Chapter Text
When Augustus told you what had happened you couldn't help but laugh. Only he would male such a proposition to his crush. You thought about turning down what had been offered but the idea of having a spectator to the kind of debauchery you had Augustus got up to was too alluring to give up. Plus, Chosen was attractive. Maybe you really did just have a type.
Chosen was invited to your apartment given that you were the only one who lived alone. When he arrived he had the most delicious blush on his face. It matched Augustus. 'You sure you want to do this?' You ask Chosen, knowing that if Augustus asked him it would probably be seen as a challenge.
He nodded as you led him to your bedroom.
'Okay, just know you can tap out at any time. And you really don't have to do this if you don't want to.' You felt like you had to make it as clear as possible that he wouldn't be judged if he didn't want to go through with this.
'I do!' The Chosen said, wincing at how eager he sounded. It was fine. He clearly only wanted to show how impressive his self control was. The fact that he'd been thinking about this moment for the last few days, waking up humping his pillow had nothing to do with it. He hadn't cum from it anyway, so his standing within the nofap community was fine.
Augustus was sat in a chair you had positioned to face your bed. Neither of you looked any different from usual and Chosen wasn't sure what he was expecting.
'Hey buddy, been keeping your seat warm for you,' Augustus smiled; you could see the nerves in his eyes. He had been buzzing with excitement all day. To prevent things from ending too early he had already jerked off this morning, twice, while on call with you.
'Freaking weirdo,' Chosen muttered under his breath as he took a seat after Augustus stood and offered it to him.
'Uh-uh, pants off baby boy.'
'Wh-what?' The Chosen replied to Augustus' request.
'Can't have you hiding anything. Or getting off from the friction,' Augustus winked. Even if he had been nervous when thinking about this, he got a lot more confident when in sexual situations, a dominate side of him taking over.
You could feel your underwear getting damp as he ordered The Chosen around.
'Fine,' Chosen rolled his eyes and tried to ignore the way his hands were trembling. If he was going to see the both of you naked it was only fair. Chosen let his khakis and underwear fall to his ankles to reveal his already hard cock.
Your mouth watered at the sight. He wasn't as long as Augustus but he was thicker. Augustus was also staring, wishing his could wrap that beautiful cock in his hand but that wasn't what there were here for. Not today at least.
He took advantage of your distraction, turning your head towards him.
'Like what your seeing?' Augustus asks, a smirk on his face. This was his chance to get back at you for teasing his about his crush.
You nod your head, eyes glancing back and forth between Chosen's hard-on and the intense look in Augustus' eyes.
'More than mine?'
Deciding to be a bit of a brat you act as if your thinking about it even though you know what he wants to hear. You turn your face towards Chosen and Augustus roughly grasps your face and turns you back to him.
'Looks like someone needs a reminder on how to be a good girl. You're mine,' he leans in to give you a possessive kiss and the word 'mine' is repeating itself in your mind. It shouldn't mean anything but you let yourself bask in the idea.
'Yours,' you whisper against Augustus' lips when he pulls away from you. Your hands make there way to his belt, unbuckling it with ease. His hands roamed under your t-shirt, slowly making his way up until he undressed your torso, revealing that you weren't wearing a bra.
The Chosen could feel his heart racing at the scene in front of him. His cock was leaking, making a mess of his three wolves moon shirt. Shuddering breaths filled the room as he tried to remain silent but failed.
Augustus began kissing down your neck, making his way to your chest while you removed his purple and black plaid shirt. His t-shirt underneath had some anime character on it and Chosen tried to distract himself by trying to remember all of the many animes Augustus had described to him to see if he could determine the character. However, he was brought out of his thoughts when he heard you gasp as Augustus sucked on your breast, leaving behind a dark pink mark. Augustus smiled at his work before looking Chosen dead in the eyes. A large amount of precum spilled from The Chosen who couldn't hold in a breathy moan at how dark Augustus' eyes looked.
After finishing undressing Augustus pinned you to the bed, he held your wrists tightly about your head as he continued marking up your neck before making his way back down your body. Your mouth went slack with pleasure as Augustus licked your clit; fingers teasing your pussy.
Chosen sat, fist clenched as he watched desperately. He wasn't going to touch himself. The last time he had actually touched himself was about two years ago. The last time he came was three months ago in his sleep after a particularly x-rated dream about Augustus.
'Fuck Augustus,' you pull at his long hair as he sucked on your clit, his fingers now deep inside you as he sissored you open.
Chosen watched as Augustus brought you over the edge multiple times. Your moans had become almost silent pleas begging for more even as you became overestimated. You'd pulled at Augustus' hair so much it had fallen out of its usual messy ponytail. The Chosen had never realised how pretty Augustus' hair was, but he also wished it hadn't covered Augustus' face so much. Maybe if he angled himself differently he'd be able to see better but he felt like if he moved it would all be over. A part of him wanted to walk over and get involved in the action but he knew he'd blow his load immediately and embarrass himself.
Instead he watched helplessly as you switched positions with Augustus so you were on top of him. Now he could really take in the sight of Augustus' body. Chosen didn't know if he'd rather be on top or beneath Augustus, or maybe inbetween the both of you.
His cock pulsated again, his cock was glistening and his t-shirt was becoming so damp he could feel it sticking to him.
'Gonna put on a show for Spencer baby girl?'
Chosen normally didn't like when people called him by his 'real' name, putting up with it from Brianna because they'd been friends since childhood. It didn't sound bad coming from Augustus either, especially now. He wondered how it would sound if you said it.
You sank down on Augustus' cock, taking him all at once. If Chosen had been more coherent he would have commented that it was impressive but all thoughts had lost his mind as he saw both of your expressions of pleasure. The way that Augustus' cock slid in and out of you. The noises you both made as you grew closer to orgasm.
Chosen's hips bucked into the air as he came uncontrolled, a loud sound of pleasure that could be described as more of a roar than a gasp or moan left his lips. The sound alerted the two of you and upon realising what had happened and seeing the state of The Chosen covered in his own cum, you both reached your peak soon after. You'd never seen someone come untouched before.
Taking a moment to catch your breath, you then climb off of Augustus wincing at the loss of him. The Chosen looked fully fucked out, still shaking slightly, his eyes glazed over.
'Looks like I win,' Augustus commented, looking pleased with himself. You roll your eyes.
'Nah, he didn't touch himself. Totally didn't count,' you reply, pulling your clothes back on before making your way to the closet to grab something for Chosen since his t-shirt was ruined. You pass him one of Augustus' t-shirts that reads 'EAT SLEEP ANIME REPEAT'.
'Y-yeah she's right,' Chosen huffed out as he cleaned himself up with his gross shirt. He felt embarrassed about what had happened but that was also the best orgasm of his life. Plus, the way that Augustus was looking at him had his cock twitching, trying to get hard again. He pulled on his boxers to try and hide it.
'Guess we'll just have to do this again then,' Augustus challenged.
'Or you could just finally get together,' you sighed. This was fun but you didn't want to keep being the middle man between them.
'Oh, I... Is that what you want?' Chosen looks at Augustus.
'I guess,' Augustus explained that he wanted the same thing as with you.
'I don't need a label for it. There's a lot of pressure with the word relationship and I'd get too in my head. I just know I like you in the same way.'
His words hit you with such a force that you felt yourself tearing up. It hadn't occurred to you that what Augustus felt for you was more than friendship and he just had his unique way of showing that. You had been so ready to accept losing this special connection you had with Augustus so that he could be with Chosen. The idea that he only wanted to add to your dynamic filled your heart with joy.
'Yeah, I'd like that too,' Chosen admits with a smile.
'We definitely need to talk about this more,' you begin before getting cut off by a yawn.
'I don't know about you guys, but I'm beat, so, snuggles.' You drag the two of them to your bed.
'Anything for m'lady,' Augustus says as he climbs in.
Chosen is just watching you two, unsure about what to do before you pull him over.
'We're gonna have so much fun with you later,' you whisper in his ear, running a hand up his t-shirt and then raking your nails down his stomach. He shivers at that before getting comfortable in your bed, immediately turning his face down towards the pillows to hide his blush, then he realised that his sunglasses are digging uncomfortably into his face.
With a little hesitation he removes them and places them on your bedside table. It was weird. You'd gotten so used to seeing him constantly wearing his sunglasses you hadn't realised you hadn't even seen his eyes.
'Beautiful baby boy,' Augustus said sleepily.
'Agreed,' you reply as you snuggle next to Chosen who mutters a 'shut up' at the compliments, not used to it.
Yeah, playing with him was definitely going to be fun, you think as you cuddle into him. Augustus has a arm over the Chosen, reaching you and holding your hand. Chosen knows he's basically trapped there between you. Of course he could get out, but he doesn't want to.