Draft:2024 Indonesian presidential debate


2024 Indonesian presidential debate is a series of debates attended by three presidential candidates, Anies Baswedan, Prabowo Subianto, and Ganjar Pranowo, as well as their vice-presidential candidates in 2024 Indonesian presidential election.

Background

edit

During the time frame established by the General Election Commission, presidential and vice presidential candidates use debates as a campaign tactic.[1] Five debates between presidential and vice-presidential pairings was place throughout the campaign season in compliance with the Indonesian electoral law of 2017.[2] While all three pairs of candidates will participate together in each debate, the KPU has planned three debates for presidential candidates and two for vice presidential candidates for the 2024 elections.[3][4] In contrast, during the 2019 election campaign, there were two special debates for presidential candidates, one for the vice president, and two for presidential-vice-presidential couples.[5][6] This format modification was seen advantageous for some pairings, and it became a topic of discussion among the public and the success teams of candidate pairs..[7][8]

Compared to the debates held throughout the 2019 election campaign, the format of each debate's segments has not altered much. The discussion will be broken up into six sections, with a total duration of around 120 minutes. Following the presentation of the candidate couples' mission and vision in the first segment, there will follow two question and answer sessions aimed at refining the vision and mission through prepared panelist questions. The presidential candidates exchange questions and answers in the following two segments, and the sixth section concludes with a closing statement.[9]

Schedule

edit
No. Day and Date Location Theme Panelist(s) Moderator(s) Broadcaster (Official) access-date=12 December 2023 |website=rri.co.id - Portal berita terpercaya |language=id}}</ref>[10] Debate Participation(s)
 P  Participant(s)  N  Nonparticipant(s) Paslon 1 Paslon 2 Paslon 3
Anies Baswedan Muhaimin Iskandar Prabowo Subianto Gibran Rakabuming Ganjar Pranowo Mahfud MD
1 Tueasday, December 12, 2023
KPU RI Office
Ardianto Wijaya

Valerina Daniel[11]
P N P N P N
2 Friday, December 22, 2023
Jakarta Convention Center[12]
  • Alamsyah Saragih
  • Adhitya Wardhono
  • Agustinus Prasetyantoko
  • Fauzan Ali Rasyid
  • Hendri Saparini
  • Hyronimus Rowa
  • Poppy Ismalina
  • Retno Agustina Ekaputri
  • Suharnomo
  • Tauhid Ahmad
  • Yosa Rizal Damuri
Alfito Deannova

Liviana Cherlisa[13]
N P N P N P
3 Sunday, January 7, 2024
Istora Gelora Bung Karno[14]
  • Defense
  • Security
  • International relations
  • Globalization
  • Geopolitics
  • Overseas politics
Anisha Dasuki

Ariyo Ardi
P N P N P N
4 Sunday, January 21, 2024
Jakarta Convention Center
[16]
  • Abrar Saleng
  • Arie Sujito
  • Arif Satria
  • Dewi Kartika
  • Fabby Tumiwa
  • Hariadi Kartodihardjo
  • Ridwan Yahya
  • Rukka Sombolinggi
  • Sudharto P. Hadi
  • Sulistyowati Irianto
  • Tubagus Furqon Sofhani
Retno Pinasti

Zilvia Iskandar[16]
N P N P N P
5 Sunday, February 4, 2024
Jakarta Convention Center
[a]
Andromeda Mercury

Dwi Anggia
P N P N P N

Broadcasting (via television)

edit
No. Day and date Broadcaster (Television) Ref
Resmi Live
1 Tuesday, December 12, 2023
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20]
2 Friday, Desember 22, 2023
[21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
3 Sunday, January 7, 2024
[25]
[26]
[27]
[28]
4 Sunday, January 21, 2024
[29]
[30]
[31]
[32]
[33]
5 Sunday, February 4, 2024
[34]
[35]
[36]
[37]
[38]

First debate

edit
2024 Indonesian Presidential Election Debate
First debate
HostKPU RI
Date(s)December 12, 2023 (December 12, 2023)
Duration150 minutes
VenueKPU RI Official, Jakarta
FootageKPU RI
TVRI
RRI
Moderator(s)Ardianto Wijaya
Valerina Daniel
TranscriptTranskrip.id
Meemo
Fact checkingCNN Indonesia
Tirto.id

On December 12, 2023, the first debate between presidential candidates was held at the KPU RI Office in Jakarta. In keeping with the idea of a town hall meeting discussion,[39] this debate introduced the three presidential candidate pairs participating in the 2024 election, although in actually just the three presidential candidates participated. The themes of the debate were Government, Law, Human Rights, Corruption Eradication, Strengthening Democracy, Improving Public Services, and Harmony among Citizens.[40] TVRI anchors, Ardianto Wijaya and Valerina Daniel were appointed as moderators at the premiere of this debate.[41]

The first debate presented the three presidential candidates debating law, bureaucracy, and democratic system. Anies and Muhaimin appeared compactly wearing white shirts with black suits with stickers “AMIN” on their chests, Prabowo wore a light blue shirt as their partner's signature color matching with his partner Gibran and there was a small pin pinned on his chest[42], Ganjar appeared wearing a white shirt that read “sat, set”, while Mahfud who wore a white shirt that read “tas, tes” with a picture of a judicial scale on his left chest.[43] Anies and Prabowo clashed during the democracy debate. Anies stated that there were still restrictions on freedom of speech.[44] Prabowo responded by dismissing the issue. He insisted that democracy under Jokowi's administration was good, even according to him, it was because of the democratic process that Anies could become governor of Jakarta.[45] Anies replied that Prabowo was considered “unable to stand to be in the opposition camp” as an honorable position.[46]


Second debate

edit
2024 Indonesian Vice-Presidential Election Debate
Second debate
HostKPU RI
Date(s)December 22, 2023 (December 22, 2023)
Duration150 minutes
VenueJakarta Convention Center, Jakarta
FootageKPU RI
CNN Indonesia
Kompas TV
BTV
Moderator(s)Alfito Deannova
Liviana Cherlisa[47]
TranscriptTranskrip.id
Meemo
Fact checkingCNN Indonesia
Tirto.id
Kompas.com

The second presidential and vice presidential debate took place on December 22, 2023 at the Jakarta Convention Center, Jakarta. With a modified town-hall meeting concept,[48] this debate will be followed by the vice-presidential candidates with a discussion format similar to the previous debate. The themes of this debate are Economy, People's Economy, Digital Economy, Finance, Tax Investment, Trade, Management of State Budget and Regional Budget, Infrastructure and Cities. Detik.com editor-in-chief and CNN Indonesia host Alfito Deannova and Kompas TV host Liviana Cherlisa were appointed as moderators for the second debate.[49]

Indonesian Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidates number 1 Anies Baswedan and Muhaimin Iskandar were dressed in the same attire as the first debate, which was white shirts with black suits. They also wore accessories, including pins labeled AMIN and kopiah.[50] Likewise, candidate pair number 2 Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka who appeared in the same outfit from the first debate, a blue shirt typical of their partner's color. Gibran rolled up his sleeves to around the elbow, while Prabowo left his sleeves up to his wrist.[51] Also, candidate number 3 Ganjar Pranowo and Mahfud MD came dressed in traditional Indonesian attire. Mahfud wore a traditional Madurese traditional outfit from East Java province, while Ganjar was also dressed in a traditional Rote outfit from East Nusa Tenggara province. In addition, their supporters also came wearing traditional clothing from different regions throughout Indonesia to watch the second debate in person.[52] This time the debate was between vice presidential candidates Muhaimin Iskandar, Gibran Rakabuming Raka and Mahfud MD. In this second debate, the vice-presidential candidates debated on the big topic of economic issues. In the middle of the debate, Gibran Rakabuming Raka asked questions about abbreviations that other candidate did not understand, so the KPU issued a rule in the next debate, participants are prohibited using questions containing terms, abbreviations or acronyms that are not common and not understood by other participants unless they explain it first.[53]

Third debate

edit
2024 Indonesian Presidential Election Debate
Third debate
HostKPU RI
Date(s)January 7, 2024 (January 7, 2024)
Duration150 minutes
VenueIstora Senayan, Jakarta
FootageKPU RI
RCTI
iNews
Garuda TV
Moderator(s)Ariyo Ardi
Anisha Dasuki[54]
TranscriptMeemo
Fact checkingCNN Indonesia
Tirto.id
Kompas.com
Narasi Newsroom

The third presidential and vice-presidential debate took place on January 7, 2024 at Istora Senayan, Jakarta. Using a modified town-hall meeting concept,[55] this debate will be followed by presidential candidates with a discussion format similar to the previous debate. The theme of this debate is Defense, Security, International, Globalization, Geopolitics and Foreign Policy. GTV editor-in-chief who previously hosted RCTI Ariyo Ardi, and iNews anchor Anisha Dasuki were appointed as moderators for the third debate.[56]

In the third debate, Indonesian Presidential and Vice Presidential candidates number 1 Anies Baswedan and Muhaimin Iskandar consistently showed their formal appearances wearing black suits and white shirts. Unlike the second debate, Anies and Muhaimin appeared without wearing caps. Indonesian Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidate pair number 2 Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka still appeared in light blue shirts, which became their characteristic. The appearance difference was brought by Gibran who layered his shirt with dark blue outerwear and sneakers to complete his look. While Prabowo appeared more formal wearing loafers. Indonesian Presidential and Vice Presidential candidate pair number 3 Ganjar Pranowo and Mahfud MD came wearing jackets like in the movie Top Gun, which they named “Top Gan”, a green bomber jacket equipped with patches of their favorite slogans “tas tes” and “sat set”, serial number “3”, as well as various programs such as “Progressive Geopilitics”, “Free College for Children of Soldiers and Bhayangkara”, to “Modernization of Sakti Defense.” Under the jacket, they used a white shirt coupled with an accessory of a red tie and appeared wearing aviator glasses when entered the arena.[57]

The third debate was between presidential candidates Anies Baswedan, Prabowo Subianto, and Ganjar Pranowo. The third debate was quite heated, with Anies Baswedan and Ganjar Pranowo asking Prabowo Subianto to disclose data on defense. Both of them demanded Prabowo's transparency while still serving as Minister of Defense. Moreover, Prabowo's performance as Minister of Defense was also considered poor on that occasion. The third presidential debate was even more hotly discussed when the three candidates used data to attack each other. Even President Joko Widodo also commented on the debate. Jokowi assessed that the third debate was more focused on attacking each other between presidential candidates. According to him, it doesn't matter if there is mutual attack, as long as it is still about vision and policy, not attacking personally.[58]

Fourth debate

edit
2024 Indonesian Vice-Presidential Election Debate
Fourth debate
HostKPU RI
Date(s)January 21, 2024 (January 21, 2024)
Duration150 minutes
VenueJakarta Convention Center, Jakarta
FootageKPU RI
SCTV
MetroTV
Moderator(s)Retno Pinasti
Zilvia Iskandar
TranscriptKumparan.com
Meemo
Fact checkingCNN Indonesia
Tirto.id
Kompas.com
Narasi Newsroom

The fourth presidential and vice presidential debate took place on January 21, 2024 at the Jakarta Convention Center, Jakarta. Taking the concept of a modified town-hall meeting,[59] this debate participated by the vice presidential candidates with a discussion format similar to the previous debates. The themes of this debate are Sustainable Development, Natural Resources, Environment, Energy, Food, Agrarian, and Indigenous Peoples and Villages. In previous debates, the moderators were paired with a man and a woman, however on this debate, two women from SCTV's Liputan 6 editor-in-chief Retno Pinasti and MetroTV's news anchor Zilvia Iskandar were appointed as moderators on the fourth debate.[60]

Candidates number 1 Anies Baswedan and Muhaimin Iskandar came with white shirts without a black suit. Candidate pair number 2 Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka compactly wore the same light blue shirt typical of their pair's colors, Prabowo was seen layering his light blue shirt with a dark blue suit. Meanwhile, Gibran was seen wearing a blue shirt with an image similar to the Straw Hat “One Piece” group flag on his left chest. Candidate pair number 3 Ganjar Pranowo and Mahfud MD were present wearing mountain people costumes specifically designed and tailored to the environmental theme. In the early session, Ganjar-Mahfud wore a green long-sleeved shirt complete with a cream-colored scraft, and the slogan Sat Set on the left chest and Number 3 on the right chest. During the press conference, Ganjar-Mahfud wore a green shirt combined with a vest with the Sat-Set slogan on the left chest, and Number 3 on the right chest.[61] The debate was between vice-presidential candidates Muhaimin Iskandar, Gibran Rakabuming Raka and Mahfud MD.

In this fourth debate, the vice-presidential candidates attacked each other about food estate, nickel downstreaming to the seizure of indigenous areas, from the revocation of mining IUPs with many mafias, nickel, lithium-ion and lithium phosphate, carbon tax and renewable energy, agrarian reform, village development, community customary rights and others.[62] Moreover, the interesting part of the fourth debate was Thomas Lembong's name mentioned by Gibran in response to Muhaimin's note, and the term “Greenflation” when Gibran asked Mahfud MD, and Gibran's gimmick to find answers from Mahfud MD.[63]

Fifth debate

edit
2024 Indonesian Presidential Election Debate
Fifth debate
HostKPU RI
Date(s)February 4, 2024 (February 4, 2024)
Duration150 minutes
VenueJakarta Convention Center, Jakarta
FootageKPU RI
tvOne
NET TV
Moderator(s)Andromeda Mercury
Dwi Anggia
Fact checkingCNN Indonesia
Tirto.id
Kompas.com
Narasi Newsroom

The fifth presidential and vice presidential candidate debate took place on February 4, 2024 at the Jakarta Convention Center, Jakarta. This debate is the final debate of Indonesia's 2024 Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidate Debates. Using a modified town-hall meeting concept,[64] this debate will be followed by presidential candidates with a discussion format similar to the previous debate. The themes of this debate are social welfare, culture, education, information technology, health, employment, human resources and inclusion. tvOne Executive Producer, Dwi Anggia, and tvOne news anchor, Andromeda Mercury were appointed as moderators for the final debate.[65]

In the fifth debate, Candidate number 1 Anies Baswedan and Muhaimin Iskandar brought the theme “Presidential Look” where the pair wore white shirts, black suits complete with blue and maroon ties, black pants, also black skullcaps. Supporters were also present at the debate location wearing matching uniforms.[66] Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidate pair number 2 Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka appeared in jackets dominated by sky blue and white colors, that covered light blue shirts.[67] Meanwhile, candidate pair number 3 Ganjar Pranowo and Mahfud MD appeared wearing student-style varsity jackets with a combination of black and white colors. On their jackets, there were a number of emblems and embroidered containing 21 of their flagship programs, along with the words “sat set” and “tas tes” on their jackets.[68]

The fifth debate as the final debate was a debate between presidential candidates Anies Baswedan, Prabowo Subianto, and Ganjar Pranowo. This debate was cool and gentle without intense debates between the candidates.[69] For example, Prabowo agreed several times with the opinions of his debate opponent Anies Baswedan. First, Prabowo agreed with Anies' idea about the importance of giving a wide space for culturalists to express themselves and then the issue of improving the welfare of teachers. Prabowo understood that Anies was a former Minister of Education and Culture (Mendikbud). In addition, Ganjar and Anies talked about the importance of strengthening data on people with disabilities, Prabowo again agreed with their input about strengthening data on people with disabilities. Meanwhile, Ganjar's debate style occasionally insinuated and attacked. He insinuated the resignation of his vice president Mahfud MD, who considered that state officials should set an example by resigning when they wanted to participate in practical political contestation. Ganjar also launched an attack on Prabowo when he asked about the free meal program for stunting in children, Ganjar replied that he did not agree. He explained that the prevention of stunting for stunted children was considered too late and should not allow excessive feeding of children to cause obesity. Prabowo responded again to Ganjar's statement that what he was asking was exactly what Ganjar had said. However, Ganjar again replied that Prabowo corrected his own question.[70] Because the fifth debate was the last debate, the closing statements of the candidates were usually only 2 minutes, in this fifth debate each presidential candidate was given 4 minutes for closing statements.[71]

References

edit
  1. ^ Humas KPU (2023-11-29). "KPU Siap Gelar Debat Capres 3 Kali dan Cawapres 2 Kali". KPU 21. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  2. ^ Farisa, Fitria Chusna (2023-11-28). "Aturan Debat Pilpres 2024: Pelaksanaan dan Materi Halaman all". KOMPAS.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  3. ^ Wibawana, Widhia Arum. "Aturan Debat Pilpres 2023: Tata Penyelenggaraan hingga Materinya". detiknews (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  4. ^ "Pemilu 2024: Debat capres 2024 - Apa saja yang diketahui sejauh ini?". BBC News Indonesia (in Indonesian). 2023-11-30. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  5. ^ Aprilia, Zefanya. "Ini Beda Format Debat Capres-Cawapres Saat Ini dengan di 2019 - Semua Halaman". CNBC Indonesia (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  6. ^ "Format Debat Capres-Cawapres RI dari Masa ke Masa, Sejak 2004-Sekarang". NU Online (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  7. ^ Rosana, Francisca Christy (2023-12-10). "Gimik Calon Presiden dalam Debat untuk Menggaet Pemilih Muda". Tempo. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  8. ^ Liputan6.com (2023-12-02). "KPU Bantah Hilangkan Format Debat Antar Cawapres di Pilpres 2024". liputan6.com (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  9. ^ "Debat capres 2024: Janji capres 2024 apa saja?". BBC News Indonesia (in Indonesian). 2023-12-12. Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  10. ^ KPU. "KPU-Tim Paslon Sepakati Format dan Tema Debat". www.kpu.go.id (in Indonesian). Retrieved 12 December 2023.
  11. ^ Juli Hantoro (9 December 2023). "KPU Tetapkan Ardianto Wijaya dan Valerina Daniel sebagai Moderator Debat Pilpres 2024". Tempo.co.
  12. ^ Ulvia Nur Azizah. "Apa Tema Debat Cawapres 22 Desember Mendatang? Berikut Informasinya". Detik.com.
  13. ^ Juli Hantoro. "Daftar Panelis dan Moderator Debat Perdana Cawapres 22 Desember 2023". Kompas.com.
  14. ^ Anggi Muliawati. "KPU: Debat Ketiga Pilpres 2024 Akan Digelar di Istora Senayan". Detik.com.
  15. ^ a b Fika Nurul Ulya. Krisiandi (ed.). "Usai Diprotes, KPU Tambah "Garuda TV" Jadi Media Penyelenggara Debat Ketiga Capres". Kompas.com (in Indonesian).
  16. ^ a b KPU. "Rapat Finalisasi Debat Keempat: Tetapkan Tema, Lokasi Hingga Panelis dan Moderator". www.kpu.go.id (in Indonesian).
  17. ^ Dikala anda Menonton TV 3.0. "[Tidak ada keterangan]". Yogyakarta – via Facebook.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  18. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Pertama Capres Pemilu 2024 Part 1". Makassar – via Instagram.
  19. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Pertama Capres Pemilu 2024 Part 2". Makassar – via Instagram.
  20. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Pertama Capres Pemilu 2024 Last Part". Makassar – via Instagram.
  21. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Perdana Cawapres #Pemilu2024 #Pilpres2024 Part 1". Makassar – via Instagram.
  22. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Perdana Cawapres #Pemilu2024 #Pilpres2024 Part 2". Makassar – via Instagram.
  23. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Perdana Cawapres #Pemilu2024 #Pilpres2024 Part 3". Makassar – via Instagram.
  24. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Perdana Cawapres #Pemilu2024 #Pilpres2024 Last Part". Makassar – via Instagram.
  25. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "#DebatKetigaCapres2024 Minggu 7 Januari 2024 (Part 1)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  26. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "#DebatKetigaCapres2024 Minggu 7 Januari 2024 (Part 2)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  27. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "#DebatKetigaCapres2024 Minggu 7 Januari 2024 (Part 3)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  28. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "#DebatKetigaCapres2024 Minggu 7 Januari 2024 (Last Part)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  29. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Cawapres Pemilu Part 1 Bersama Moderator @zilviaiskandar & @retnopinasti". Makassar – via Instagram.
  30. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Keempat Cawapres Pemilu 2024 Part 2". Makassar – via Instagram.
  31. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Keempat Cawapres Pemilu 2024 Part 3". Makassar – via Instagram.
  32. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Keempat Cawapres Pemilu 2024 Part 4". Makassar – via Instagram.
  33. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Keempat Cawapres Pemilu 2024 Last Part". Makassar – via Instagram.
  34. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Final Calon Presiden 2024 Part 1 (Minggu 4/10/2024)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  35. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Final Calon Presiden 2024 Part 2 (Minggu 4/10/2024)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  36. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Final Calon Presiden 2024 Part 3 (Minggu 4/10/2024)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  37. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Final Calon Presiden 2024 Part 4 (Minggu 4/10/2024)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  38. ^ Wahyudi Radi. "Debat Final Calon Presiden 2024 Last Part (Minggu 4/10/2024)". Makassar – via Instagram.
  39. ^ Indonesia, C. N. N. "KPU: Debat Perdana Pilpres 2024 Pakai Konsep Town Hall Meeting". nasional (in Indonesian). Retrieved 2023-12-13.
  40. ^ Humas KPU (2023-11-29). "KPU Siap Gelar Debat Capres 3 Kali dan Cawapres 2 Kali". KPU 21. Retrieved 2023-12-12.
  41. ^ Juli Hantoro. "KPU Tetapkan Ardianto Wijaya dan Valerina Daniel sebagai Moderator Debat Pilpres 2024". Tempo.co.
  42. ^ Dewanti, Yolanda Putri. "Beda Gaya Busana Anies Baswedan, Prabowo Subianto, Ganjar Pranowo di Debat Capres Pertama". Tribun News (in Indonesian).
  43. ^ Sari, Brigitta Belia Permata. "Tiba di Markas TPN, Ganjar Pakai Baju 'Sat-Set' dan Mahfud 'Tas-Tes'". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  44. ^ Wiryono, Singgih. "Anies Sebut Rakyat Tak Percaya pada Proses Demokrasi Saat Ini". Kompas (in Indonesian).
  45. ^ Muliawati, Anggi. "Aksi Joget Prabowo Usai Tanggapi Anies soal Penguatan Demokrasi". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  46. ^ Muliawati, Firda Dwi. "Debat Memanas! Anies: Pak Prabowo tidak Tahan Menjadi Oposisi". CNBC Indonesia (in Indonesian).
  47. ^ Indonesia, C. N. N. "KPU: Alfito Deannova dan Liviana Cherlisa Moderator Debat Cawapres" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 18 December 2023.
  48. ^ developer, medcom id (2023-12-18). "Update Debat Kedua Pilpres: Lokasi, Format Baru, hingga Daftar Panelis" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 18 December 2023.
  49. ^ Media, Kompas Cyber (2023-12-18). "Alfito Deannova dan Liviana Cherlisa Jadi Moderator Debat Cawapres Perdana Halaman all" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 18 December 2023.
  50. ^ Abdurrahman, Sultan (2023-12-22). "Pakaian Anies-Muhaimin di Debat Kedua Sama dengan Saat Debat Pertama". Tempo News (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 December 2023.
  51. ^ Santosa, Lia Wanadriani (2023-12-22). "Baju adat hingga jas jadi pilihan para cawapres pada debat kedua". Antara News (in Indonesian). Retrieved 23 December 2023.
  52. ^ Indonesia, C.N.N. "Ganjar dan Mahfud Pakai Baju Adat NTT-Madura Hadiri Debat Cawapres" (in Indonesian).
  53. ^ Putra, Nanda Perdana (5 January 2024). "KPU Larang Capres Pakai Pertanyaan Singkatan Tanpa Penjelasan Saat Debat". Liputan 6 News (in Indonesian). Retrieved 7 January 2024.
  54. ^ Indonesia, Tempo.co. "Anisha Dasuki Kembali Jadi Moderator Debat Capres Kali Ini Berpasangan Dengan Ariyo Ardi".
  55. ^ developer, medcom id (18 December 2023). "Update Debat Kedua Pilpres: Lokasi, Format Baru, hingga Daftar Panelis" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 18 December 2023.
  56. ^ Media, C.N.N. Indonesia. "Profil Moderator Debat Ketiga Pilpres Anisha Dasuki dan Ariyo Ardi" (in Indonesian). Retrieved 18 December 2023.
  57. ^ Kristianti, Livia. "Jaket "Top Gan" hingga kemeja formal para capres warnai debat ketiga". Antara News (in Indonesian).
  58. ^ Irmayanti. "Panas! Koreksi-Evaluasi Bermunculan Usai Debat Capres Ketiga". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  59. ^ Kamila, Alfa. "Jadwal Lengkap Debat Pilpres Keempat, Tema, Lokasi, Panelis dan Moderator". Jawa Pos (in Indonesian).
  60. ^ Priyasmoro, Muhammad Radityo. "Profil Retno Pinasti dan Zilvia Iskandar, Moderator Debat Keempat Pilpres 2024". Liputan 6 News (in Indonesian).
  61. ^ Pradita, Utama. "Potret Busana Pasangan Capres-Cawapres di Debat Keempat". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  62. ^ "Rangkuman debat cawapres Pilpres 2024: Saling serang soal food estate, hilirisasi nikel hingga perampasan wilayah adat". BBC News (in Indonesian).
  63. ^ "Pengamat: Debat Keempat Pilpres 2024 Lebih Tampilkan Gimmick ketimbang Substansi". Kompas TV (in Indonesian).
  64. ^ Sumitro, Fria. "Jadwal Debat Capres 2024 Kelima, Lengkap Tema hingga Stasiun TV-nya". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  65. ^ Anugrah, Willy Indonesia. "Profil Andromeda dan Dwi, Moderator Debat Final Capres". RRI (in Indonesian).
  66. ^ Abdurrahman, Sultan. "Timnas Amin soal Baju yang Dipakai Anies-Muhaimin saat Debat: Presidential Look". Tempo News (in Indonesian).
  67. ^ Shanti, Hreeloita Dharma. "Prabowo-Gibran tampil beda dalam balutan jaket di debat kelima". Antara News (in Indonesian).
  68. ^ Hafiez, Fachri Audhia. "Begini Pilihan Busana Capres-Cawapres di Debat Kelima". Medcom ID (in Indonesian).
  69. ^ Iman. "Pemerhati Nilai Debat Kelima Capres Berjalan Landai". RRI (in Indonesian).
  70. ^ Irmayanti. "Debat Pamungkas Capres 2024: Adem Ayem hingga Minim Serangan". Detik News (in Indonesian).
  71. ^ Muliawati, Anggi. "KPU Tambah Durasi Closing Statement Debat Kelima Pilpres 2024". Detik News (in Indonesian).


Cite error: There are <ref group=lower-alpha> tags or {{efn}} templates on this page, but the references will not show without a {{reflist|group=lower-alpha}} template or {{notelist}} template (see the help page).