Work Text:
It’s the evening of Toni’s 22nd birthday, and her friends have insisted that she let them throw her a party. Toni of course refuses, but she should have known better than to think that her best friend, Fatin, would accept no for an answer.
At four that afternoon, Toni was slobbed out on her couch watching reruns of her favorite shows. A loud knock echoed through her apartment, Fatin’s signature greeting being screamed through the wooden door.
“Open up, bitch!”
“Fatin, I wish I could say I was surprised.” Toni rolled her eyes, letting her friends in. Fatin sat down 2 bottles of champagne, Dot, Martha, Leah, Rachel, and Nora carrying the rest of the party supplies and Bluetooth speakers for music.
“I told her you said no, but you know this one. Can’t let a birthday go uncelebrated.” Dot said, shrugging.
“As long as it’s just us, it’s cool. I just don’t want a big thing.”
“Fine. But you’re changing.” Fatin said, pushing her sunglasses up onto the top of her head, raising a disapproving eyebrow at Toni’s current attire.
“Why? These are my favorite pants.” Toni frowned, looking down at herself.
“They’re spider-man fleece pajama pants, Toni. Even your standards must be higher than that.”
“Excuse me for wanting to be comfortable in my home on my birthday.”
Fatin ignored her, grabbing her wrist and tugging her down the hall into her own room. Toni was pushed down on her bed while Fatin dug through her wardrobe.
“Do you have anything in here that isn’t athleisure?”
Toni scoffed. “I don’t make fun of the amount of animal print you have, don’t make fun of my shit.”
“Try this on.” She ignored Toni’s jab as she tossed a long sleeve shirt and boyfriend cut jeans at her.
Toni got dressed, looking for Fatin’s approval, but Fatin just wrinkled her nose.
She threw another outfit at Toni, only to get the same reaction.
This happened no less than 5 times before Toni cut her off. “Whatever you pick next, I’m wearing. I"m not changing again. You guys have seen me in my worst clothes, why does this even matter?”
“You’ll thank me later, Toni. Here, this is the one.”
She handed Toni a simple short sleeve black button up, paired with a pair of high rise jeans, her tried and true black vans finishing the look.
“Perfect.” Fatin said, happy with her final outcome.
“Great, can we go drink now?”
Fatin laughed, following Toni back out into the kitchen that the girls had managed to decorate in the time it took her to get dressed.
Toni was on her second glass of champagne, going to refill it but Dot stopped her.
“What’s wrong?”
“You, um, you probably don’t want to be drunk for the rest of the night.”
“What? Why would I not? Have you heard Leah’s karaoke? I think I have to be drunk to get through another song.”
“Yeah, sorry dude. But lucky for you, we’re heading out any minute now.”
“What?”
“Don’t ask me, this was Fatin’s idea.” Dot said, holding her hands up defensively.
Toni left her, crossing her living room to find Fatin.
“What is Dot on about? What did you do?”
Fatin frowned, looking down at her phone. “Oh! I must have lost track of time. Alright ladies, everybody out!” She yelled, the girls starting to gather their belongings to leave.
“Why are you all leaving? What’s going on?”
Fatin smirked mischievously. “Your birthday present is almost here.”
“Ok? And you can’t be here when it is?”
“When she is.” Fatin winked, heading to the door.
“She? Fatin what the fuck did you do?”
“I got you the best birthday gift you’ve ever been given.”
“Which is??”
Fatin rolled her eyes. “You really can’t take a surprise, can you? We hired you a private dancer, T. Relax, go sit down. She’ll be here soon.”
Toni’s jaw dropped, stunned as she watched Fatin laugh loudly, shutting the front door behind herself and leaving Toni alone.
Toni was fine, really, she wasn’t freaking out at all.
At least, she convinced herself of that. It was a lap dance, so what.
She was sure of that for all of a minute and a half before she felt the anxiety wash over her and she ran to grab her phone, dialing Fatin.
“Bitch, I told you to chill out. You’ve been single for 10 months. It’s time you move on.”
“Ok, maybe you’re right, but I’m not moving on with a sex worker. I’ve never even had a lap dance! Why would you spring this on me?”
“Toni, she isn’t a sex worker. She’s a dancer. And don’t hold your breath on that moving on thing, you might be surprised.”
“Fatin, I have no idea what I’m doing. Should I change clothes? Do I offer her a drink? Do you think she would want some of the cake?”
“Toni, you look hot. Please god don’t change after I worked so hard on your outfit.”
“Ok but what -“
Three soft raps landed on her front door, silencing her.
“Fatin, what do I do??”
“Take a deep breath, and enjoy yourself. Happy birthday, T. Use protection!” Fatin yelled, laughing as she hung up, leaving Toni to go let the woman in.
Toni smoothed her hair down, trying to act natural when she opened her door.
Toni’s eyes bulged nearly out of her skull when she recognized Shelby fucking Goodkind standing outside of her apartment, wearing a long black coat. Black satin gloves, sheer black leggings and black lace covered heels were the only visible parts of her outfit.
“Shelby? What are you doing here? I haven’t seen you in years.” Toni said, standing frozen in her doorway.
“Fatin hired me?” Shelby said, a bemused look on her face.
“Fatin hired you?”
Shelby smirked, “So, can I come in?”
Toni opened the door wider, stepping to the side as Shelby walked in, looking around Toni’s space.
She looked so different from the girl Toni, albeit begrudgingly, had a crush on in high school. Her hair was more natural, down flowing with a simple braid framing each side of her face.
Her usually simple makeup was now edgier,
chunky black wings lining her eyes.
More jarring than anything, Shelby was now carrying herself with more confidence. She was friendly to everyone at school, but she was always under Andrew’s arm, attached to his hip. Now, she seemed to have taken ownership of herself. She was hot, and she knew it.
"Of all the ways I thought about meeting you again, this was not remotely on the list…”
"So, you"ve thought about meeting me again?" Shelby cocked her head, smiling at Toni.
“… I just admitted that, didn"t I? My, uh, my brain isn"t quite working at full power right now."
"Whatever could be distracting you, Toni?"
Shelby teased, slipping her coat off her shoulders revealing a black corset top and the shortest fucking black shorts Toni had ever seen.
Shelby laid her coat over the back of a chair in Toni’s living room, straightening it out and turning to fully face her.
Toni’s eyes scanned Shelby’s body, having a hard time believing that this was the same girl she last saw 4 years ago in the halls of their high school.
“You really have to ask that?” Toni asked dumbly, her throat closing as Shelby crossed the room, a finger on her chest pushing Toni down onto the couch.
“Consider me curious. We can circle back to that.”
“Fuck.” Toni cursed under her breath, watching as Shelby sat beside her. Her hand reached for Toni’s, pulling it into her own lap and gently tracing up and down her fingers.
“We need to talk before we begin. What are you comfortable with?” Shelby asked, her words sounding formal, but her tone casual, soothing.
“Me?”
Shelby giggled. “Yes, I’ll be undressing throughout if that’s ok with you -“
“Yes” Toni said, too quickly.
Shelby chuckled. “I figured as much, but are you comfortable with me removing yours as well as we progress? It’s completely ok if you want to stay clothed, won’t bother me a bit.”
“I… yeah. Yeah that’s fine. I can too.”
Shelby bit her bottom lip, nodding as her eyes fell down Toni’s body, slowly looking back up.
Toni felt frozen under her gaze, thankful that Shelby kept talking because she wasn’t sure she would be able to right now.
“You’re not allowed to kiss me, but you have free reign from my chest to my neck. However, only when I give you the go ahead. Are you comfortable with the same for you?”
Toni nodded quickly, her lips parted as she sucked in slow, deep breaths.
Shelby smiled, releasing her hand. She stood, walking to her coat and taking her phone out. She locked eyes with Toni as she slowly pinched her middle fingertip, pulling one of her gloves off, then doing the same to the other hand. She started a premade playlist as well as a 60 minute timer, walking back over to Toni, who was still stuck, mind unable to catch up to the scene unfolding in front of her.
Shelby took her place in front of Toni, starting to sway gently to the music.
“So, how about those distractions?”
Toni’s brows knit together, entranced by the way Shelby was already feeling the music and having a hard time comprehending what she was asking, so Shelby asked more clearly.
“I told you we’d come back to them, did I not? I’m waiting.” She said in a sing-song voice, snapping Toni’s eyes from her gyrating hips up to her face.
“Right. Um, your eye makeup is different. Makes your eyes even more intense than I remember.”
Shelby raised her eyebrows. “My eyes? That’s what’s distracting you?”
“Fuck, Shelby. I don’t want to be, like, a creep ogling you.”
Shelby smiled, stopping dancing and leaning forward, hands on the back of the couch on both sides of Toni’s head.
She knew what she was doing, knew that it would cause her breasts to take up Toni’s entire field of vision.
“You’re not a creep, Toni. You’re allowed to say what’s really on your mind. Don’t hold back for my sake, alright?”
Toni licked her lips as her eyes dropped to Shelby’s chest, nearly spilling out over the top of her corset. “You’re perfect.” She blurted, taking note of the momentary drop in Shelby’s demeanor, softening for a beat but she slipped back into her persona quickly.
“Not exactly as… graphic… as I was expecting, but it’s a start.”
Shelby stood back up, closing her eyes as she started to really feel the music, running her hands from her thighs up her stomach, cupping and squeezing her chest. She threw her head back, letting out a soft sigh.
Toni’s eyes couldn’t decide where to look. She watched as Shelby’s body moved smoothly, effortlessly. Yeah, this was her job, but fuck she was good at it.
“What else, Toni?” She asked, facing away from her and bending forward, grinding in between Toni’s spread legs for a few beats before slowly righting herself.
Toni licked her lips, entranced. “Um… I really want to touch you right now, kind of all I can think about”
Shelby smirked. “Not yet.”
Toni grunted disapprovingly, having to tuck her hands under her own thighs to prevent herself from reaching out.
Shelby hooked her hands into her shorts, watching over her shoulder as Toni’s eyes fell to her ass as her pink thong was revealed.
Shelby stepped out of her shorts, holding them out to her side, dropping them to the floor.
She backed closer to Toni, shaking her ass rhythmically for a few beats, shifting to grind against her thighs to the beat of the song playing softly in the background.
Shelby could hear Toni’s breath hitch when she backed more firmly into her lap, considering giving her some freedom to touch her, but decided to tease her a bit more first.
Shelby sat up, fully sitting in Toni’s lap. She spun to the side,her arm falling around Toni’s neck and playing softly with the baby hairs at the nape of her neck. “Do you want to take my top off, Toni?”
Toni’s jaw dropped, nodding incessantly.
Shelby stood, smirking at Toni"s huff, but turned to straddle her before she could complain. She smiled proudly as she watched the muscles in Toni’s arms twitch, desperate to touch her.
“Then take it off.” She said, seduction dripping in her words.
“But you said I couldn’t -“
“Toni. Take my top off.” Shelby said, voice lowering an octave, sounding more assertive than she had even intended, but it did the trick.
Toni"s hands shakily grabbed the hem of Shelby’s tight black corset, frowning when she realized how unforgiving the material was.
“How do I…?”
Shelby smiled fondly. “Back zipper.”
Toni’s brow furrowed in concentration as she reached around Shelby’s back, moaning low in the back of her throat when she felt the cool zipper under her fingers. She could feel her arousal growing as the teeth slowly but surely separated, finally reaching the bottom.
The only thing keeping Shelby’s upper half clothed was Toni’s hands on her sides, holding her top up until she checked one more time.
“Are you sure?”
“Toni, I’m all for consent, but please take it off.”
Toni let out a low growl, recognizing the desire in Shelby’s tone, feeling much less anxious about this all realizing this might not be so one-sided.
She let go of her hold on the fabric, letting it fall between them. Shelby took it, dropping it behind her.
“You have a nipple piercing.” Toni said, mesmerized, eyes glued to the small bar of metal glinting in the low light of the room.
“You like it?”
“Fucking sexy.” Toni said, her hand instinctively reaching to touch it, but Shelby shook her head no.
“But, you -“
“Never said you could touch, baby. Just wanted some help with the zip.”
Baby
Toni felt a heat coil in her lower belly, an uncomfortable wetness starting to seep into her boyshorts.
Ok, so apparently Toni’s into pet names. Or maybe she’s just into Shelby. Either way, she forced her hands back to her sides, gripping the cushions under her because she wasn’t sure she could stop herself from touching Shelby otherwise.
“Good girl.” Shelby whispered into her ear, starting to move her hips with the song, her own hands coming up to pinch and tug at her nipples, toying with the barbell piercing in her left.
“Yours?” Shelby asked after the song finished, transitioning to the next, dropping her hands to the buttons of Toni’s shirt.
Toni nodded, reaching down to help but Shelby stopped her.
“I’ve got you.” She said, holding eye contact with Toni as her fingers worked down her button up, eventually sliding it off her shoulders, leaving it bunched up behind her back.
Shelby could see by the third button that Toni wasn’t wearing a bra, but it was different once she pushed it fully off, once she saw Toni’s bare chest on display for her.
Shelby could feel her resolve slipping, but she had to keep at least some semblance of professionalism. Her blunt fingernails traced the lines of Toni’s abs, making their way up to her chest.
Shelby lifted an eyebrow, a silent question which Toni was more than happy to answer yes to.
Shelby kneaded softly at first, palming her until she felt her nipples stiffen, rolling and pinching them between her fingers.
“What else, Toni?”
“I- What?”
“Surely your list wasn’t finished already. What else is distracting you?”
Toni shook her head, trying to focus, but her eyes were locked onto Shelby’s long, skilled fingers. One hand working on Toni’s chest, the other on her own.
“Come on, Toni. What else?” Shelby prompted.
“Um… I really like your piercing.” Toni said mindlessly, watching as Shelby tugged it a little harder.
Shelby laughed. “Try again.”
“Fuck, it’s incredibly distracting that you’re you.”
Shelby’s hips lost their rhythm as she leaned back to look at Toni. “What do you mean?”
“God, Shelby. I… do I have to say this right now?”
Shelby leant forward, kissing and nibbling softly across the underside of Toni’s jaw to the shell of her ear. “You don’t have to say anything, but I’d love to know. Might persuade me to let you touch me if you do.” Smiling against her skin when she heard Toni’s frustrated huff.
“I had this embarrassingly huge crush on you in high school.” Toni admitted quickly, feeling her whole chest heat up with embarrassment.
Shelby stopped completely, sitting back to meet her eyes. “You what?”
“Don’t make me say it again.”
Shelby bit down hard on her bottom lip, glancing back at her phone.
Toni felt like her heart dropped down to the pits of her stomach, nausea washing over her. She shouldn’t have admitted that, not while they were both here, half dressed, Shelby in nothing but that skimpy thong.
Toni’s cheeks flooded with heat. “Shelby, I’m so sorry. If you’re uncomfortable now its fine if we -“
Shelby looked at her, confused. “What?”
“If you don’t want to do this now that you know I was into you, I get it.”
“Toni. I can assure you that is the last concern I have right now.”
“It’s just, you looked at the timer. I thought you were hoping we were almost finished.”
“Oh, I was hoping the timer was almost up, but not for that reason.”
“You- what?”
“I can’t kiss you so long as I’m still within the hour I was paid for.”
Toni’s breath caught in her throat. “You mean…”
“Once that timer goes off, we are free to do whatever we want.”
“How long was left?” Toni questioned, feeling her heart pounding violently within her rib cage.
“Twelve minutes.” Shelby said, dipping her head to attach her lips to Toni’s nipple, hips starting to move with the music again.
Toni was fighting a losing battle trying to keep her back from arching and her hips from rising up into Shelby, seeking some, any friction. Her resistance just resulted in sporadic jerks of her hips that she knew Shelby was noticing, feeling her smug grin against the soft skin of her breast.
“Can I touch you yet?” Toni pleaded, hating how wrecked she sounded, but her teenage fantasies were playing out right in her face, she couldn’t help it.
“You can be patient for me, can’t you?”
“Fuck, I have been.”
“Just a few more minutes, Toni. You can wait.”
“But -“
“Believe me, Toni. I want your hands on me as much as you do. But you’re going to wait for me.”
Toni whimpered, a sound she wasn’t sure she had ever made before. She had never been with someone who took charge, bossed her around like Shelby was, but she couldn’t deny the intense effect it was having on her.
She steeled herself, letting her chest arch more firmly into Shelby’s mouth, an attempt to have some control in the situation, but Shelby tsked disapprovingly. She removed herself from Toni’s lap, standing in front of her.
Shelby leaned over her, lips brushing her earlobe. “Gonna take your pants off. That ok?”
Toni groaned, but nodded. She let her head fall back onto the couch, but kept her eyes trained on Shelby, watching as she popped the button and pulled the zipper down.
She looked back up at Toni, confirming that she was comfortable with Shelby removing the article. Toni answered by raising her hips, jaw hanging slack.
Shelby couldn’t help but glance down between Toni’s slightly spread legs, taking note of the dark patch there.
“Must be better at my job than I realize, I’ve hardly touched you, Toni.” She teased, having a little too much fun watching Toni squirm in front of her, but Toni took it the wrong way.
“I. Um, sorry… It’s just been a while.”
“What?” Shelby asked, her palms resting on top of Toni’s thighs as she looked up at her.
“I haven’t… I’ve been single for almost a year. And I’ve never done anything like this. I’m just… I’m really into this, Shelby. But you already knew that.”
Shelby bit her lip, smiling much more softly than the moments prior. She reached for Toni’s hand, bringing it to her lips and placing a sweet kiss to each of her knuckles.
“Toni, there’s nothing wrong with being turned on from this. I promise you, I’m no better.”
Toni’s mouth went dry, she knew Shelby said she wanted to kiss her, but if she was turned on too did that mean…
“C’mere” Toni mumbled, pulling on Shelby’s hand that was still holding her own, Shelby straddling her once more. Toni guided Shelby’s hand to the couch behind her head, dark eyes locking.
“How much longer is on that fucking timer?” She groveled, letting her hand trace down Shelby’s forearm beside her head before dropping it back to the couch, knowing she couldn’t touch her just yet.
Shelby looked behind herself, sucking in a quick breath.
“9 seconds.” She whispered, sounding as needy as Toni felt.
Toni licked her lips, needing to ask one more time. “I can kiss you?”
Shelby’s throat bobbed as she swallowed. “When the timer ends.”
Toni nodded. “How much longer?”
“Three.” Shelby mumbled, eyes locked on Toni’s plump lips.
The timer echoed through the apartment, Toni’s hands shooting straight to Shelby’s cheeks and crashing their mouths together. They both groaned, Shelby’s hands grasping the base of Toni’s neck, a fruitless attempt at bringing their mouths even closer.
Shelby flicked her tongue at Toni’s bottom lip, but couldn’t resist teasing her once more.
“You have the freedom to touch me however, wherever you’d like, and you chose to hold my cheeks? How PG of you, Toni.”
Toni scoffed, feeling challenged. She let her fingertips slip to the back of Shelby’s head, trailing down her bare back all the way to her ass.
She squeezed roughly, pulling Shelby’s hips flush with her own. “These cheeks better?” She teased, nipping at Shelby’s bottom lip.
“Oh my Lord, you’re so corny.”
Toni mumbled against Shelby’s lips. “Only for you.”
Shelby’s heart was beating out of her chest as she pulled back, searching Toni’s eyes.
“I need you to know before we go any further. This has nothing to do with me being paid. I’m here now because I want to be. This is completely separate from my work, only about us.”
Toni nodded, her hands moving around to Shelby’s hips, fingers splayed across her lower back.
“I want you here, Shelby. I just have so many questions.”
Shelby pursed her lips. “I’ll answer any questions you have… after.”
She dipped her head, attacking Toni’s neck with her lips, biting and sucking across the column of her throat.
Toni let her head fall back, fully submitting herself to whatever Shelby wanted. Her hands drifted around to Shelby’s front, moving at a snail"s pace up her abs until she held the full weight of her breasts in each of her hands.
Shelby sighed against her, her hips starting to rock against Toni once more. They picked up intensity when Toni swiped her thumb over her piercing, eliciting a moan from Shelby.
“Feels so good, Toni.” She said, fully chasing her own release now. Toni could tell she was getting closer, so she threaded her fingers through Shelby’s hair, tugging her lightly away from her neck.
She leaned forward herself, her hands keeping a solid hold around Shelby’s waist as she kissed down her throat, scraped her teeth across her collarbone, nipped and sucked all across the swell of her breast until finally her lips wrapped around Shelby’s nipple.
She had never been with a girl with a piercing like this, wasn’t sure what felt good and what was too much, but Shelby seemed to like it when she traced it with her finger, so she tried with her tongue.
Shelby moaned loudly above her, tugging harshly on her hair to hold her in place.
Ok, so that’s a good thing. She noted, sucking lightly on it next, letting her left hand come up to pinch and flick at her other nipple.
Shelby’s moans grew louder.
Ok, so that’s even better.
Toni kept her ministrations, licking and sucking across Shelby’s chest. She felt Shelby’s hips grind down incessantly before feeling the bump of Shelby’s knuckles against her stomach, beginning to touch herself.
Toni grunted disapprovingly, pulling her mouth away from Shelby’s chest.
Shelby frowned, complaining when Toni’s fingers wrapped around her wrist, pulling it away from her center.
“I want to touch you, Shelby. Let me?”
Shelby nodded quickly, trying to pull Toni’s hand down to quell the ache between her own thighs, but Toni had other plans.
“Can I take you to bed?” She asked quietly, sighing contentedly when Shelby nodded, eyes never leaning Toni’s.
Shelby kicked her heels off before standing, taking Toni’s hands and leading her away from the living room and down the hall. She had every intention of going to Toni’s room, but as she looked at Toni and saw the unfiltered desire on her face she couldn’t help but push her into the wall, kissing her, hard.
Toni made a choked sound of surprise low in her throat, but came to her senses when she felt Shelby’s tongue melding with her own.
Shelby pushed her back flush against the wall, nudging her legs apart with her knee and slotting her thigh between.
Toni’s head fell back against the wall with a loud thud, but the groan she released was all pleasure, no pain.
“Shelby, I want -“
Shelby cut her off with her lips, kissing her roughly as her thigh alternated applying pressure and taking it away. She began sinking to her knees, kissing down Toni’s abs, hands reaching up to massage her breasts.
She looked up at Toni as she placed a soft, barely there kiss at the elastic of her underwear. Toni knew if she let this go on any longer that her plan would be out the fucking window so she bent her knees, cupping Shelby’s cheeks and pulling her back up.
“Let’s go to my room.” Toni said, praying that Shelby didn’t argue because she didn’t have the willpower to stop her again.
Shelby kissed her, nodding as their lips slotted together. She reached down Toni’s body, wrapping her hands under her thighs and lifting her effortlessly, Toni’s legs locking around her waist.
She took a few steps forward, never breaking their kiss, but slowed to a stop.
“Second door on the right.” Toni spoke against her lips, letting go of Shelby’s neck with one hand to twist the knob. Shelby kicked it the rest of the way open, walking them to Toni’s unmade bed and sitting her down.
Toni opened her eyes, widening when she saw the state of her room.
“Fuck, I should have cleaned up. Fucking Fatin had me try on like a dozen different outfits.”
Toni tried to sit up to at least throw her clothes back into the closet, but Shelby flattened her hand against her chest, pushing her back into the mattress. Toni’s legs were still hanging over the edge from where Shelby had sat her, but Shelby didn’t seem to mind.
She dropped to her knees right there on Toni"s bedroom floor, dark eyes looking up at her. She pressed a kiss to the inside of each of Toni’s knees, tucking her pointer finger under the band of her shorts.
Toni raised her hips, not second guessing allowing Shelby to see all of her. She kept her eyes on Shelby’s face as she removed Toni’s final layer, seeing nothing but desire.
“So perfect, Toni.” Shelby mumbled, kissing up her thighs until she was just inches from where Toni craved her.
Shelby pressed a tender kiss right under Toni’s navel before flattening her tongue, licking up her slit broadly, soaking in the taste of her.
“So good, baby.” She moaned, wrapping plump lips around her swollen clit.
Toni’s right hand threaded messily into Shelby’s hair, tugging her closer as her hips started trying to grind onto her tongue, but she caught herself, forcing her hips back down onto the mattress and letting Shelby get her there.
Her neck was aching trying to hold it up enough to watch Shelby, so she laid back, letting her eyes fall shut.
Shelby was working magic between her thighs, and Toni could feel herself teetering at the precipice, but no matter how hard she tried to let herself fall over it, she couldn"t get there, not without seeing her.
“Shelby?” She said, having to clear her throat after from how choked it sounded.
“What do you need, Toni? Do I need to stop?”
“Fuck, no. Definitely not that. Just, can you come up here?” She asked quietly.
Shelby softened, placing one more kiss to Toni’s throbbing clit before standing and pushing Toni further up the bed, settling down between her thighs.
“Better?” She asked, kissing Toni chastely.
Toni nodded, whimpering when she felt Shelby’s hand snaking between them, drawing light circles on her.
“Inside?” Shelby asked, resting her forehead against Toni’s, both damp with sweat by now.
Toni nodded quickly, staring deep into Shelby’s eyes as she coated two fingers in her slick, sinking into the knuckle. Shelby paused for a few seconds, allowing her a chance to adjust. She kept her fingers bottomed out, curling up into Toni’s front wall.
Toni clung desperately to her back, hooking her foot around Shelby’s calf to give her better leverage, bringing her hips up to meet Shelby’s hand as she began thrusting at a steady pace.
Shelby could feel her flutters around her fingers, so she went to kiss down her chest, but Toni shook her head quickly, pulling Shelby’s face back to her own and kissing her.
Shelby nodded into the kiss, focusing on angling her fingers to reach deep within Toni, her palm brushing her clit with each stroke.
“Come for me, baby?” Shelby asked gently, a stark contrast to the rough way her fingers were working inside of her, but Toni threw her head back, moaning as she finally reached her release.
Shelby worked her through it, eventually pulling her fingers out. She went to wipe them on the sheets beside Toni, but smirked as she thought of a better solution.
She slowly raised the fingers that were previously inside of her, holding them in front of Toni’s lips. She didn’t want to do anything Toni was uncomfortable with, but when she saw Toni’s eyes darken and her lips fall open, she was clear they were on the same page.
She traced across her lips, watching hungrily as Toni’s tongue darted out for a taste of herself, and Shelby couldn’t wait any longer. She pushed her fingers into Toni’s waiting mouth, moaning in the back of her throat when her lips wrapped around them, sucking roughly.
Shelby had been so focused on Toni’s pleasure that she had ignored her own, but right now, the ache came back with a vengeance. Shelby squeezed her thighs together, but it wasn’t even close to enough.
She shifted her legs, straddling one of Toni’s thighs. She started slowly, gliding back and forth against Toni’s toned muscle as she pushed her fingers in and out of her mouth in time.
She could feel the vibrations on Toni’s tongue as she moaned around her fingers, pulling them out completely when she felt herself getting closer to her own release.
Toni grabbed her hips, guiding her movements against her, pushing her thigh more roughly into her until Shelby burrowed her face in her neck, moaning into her skin, breathing heavily through her orgasm.
She caught her breath, shifting her weight to remove herself from Toni, but Toni wasn’t satisfied.
“Can you go again?” She asked, running firm hands up and down Shelby’s thighs.
Shelby gasped softly, brushing her lips against Toni’s. “I… Yeah, I can.” She whispered, letting Toni flip them over, switching their positions.
Toni kissed her passionately, getting lost in it for a few minutes. She could feel Shelby’s hips moving beneath her, so she leaned back onto her calves, running her finger along the band of her thong.
“Off?” She confirmed, slowly bringing them down her legs, running her hands up the black sheer thigh highs Shelby was still wearing.
“These too?” She asked, massaging her thighs until Shelby responded.
“If you want.” She said, ultimately leaving it up to Toni.
“Want to see all of you.” Toni mumbled, biting her lip as she gently pulled each leg free.
“I know you’ve probably heard this a million times, but you are so beautiful.” Toni said sincerely, dropping open mouthed kissed up the length of Shelby’s bare legs until she was hovering over her center, Shelby’s legs resting over her shoulders.
Toni rested her chin against her manicured curls, reaching her left hand up to search for Shelby’s, lacing their fingers together loosely and letting them fall to the mattress.
Toni wanted to tease her, wanted to draw this out as long as she could, but when Shelby’s legs fell further apart and Toni saw the sheer amount of her arousal she couldn"t resist diving right in.
She spread Shelby’s lower lips with her fingers before licking through her wetness, moaning loudly at the overwhelming taste flooding her senses. She lapped at Shelby, swallowing a few times, savoring the feeling of her on her tongue.
“You taste so fucking good, Shelby. Holy shit.” She moaned again, feeling Shelby’s grip on her hand squeeze tighter.
Her free hand found Toni’s hair, tugging a little harder each time her tongue hit just the right spot on her sensitive nub.
Toni snaked her hand under herself, slowly entering Shelby with her middle finger, tongue never relenting on her clit.
“Fuck, Toni… more.” Shelby moaned, tugging more harshly on Toni’s hair as she added her pointer finger on her neck thrust.
Toni was almost certain if she shifted her hips just a bit against the mattress, she could come again within seconds. She had never heard Shelby curse like that, and the fact that it was in this moment, because of how Toni was making her feel? It was almost too much.
“Say it again?” Toni begged against her clit, thankfully not having to expound on her request.
“Fuck, Toni. I’m close.”
That was all the encouragement Toni needed to redouble her efforts, grunting with exertion as she pumped into Shelby, her lips wrapping around her clit, sucking roughly.
She looked up at Shelby’s half lidded eyes, looking every bit as blissed out as Toni felt. As Shelby came, she kept her eyes trained on Toni’s, her brows knitting together harshly, her hand holding Toni’s in a firm, desperate grip.
Toni felt her heart skip a beat, breath stuck in her throat. She couldn’t shake the fact that this felt like so much more than a casual hookup. But at the same time, she hardly knew this Shelby. But fuck if she didn’t want to.
Once Shelby seemed to catch her breath, Toni worked her way up her body, kissing her languidly as they both came down. Toni settled down beside her, smiling when Shelby wrapped an arm around her and pulled her closer.
“That was incredible.” She whispered, blunt fingernails scraping at Toni’s scalp.
Toni hummed, pressing a kiss against Shelby’s collarbone. This moment felt so loaded. Like whatever came next could, would, change the course of the rest of their lives.
They laid in silence for a while, lazily stroking each other"s skin, but Toni’s mind wouldn’t shut up long enough for her to fully relax. She sighed, hoping this conversation didn’t ruin everything.
“Hey, Shelby?” She asked quietly.
Shelby hummed, fingers not ceasing as they scratched up and down Toni’s back.
“Can I ask you those questions now?”
“Sure. What do you want to know?”
Toni sat up, but immediately missed the contact so held Shelby’s hand, lacing their fingers together in her lap.
“What has happened since high school? How did you end up here?”
Shelby smiled softly. “Starting with the heavy hitters, aren’t we? I came out to my family two years ago when Andrew proposed and I turned him down. I couldn’t picture myself with him any longer. It was one thing to have a beard boyfriend, but fiancé? Husband? I couldn’t. So I told Andrew as much, and later that night my family found out.”
“Shelby, I’m so sorry.” Toni’s brows knit together, grip on Shelby’s hand tightening.
Shelby shook her head, kissing Toni’s hand before dropping them back down. “They kicked me out, and I used the money I had saved up over the last few holidays and bought a ticket to California. I worked as a waitress here for a while, but I was just barely making ends meet. I probably would have been fine if I had stayed in Fort Travis, but a dollar just doesn’t go as far here and I couldn’t bear to stay in the same city as my family for another minute.”
“I get that. You couldn’t have avoided seeing them if you stayed there.”
“Right. I came here, knowing a big city would have the most opportunities for me, but I didn’t take into account how much more expensive everything is. Waitressing just wasn’t cutting it. One of the girls I worked with told me about this side gig she had started, and I had my first dance that night.”
“Do you like it at least?” Toni asked, thumb running across Shelby’s knuckles.
Shelby laughed softly. “I have definitely dealt with my fair share of losers, some ladies are just downright rude, but I am always in control, so it"s not so bad.”
“We both know you love being in control.” Toni smirked, hoping to lighten the mood.
Shelby grinned, shaking her head softly. “Don’t pretend you didn"t like it.”
Toni’s jaw dropped slightly, but she couldn’t exactly argue that, could she?
“Tonight… This isn’t how my work usually goes. Not just the sex, and the kissing and all that. During… I’ve never actually gotten down to just my panties before. Never touched a client the ways I touched you, or let you touch me.”
“Why did you?”
Shelby bit her lip, pointedly avoiding Toni’s eyes. “You aren’t the only one who had a… what did you call it? An embarrassingly huge crush?”
“You… what?” Toni asked, feeling her stomach drop.
Shelby blushed furiously. “You drove me crazy back in high school, Toni. At first because you just ran so hot that I felt like I couldn’t even have a conversation with you. But the more I got to know you, even if from afar, I could tell it was just passion. When Fatin contacted me about the dance, I had to accept.”
“You were into me, too?” Toni asked, heart racing.
Shelby smiled shyly, tucking her chin and looking at Toni through her eyelashes. “Seems like I still am.”
Toni surged forward, crashing her lips against Shelby’s in a bruising kiss.
Shelby kissed her back just as roughly, but pulled back, wanting to explain herself.
“I swear I didn’t plan on taking things this far. I just couldn’t turn down the chance to see you again. And then when you admitted to having feelings for me back then… I couldn’t help myself.”
“Shelby, everything that happened tonight I was completely on board with. Seriously, best birthday I’ve ever had. Actually… we should probably go ahead and pencil this in for my birthday every year.”
Shelby grinned, rolling on top of Toni, pinning her hands above her head as she kissed her deeply. “I think that could be arranged.”