Talk:Prepared guitar

Merge proposal

While I really appreciate work of User:Tomaat on 3rd bridge and Moodswinger articles, though I deeply think that one general article on prepared guitar is enough than having 3 stub-like articles on same subject.

Besides, sadly, it looks more like self-promotion of Moodswinger (according to comment on Image:Moodswinger.jpg, it looks like Yuri Landman wrote so many articles mention his product himself). --GreyCat 22:22, 16 February 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Poll on merge proposal

Yuri Landman: "Very good, I don't have problems with the merge."—Preceding unsigned comment added by 83.83.196.112 (talk • contribs)

Yuri Landman writes: Could the one who is going to merge this article pay attention to my next explanation about the instruments? (I'm from Holland, so please excuse me for my bad english. I also added this note on the Moodswinger-article)

Note: "Merging 3rd Bridge & Moodswinger is okay by me. The main reason I separated it to 3 topics is that a prepared guitar is a guitar. A 3rd bridge instrument can be any (self created) electrical stringinstrument (see the Pencilina of Bradford Reed or Glenn Branca's instruments). So a 3rd bridge stringinstrument is one step further to a different (new) instrument than the electric guitar, which is very limited and inconvenient for this technique. My Moodswinger has for that reason 12 strings instead of 6 and a calculated mathematical harmonic resonance scale. Bradford also used a few similar pitches (1/3 2/3 & 1/4 3/4) in a more primitive scale. This resonance scale isn't on a normal 12-TET scaled instrument. Prepared guitars not only use a 3rd bridge, but also springs or other objects can be placed on the strings to alter the timbre of the tone. So a prepared Guitar is broader in experimentatl usage but sometimes less focused on harmonic mathematics.

Short:

My Moodswinger is a 3rd bridge instrument.
A prepared guitar can be a 3rd bridge instrument, but is not always a 3rd bridge instrument.
A 3rd Bridge instrument is not always a guitar and not always prepared, but sometimes especcially constructed (like my, Branca's and Bradford's instruments)."

So maybe merge Moodswinger 3rd Bridge, but not merge 3rd Bridge and prepaired guitar?

glissando statement

from the article: "one can play a true glissando with a slide, but this is otherwise impossible on a fretted instrument."

that's not true, one can bend the string after playing a note to achieve a true glissando Amirman 19:24, 7 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Fixed, although it's debatable whether this slide stuff should be on here at all. It's irrelevant, and I vote for deletion. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 213.83.108.10 (talk) 15:31, 24 June 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Pictures

I would like to see more pictures of third bridge-guitars. Does someone have pics of:

Fred Friths instruments?
Pencilina
Neptune (band)
other similar instruments built by people?Houtlijm 18:38, 27 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]