fingers all the way inside, moaning at the pleasurable stretch. Natsu gaped at the sudden warmth encapsulating his fingers, the pulsing more intense and frequent than it was before.
"Natsu..." she whined at his stillness.
"Right, sorry..." He started pulling his fingers in and out, curling them to find that spot inside her again, pleased when he easily did. Remembering her second wish, he leaned back into her, tongue swiping across her, flicking against her clit erratically as he'd done before. A sharp cry left her mouth when he happened to hit her clit and her g-spot at the same time, her fingers finding their way to his hair as they sought something to grab on to in an attempt to ground herself. Natsu groaned, adoring the little tugs she gave as he worked to find his rhythm, thrusting his fingers in to match every swipe of his tongue.
"Keep going, Natsu," Lucy gasped. "Please, Natsu, please please please, yes!" Her legs shook, orgasm in reach, dots filling her vision. "Natsu...!" she shouted, yanking his hair as she tumbled over the precipice, eyes slamming shut as she threw her head back, hips bucking against his mouth while she rode the waves of her release before collapsing against the couch, boneless. She twitched as Natsu gently pulled his fingers out before giving one more lick across her slit and then sitting back up on the couch, tossing an arm around her and carefully pulling her body to rest on his shoulder.
"That was a lot of fun," he grinned at her when she opened her eyes again. Her heart beat rapidly as she gazed up at him, and it wasn't just because of her orgasm.
"Thank you," she said simply with a smile.
"I was happy to do it," he replied, eyes soft as he took in her post-orgasmic glow. "No need to thank me."
Their breaths settled as he held her, and Lucy was reminded of his "little issue" again when she noticed his dick twitch. Debating with herself on whether or not she'd make her next request, Lucy fiddled with her fingers.
"Whatsa matter?" Natsu mumbled, feeling her nerves spike.
"Can we have sex?"
Natsu gulped, biting his tongue before he could blurt out an eager 'yes'. "Are you sure?" he asked.
"Yeah," Lucy responded, a little hesitantly. "Unless you don't...?"
"Yes- I mean-" Natsu grasped her hand. "I'd love to... With you... But only if you really want to. I don't want to if you're only offering it to help me with this damn thing," he said, gesturing toward his erection with a groaned chuckle.
"Natsu, I want to. And not just because I want to help you through the aphrodisiac." She let out a shaky breath. "I've wanted to for a long time." She chose not to elaborate and Natsu didn't push her to.
"Wait... Do you have, um. Any condoms?" He squeaked. "Cuz I don't."
"I'm on a contraceptive- er, birth control potion..." Natsu didn't voice it, but she could see the 'why' in his eyes. "They help with period pain. And, uh..." She blushed. "The girls insisted, in case something like this happened between you and I..." she gestured between their naked bodies.
"Okay," he said with a gulp, deciding not to think too hard about the fact that part of her reasoning was just in case she had sex with him, specifically. Despite his nerves, the corners of his mouth couldn't help but turn up at the thought that he and Lucy were about to be connected in the most intimate way possible, and that she'd apparently thought about it before. "Should we stay on the couch or...?"
Lucy paused for a moment. "My bed," she decided. And with a nod, Natsu scooped her up in his arms and laid her down across her bed, Lucy squeaking in surprise as he carried her. She made herself comfortable, laying her head on a pillow and pushing blankets out of their way while Natsu climbed over top of her, his knees on either side of her hips while an arm above her head braced himself to gaze in utter awe at the glory below him. Lucy's eyes bright, hair fanned around her, and bare chest rising and falling with her breath, Natsu couldn't believe this gorgeous woman was allowing herself to be so close to him.
"You're so pretty," he told her with a smile, trying to ease some of their tenseness. It seemed to work, because Lucy's lips spread into a soft smile and her body relaxed. Carefully, he brought his hand to her cheek, rubbing his thumb across it, grinning down at her as he fought the urge to kiss her. That felt like a line, one he wasn't sure Lucy would be willing to cross. Instead, he rested his forehead against hers, eyes closing while their breath mingled, something familiar in an unfamiliar situation.
"Can I touch you?" Natsu asked with a shaky breath when he opened his eyes, head rising from hers, trying not to openly stare at her chest again.
"Of course you can," She nodded, breathless in anticipation as his hand grazed from her cheek to her shoulder, then down to her waist, squeezing it lightly. He gulped and nodded, palm coming up to rest against the soft skin of her breast, fingers twitching slightly as he tried to calm his eagerness at getting to touch Lucy's boobs with her blessing. He held the flesh in his palms, grasping gently as he explored the softness. Lucy fidgeted a little uncomfortably as he avoided her the firm peaks of her breasts, frustrated at the lack of real stimulation. "You- you can touch my nipples..." she explained, blushing.
Natsu nodded again, immediately following her request and pinching one between his fingers, pulling a gasp from Lucy. He kept exploring her chest, fingers wandering and pinching and squeezing, eyes zeroed in on his task while his ears focused on Lucy's reactions, trying to gauge what she liked. When he noticed her groans turn from pleasure back to frustration, he paused.
"What's wrong?" he asked, staring into her eyes with an intensity Lucy still wasn't used to.
"Nothing!" she squeaked. "I just- you said- we're supposed to be having sex and you keep playing with my boobs!"
Natsu brightened at the reminder. "Sorry, yeah, I uh... I got distracted. I like your boobs."
"Clearly..." she mumbled, still flushed pink and avoiding his gaze.
"Um..." he started, hand leaving her breast to let his finger wander across her slick folds. "How do you, uh..." He gulped again and grasped his dick, gasping when it grazed against her. "How should I put it in?"
"I... I don't know!" she flushed, her eyes squeezing shut. "I told you, I've never done this!"
Natsu gulped at the reminder that they were sharing their first time. We'd share all our times if it were up to me... he mused. "Okay, I'll uhh... I'll just do it then I guess." He let out another shaky breath as he rubbed himself against her folds again, carefully searching for her entrance. "But tell me if you're uncomfortable at all! I don't wanna do this wrong..."
She nodded, biting her lip in anticipation as she felt his dick catch against her opening.
Their breathing stopped as his tip slipped gently inside, both surprised by how little resistance there was. Lucy opened her eyes, focusing in on Natsu's arm next to her, the limb shaking as it held his body above hers.
"Lucy..." he moaned, and she finally brought her eyes up to his again, body pulsing at the heated look in his face. His eyes bore into hers, shallow breaths leaving his lips, before turning into moans as she fluttered around the head of his shaft.
She wiggled her hips, letting him slip just a little deeper into her, looking away again in her nerves. She heard Natsu's breath catch in his throat. "You... You can keep going," she told him.
"Hnng... Yeah, okay. Just wanna... Wanna make sure you're good. Don't wanna screw up." He pressed himself further inside her, still ever so slowly, and Lucy almost wanted to giggle when she looked back up at his face. His eyebrows crinkled determinedly while he grit his teeth, staring down at where their bodies connected, clearly trying to hold his urges back.
Lucy pressed her hips up, taking him all the way inside her.
"Ahhh... Hah..." Natsu moaned, stilling, losing his mind at the feeling of her flesh wrapped tightly around him, pulsing in time with their heartbeats. This was amazing. This was perfect. Holy shit, he couldn't believe just how good it felt. Natsu never imagined he was missing a whole lot when he heard his guild mates discussing their bedroom endeavors, but now? He wanted time to stop, so he could stay right here, connected in the most intimate way with the woman he loved, forever.
Lucy sighed wistfully as she got used to the stretch, pleased by the complete lack of the pain she'd been expecting. It felt different, but so so right. She couldn't believe she'd gone so long without the feeling of him inside her, and she didn't know how she'd go without it once this night was over and their friendship went back to normal. Her heart clenched at the reminder of the situation. Was there any possibility they would do this again? Natsu certainly seemed to be enjoying it so far, but maybe that was just the aphrodisiac's doing.
She willed away her train of thought. No use thinking about tomorrow. Lucy was going to enjoy this moment.
"Natsuuu..." she whined when he kept still for a little too long. "Can you please move?"
"Yeah, just... Gimme a sec. Tryin not to embarrass myself here," he told her, meeting her eyes again as he cracked a small smile.
Lucy laughed lightly, bringing her hand up to hold his cheek. "I won't let you feel embarrassed. Whatever happens, happens."
His smile grew as he leaned into her hand. "Yeah. Okay." Straightening himself out and letting her hands fall to his shoulders, Natsu took a moment to breathe before pulling his hips back again, moaning while she fluttered around him, and then pressing back in once his tip was the only thing left inside. Lucy sighed contentedly, signaling to Natsu that he could continue. He smiled nervously down at her before falling into a moan as he kept thrusting in and out, slowly ramping up his speed. Lucy wrapped her legs around his hips for better leverage to match his movements, trying to help him find that spot inside her that begged for attention.
"Natsu!" she cried when he discovered it, his tip just grazing against it. Remembering how much she'd enjoyed it with his fingers, Natsu gulped and nodded, adjusting himself to better aim for her g-spot, but he couldn't quite thrust into her the way he wanted to.
"Lucy..." Natsu groaned, pausing. "Lemme try something..." She nodded, meeting his eyes, Natsu smiling at the evident trust he found in them. He adjusted his position, wrapping his arms under her torso to hold her close, their chests tight against each other, using his hold to thrust into her deeper.
"Ngh, Natsu, ah..." Lucy closed her eyes and whimpered as he kept hitting that sensitive spot while his groans and gasps tumbled from his mouth right next to her ear. The sensations were starting to overwhelm her. Her legs tightened around him as she ground up against his thrusts, chasing the high she could feel in the distance.
Natsu could feel the way she fluttered wildly around him as he kept thrusting. "Ngh- fuck." He was getting close, but he wanted her to get there first. He tried to think about what he could do to make it even better for her, but the way she kept tightening around him was making him see stars, his brain melting in the pleasure and all he could do was let out a mantra of her name.
"Natsu- I-" Lucy was struggling to say what she wanted. She was standing on the precipice and her mouth couldn't form the words. So she grabbed his cheeks and brought his face to hers in a tight kiss instead, closing her eyes to mitigate her sensory overload.
Stunned for only a second, Natsu didn't let his pattern waver for long. Eagerly returning the kiss, he kept thrusting. "Fuck, Lucy, I love you. I love you. I love you," he mumbled between his groans as he pulled back from the kiss, leaning his forehead against hers.
"I love you too!" she cried out instinctively, no longer registering the words leaving her lips, gasping as Natsu pounded deep into her. "I love you so much, so so much... Ugh, Natsu. Please, please please!" she whined, not knowing what she was pleading for.
Natsu grit his teeth. He couldn't hold back much longer. In a last ditch effort to get Lucy to crash when he did, he brought a hand down to where they were connected and stroked purposefully across her clit once, twice, three times.
And Lucy cried out as she finally released, tightening around Natsu and triggering his own. Natsu stole her lips again as they orgasmed, his hips stuttering and vision swimming. Natsu's body shook as he pulled back from the kiss to rest his head against her shoulder, chest heaving on top of hers as he recovered from the mind-blowing sex they'd just had. They didn't say anything, didn't move. Just breathed, content in each other's presence.
"That was amazing," Natsu finally croaked, pressing a kiss to her shoulder as Lucy hummed in agreement.
And then their brains started running again, recalling what they'd said to each other right before they came.
"I... Natsu..." Lucy started, trailing off, not knowing how to finish her sentence. He'd said it first, but surely he was just caught up in the moment. There was no way he saw her that way, right?
"Did you mean it?" Natsu asked, propping himself up again to look at her. "What you told me?"
Did she want to deny it? Apologize for saying it? Now that she'd said it out loud, Lucy's heart hurt at the thought of denying it any longer. And doing so would mean lying. Lying to Natsu.
"Please, Lucy, tell me," he pleaded, eyes full of desperation as he took a hand into his and squeezed it.
Lucy felt tears brimming her eyes and tore her gaze from him. "Yes..." She whispered. "I love you." That was it. He knew the truth. Their relationship would never be the same again.
"Heh," he let out a small laugh and Lucy jerked her eyes back toward him, anger beginning to flood her before she saw the wide, joyful grin on his face. She had but a moment before he was squeezing her in a tight hug again. "I love you, too!"
Lucy gaped. "You... You do? You love me?" She wanted to grin as he kept whispering confirmations in her ear and stroked her hair, leaving kisses against wherever his lips landed. But anxiety was still swimming in her gut. "Are you sure? You really love me? This isn't just because of the aphrodisiac?"
Natsu pulled back to look at her with confusion. "Of course I do, Lucy. The chocolate just made me more horny for you than I already am anyway," he chuckled, an embarrassed blush rising to his cheeks. "I've known I love you for a long time. I just didn't think you'd love me back."
"I didn't think you were interested in that sort of thing!" Lucy replied. "You know, romance... Love... Sex..."
"Well," he started. "I wasn't. Not until you."
Lucy's heart warmed, pink flush blooming across her skin. Before her doubts could continue to spiral, Lucy pulled him down for another kiss, but the smiles on their faces made locking lips a struggle. Both letting out giggles, Natsu asked, "does this mean you're my girlfriend?"
She grinned, wrapping her arms around his neck in a hug, unbothered by the sweat dripping from him to her. So content in his presence, her anxiety from moments before was simply melting away. "Yes. As long as you're my boyfriend."
"Hell yeah," he chuckled. "And we get to keep doing this?"
Lucy let out a laugh. "We damn better." He grinned and gave a playful grind of his hips, but the movement suddenly reminded them that he was still hard inside of her. "You've still got..." Lucy glanced at her clock. "About 14 hours yet on that aphrodisiac. Wanna keep going now?" she asked with a cheeky smile.
Natsu grinned as his eyes lit up, energy flowing through his veins again at the prospect of more sex with his new girlfriend, the love of his life. "Anything you want, Lucy."
~~~
"Gajeel!" Levy giggled as she sat up, recovered from her latest orgasm of the night, kicking his hands away while she got out her lacrima phone. "Stop, I gotta call Lucy!"
Gajeel groaned, flopping next to her. "Yeah, yeah. I'm telling you, though. She's gonna be busy," he told her, waggling an eyebrow at the word 'busy'.
"For their sake, I hope they are," she laughed. "But she was really freaked out earlier, I wanna make sure she's okay. That they're both okay." Dialing while Gajeel continued to grumble about his 'little dragon' in need of attention, Levy tossed a pillow at him and gave a cheery 'hello' when Lucy picked up.
"Oh, Levy," she heard Lucy rasp. Lucy cleared her throat. "Hi, Levy, now's really not a gr-EAT TIME!" Lucy's sentence was punctuated by a shriek, a thump, and then an absolutely sinful moan of Natsu's name. Gajeel laughed at Levy's reddening face.
"I just wanted to check on you," Levy squeaked at the continued groans and pleads she could hear in the distance. That light thump she'd heard must've been the phone dropping. Lucy would probably not be back on the phone anytime soon. "But it sounds like everything's good there okaybye!" Levy slammed her lacrima down, face burning.
"Salamander and Bunny Girl fuckin'?" Gajeel asked with an amused chuckle. Levy simply nodded. "Good. Now that you have your answer, can we?" he asked with a salacious grin. Levy giggled, catching his lips before nodding again and shrieking as he pounced on her.