Chapter Text
SFW
A- Affection (How affectionate are they? How do they show affection)
Toby is very affectionate if you allow it. If you do not like being touched, he will try to mold to your comfort, though he always feels the need to be touching some part of you when you're around. He would do most affectionate gestures, kisses, hugs, cuddling, linking arms, etc.
B- Best Friend (What would they be like as a best friend? How did the friendship start?)
He would be a random best friend, one who you never know what they will do next. It started in the woods when you were lost and nearing the proxy territory, he had led you away from it since you were not a target at the time. Ever since then you had decided to go visit the ax-wielding man when you had the chance.
C- Cuddles ( Do they like to cuddle? How would they cuddle?)
He loves to cuddle, it gives him a sense of security that you are real and not one of the things he hallucinates. He likes to spoon and lay his head on your chest. If you are shorter than him, he will be the big spoon. If you are taller than him, he will be the little spoon.
D- Domestic ( Do they want to settle down? How are they at cooking and cleaning?)
He wishes he could settle down, but being a proxy under the operator's control means he can never rest. He's not good at cooking unless it is outside over a fire, since that is what he is used to. The same thing with cleaning, he's used to being in a mess, so he won't be good at picking up after himself.
E- Ending ( If they had to break up with their partner, how would they do that?)
He would leave you a note explaining why he can't see you anymore. It would tear him to shreds but it was for the best before he was forced to kill you by the Operator's choice.
F- Fiance ( How do they feel about commitment? How quick would they get married?)
Once again, he wishes he could commit, but is struck down by being a proxy. If he had a more normal life he would wait about 3-4 years of being in a relationship before asking for your hand in marriage.
G- Gentle ( How gentle are they, both physically and emotionally?)
He tries his best to be gentle with you, though his ticks might make his body act out. He tries to softly touch you every time he comes close, but sometimes that turns into a harsh grab on your arm or leg. He does his best to not hurt you emotionally since he is very sensitive himself when it comes to emotions.
H- Hugs ( Do they like hugs? How often do they do it? What are their hugs like?)
He loves hugs and will try to hug you whenever he can. He loves both back and front hugs. His back hugs come with him trying to nuzzle into the crook of your neck while wrapping his arms around your waist. From the front, he pulls you close and has his right arm above his left on your back while his head tries to hide somewhere on your body.
I- I Love You ( How fast do they say the L-word)
It takes him some time to say it since he doesn't know how you will react to it. Once he does it comes out in a stutter before he leaves for the night. You found it cute so now he tries to say it more.
J- Jealousy ( How jealous do they get? What do they do when they get jealous?)
He gets very jealous but tries to not jump to conclusions when he does. If it becomes too much he asks the Operator for permission to kill them.
K- Kisses ( What are their kisses like? Where do they like to kiss you? Where do they like to be kissed?)
He tries to give soft kisses, but they come harsh. He goes for a peck on the lips but ends up clashing teeth and profusely apologizing and begs you for another try. He loves to kiss your neck and lips, somewhere intimate so he can be closer to you. He would like it if you kissed his cheeks, especially if it's the one that has his injury because it makes him feel better about it.
L- Little Ones ( How are they around children)
Not good. Plain and simply not good.
M- Mornings ( How are mornings spent with them?)
If he is allowed to stay till morning he will wake first and wait for you to wake up as well, no matter how long it takes. He kisses you first thing when you wake and cuddles you till you want to get up. He will try to help make breakfast if you want it and stay with you till he is needed or till you have to go to classes or work.
N- Nights ( How are nights spent with them?)
He tries to stay the whole night but is needed often for missions. He cuddles you while you watch a show or movie on the tv. You make him shower so he can take care of himself in the night after you. He waits on your bed while you get dressed for bed and stuff and wears a huge smile when he sees you. You two cuddle and poke around with each other before falling asleep.
O- Open ( When would they start revealing things about themselves? Do they say everything all at once or wait a while to reveal things slowly?)
He would try to keep what he does a secret for as long as he could. Dropping simple answers when you ask what he does for a living- he normally says that he works with his friends in the woods with trees. If you ever found out what he actually does, he avoids you for your protection. If you come out into the woods looking for him he would cry because he doesn't know what you think of him now and thinks that you're there to break up. If you tell him that you want to stay together, he would doubt your words till you make it crystal clear to him. He would break down in your arms, relieved that you don't want to split, and promises to protect you no matter what.
P- Patience ( How easily angered are they?)
Depends on his mood. If it was a harsh day he will be a bit blunt and try his best to not lash out at you.
Q- Quizzes ( How much would they remember about you? Do they remember every little detail you mention in passing or do they forget everything?)
Once again, he tries his best but ends up forgetting most stuff since he has so much going on with his profession.
R- Remember ( What is their favorite moment in your relationship?)
When you first allowed him to kiss you. He was overjoyed and ended up messing it up, but you allowed him another chance which he took slowly. You both were in the woods at night and he had cupped your face before placing a kiss on your lips, he ended up giving you multiple little kisses and cried some afterward in appreciation.
S- Security ( How protective are they? How would they protect you? How would they like to be protected?)
Extremely protective. He tries to keep you a secret from the others so they won't go after you to fuck with him. Watches over you when he can and is relieved when you don't notice him in the trees above your campus/workplace. He doesn't need to be protected since he can handle stuff.
T- Try ( How much effort do they try to put into dates, anniversaries, gifts, and everyday tasks?)
Tries his best so he can please you, but remember that he does not get paid and lives in the woods, so don't expect anything extravagant. Brings you wildflowers from the lake that he loves to take you by just touching the hunting area. Hopes that he doesn't get a mission on any anniversaries, but if he does, he leaves you a note with some chocolate he stole with more flowers.
U- Ugly ( What would be some bad habits of theirs?)
He bites his fingers and picks at his skin. Very unconfident when it comes to relationships so he feels like he's not doing enough. You have to reassure him that he is doing perfect with what he does.
V- Vanity ( How concerned are they with their looks?)
Cleans off the blood on his clothes and skin before meeting you, worries that you are uncomfortable with his wound.
W- Whole ( Would they feel incomplete without you?)
Very incomplete when you aren't around, and it just gets worse the longer you're in the relationship. The other creeps notice something is up when he is unfocused on the job.
X- Xtra ( A random headcanon for them?)
He introduces you to Sally when she pinky-promises that she will never tell on him. She brought you her bear to play with and all three of you had a tea party. She hasn't told anyone yet because she knows what will happen to you if you are found out.
Y- Yuck ( What are some things they wouldn't like, either in general or in a partner?)
Hates being manipulated, one of the reasons that he hates being under Slenderman.
Z- Zzz ( Sleeping habits?)
He snores lightly but it is enough to make you annoyed. He loves to cuddle you and lay his head on your chest to hear your heartbeat.
-----------------------------
NSFW
(I find Toby to be more submissive when he's relaxed but is very dominant if he is wound up from his missions)
A- Aftercare (What they are like after sex)
When he is submissive he loves it if you clean him up and run a bath for him all the while checking up on him. Very lovey afterward. While dominant he does the same for you, making sure you're alright after and cleaning you up. Cuddles after is a must.
B- Body Part (Their favorite part of their body and their favorite part of their partner's body)
He likes his hands, even though they are used for something bad, he sees the way you react to them and loves your reactions to it. His favorite part of you is your thighs and stomach. It doesn't matter what body type you have, he loves the way your thighs and stomach shape.
C- Cum (Anything to do with cum)
Bitter and watery, he doesn't have a good diet so it shows in his cum. He is a sprayer, his cum goes everywhere when not contained, which he does enjoy.
D- Dirty Secret (What's a dirty secret of theirs?)
He wants to do terror play with you when you guys get more comfortable with each other, but never will because he doesn't want to see the fear in your eyes nor does he want you to think that you are actually scaring him as well.
E- Experience (How experienced are they? Do they know what they're doing?)
Maybe did it once with a female proxy candidate to shut her up about it, but other than that, nothing. He has a slight idea but likes to have you be the dominant one so he doesn't make a fool of himself.
F- Favorite Position (Self-explanatory)
When submissive he likes it in missionary or with his back against the wall so he can grab onto you and burry his face into your neck to muffle his moans. When dominant he likes missionary so he can see your expressions.
G- Goofy (Are they more serious in the moment, or are they humorous?)
Tries to be serious, but fails. He's a bit silly, so please don't make fun of him for it.
H- Hair (How well-groomed are they? )
Has never groomed down there since the incidents, but if you want it, he'll try to find a way to trim it off.
I- Intimacy ( How are they during the moment? )
Very clingy and intimate. He tries to be as close to you as he can and praises you for everything.
J- Jack Off ( Masturbation headcanons)
More often than not, when he wants to have sex he'll not be allowed to venture out of the woods to your house so he has to masturbate. He'll either find a bush or climb up a tree to deal with his needs.
K- Kinks ( One or more of their kinks)
He loves praise and light bondage. He also likes it if you could manhandle him or make him go mindless.
L- Location (Favorite place to have sex)
Bed or wall.
M- Motivation (What turns them on or gets them going?)
Whenever you touch him first, like a close hug or a longer kiss, that really gets him excited.
N- No (Something they wouldn't do, turn-offs)
He would never hurt you no matter how much you ask, it reminds him too much about his past life.
O- Oral ( Preference in giving or receiving, skill, etc.)
He loves giving oral, though he is not that good at it. He'll get better over time, but when he tries it first, it was not good. He does his best to make you feel good, but sometimes you have to just fuck his throat and tell him to deal with it. Much rather prefers giving to receiving and tries to not mess with his wound.
P- Pace (Are they fast and rough? Slow and sensual?)
Likes it when you pound him into oblivion to the point where he can't think about anything, but also likes it slow so he feels loved. When he's dominating, he likes to go rough if you are alright about it.
Q- Quickie ( Their opinion on quickies)
He doesn't mind them since he might have to do it often. Due to his work, he doesn't have time for a full session, so a lot of quickies happen.
R- Risk ( Are they game to experiment, do they take risks, etc.?)
He'll risk whatever you want, he doesn't mind trying out something that you want to do and talks about it after to make sure that you liked it.
S- Stamina (How many rounds can they go for? How long do they last?)
Due to him being inexperienced, he cums fast, so he goes through more orgasms than you would. His stamina is excellent so he can last through those orgasms for a while.
T- Toy (Do they own toys? Do they use them on themselves or their partner?)
Doesn't own any toys since he would have to always hide them on his person. If you use toys, he might be a bit moody when he first found out, talking about how he could do better than your toys. If it gets too much for him to watch you use them, he will try to hide them when you're sleeping, which leads you to tell him that you only use them when he can't be there. That makes him feel a bit better, but still eh about it.
U- Unfair ( How much they like to tease)
Will tease in a dominant persona, but very lightly and he gives in easily. He doesn't like it when you tease him because then he begs like a dog for whatever he wants and it is embarrassing to him.
V- Vocal ( How loud they are, what noises do they make?)
Vocal, but hides it. Bites into random pillows, his sleeve, your shoulder, etc. You have to tell him to stop hiding his moans. When he does, he has those high-pitched to low moans with his ticks mixed in due to the stimulation of it, loud.
W- Wild Card ( A random thing that they do)
He will have days where all he wants to do is make you happy, not allowing himself to have any sort of release for the session and only focused on you.
X- X-ray (What's it like down there?)
4-5 soft and 7 hard. Slightly thick, cut and has a few shallow veins.
Y- Yearning ( How high is their sex drive?)
High, but he knows he can't have it all the time, so he tries to control it.
Z- Zzz ( Do they fall asleep after sex?)
Tries not to fall asleep, but ends up going anyways. Falls harder when it was a rough session.