The 2021 Italian government crisis was a political event in Italy that began in January 2021 and ended the following month. It includes the events that follow the announcement of Matteo Renzi, leader of Italia Viva (IV) and former Prime Minister, that he would revoke IV's support to the Government of Giuseppe Conte.[1]
 Mario Draghi accepting the task of forming a new government | |
| Date | 13 January 2021 – 18 February 2021 |
|---|---|
| Location | Italy |
| Type | Parliamentary crisis |
| Cause | Withdrawal of Italia Viva's support to Giuseppe Conte's government |
| Participants | M5S, Lega, FI, PD, FdI, IV, LeU, Aut, Mixed Group |
| Outcome |
|
On 18 and 19 January, confidence votes were held in both Houses of Parliament; the Government managed to win both, but fell short of an absolute majority in the Senate due to IV Senators abstaining.[2]
On 26 January, Conte offered his resignation as Prime Minister; President Sergio Mattarella consequently started consultations for the formation of a new Government, which ultimately resulted in Mario Draghi being sworn in as Prime Minister on 13 February.[3]
Background
editThe 2018 general election produced a hung parliament. After long negotiations, a coalition was finally formed on 1 June between two populist parties, centrist Five Star Movement (M5S) and right-wing League, led by the M5S-linked independent Giuseppe Conte as Prime Minister.[4] This coalition ended with Conte's resignation on 20 August 2019 after the League withdrew its support of the government.[5] In September 2019, a new government was formed between the M5S and two left-wing parties, the Democratic Party (PD) and Free and Equal (LeU), retaining Giuseppe Conte at its head.[6][7][8][9] On 16 September, a few days from the investiture vote, in an interview with la Repubblica, former Prime Minister Matteo Renzi announced his intention to leave the PD, launching a new centrist and liberal party named Italia Viva (IV).[10][11] In the interview, he confirmed continued support of Conte's government.[12] Two ministers, Teresa Bellanova and Elena Bonetti, and one undersecretary, Ivan Scalfarotto, followed Renzi to his new movement.[13]
Political crisis
edit
Between December 2020 and January 2021, discussions arose within the government coalition between Conte and Matteo Renzi, former Prime Minister and leader of Italia Viva.[14] Renzi called for radical changes to the government's economic recovery plans after the COVID-19 pandemic, and also demanded that Conte cede his mandate over the secret services coordination task.[15] During his end-of-year press conference, Conte declined Renzi's requests, asserting that he still had a majority in the Parliament.[16]
On 13 January, during a press conference, Renzi announced the resignation of IV's two ministers, effectively triggering the collapse of Conte's government.[17] Renzi stated: "We will not allow any Prime Minister to have full and unrestricted powers. [...] We are facing a dramatic emergency, but a Government should not be kept alive just because of that. If we are to build a serious response to the pandemic, we must unblock construction sites and act on industrial policies. There is a reason that in Italy we the highest number of deaths and an ever-collapsing GDP"[18]
During a late-night Council of Ministers, Conte strongly criticised Renzi, stating that "Italia Viva has assumed the serious responsibility of opening a government crisis. I am sincerely sorry for the considerable damage that has been done to our country by a government crisis in the midst of a pandemic. [...] The gravity of this decision cannot be diminished."[19] The Prime Minister was soon backed by the secretary of the Democratic Party, Nicola Zingaretti, who labeled the crisis as a "very serious mistake against Italy" and "an act against our country",[20] while the Minister of Culture, Dario Franceschini, head of the Democratic delegation in the government, stated: "Whoever attacks the Prime Minister, attacks the entire government; Giuseppe Conte has been serving the country with passion and dedication against the most serious challenges we've ever faced in the history of our Republic".[21] The Minister of Foreign Affairs and former leader of the M5S, Luigi Di Maio, described Renzi's decision as a "reckless move", asserting that "Prime Minister Conte and President Sergio Mattarella are the only two pillars Italy has in this moment of uncertainty";[22] while Roberto Speranza, Minister of Health and de facto leader of Free and Equal (LeU), said that Conte "has served the country with discipline and honor", adding that LeU still supported him.[23] Moreover, many other prominent members of the cabinet like Stefano Patuanelli, Alfonso Bonafede, Vincenzo Spadafora and Riccardo Fraccaro expressed their support to Conte.[24] The opposition leaders, Matteo Salvini and Giorgia Meloni, immediately asked for snap elections.[25]
On 15 January, Conte announced that he would report about the government crisis in Parliament in the following week. On that occasion, he would also seek for a confidence vote to understand whether his Government still enjoyed parliamentary support.[26]
Vote of confidence in Conte's Government
editOn 18 January, the Chamber of Deputies passed a motion of confidence in the Government with 321 votes in favour, 259 against and 27 abstentions.[27][28] The next day, the Government won a confidence vote in the Senate as well, but fell short of the 161 votes needed to achieved an absolute majority. Of the 312 Senators present, 156 voted in favor and 140 against, while 16 abstained;[29][30][31]
In both houses of Parliament, Italia Viva abstained. The Government also received support from a few MPs belonging to opposition parties, such as three MPs from Forza Italia and one from More Europe.
| 18–19 January 2021 Confidence votes for Conte II Cabinet | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| House of Parliament | Vote | Parties | Votes |
| Chamber of Deputies (Voting: 580 of 630, Majority: 290) |
 Yes |
M5S (188), PD (93), LeU (12), CD (11), Mixed Group–Ind. (8), SVP–PATT (4), MAIE (3), IV (1), FI (1) | 321 / 580
|
 No |
Lega (125), FI (85), FdI (31), NcI–USEI–C! (9), EU–Action (4), Mixed Group–Ind. (3), AP–PSI (2) | 259 / 580
| |
| Abstention | IV (27) | 27 / 630
| |
| Senate of the Republic (Voting: 296 of 321, Majority: 148) |
Yes |
M5S (91), PD (35), Aut (8), Mixed Group–Ind. (8), LeU (6), MAIE (4), FI (2), PSI (1), EU–Action (1) | 156 / 296
|
| No |
Lega (62), FI–UDC (49), FdI (19), Mixed Group–Ind. (5), IdeA–C! (3), EU–Action (2) | 140 / 296
| |
| Abstention | IV (16) | 16 / 321
| |
Resignation of Conte and consultations
edit
On 26 January, after a few days of inconclusive negotiations with centrist and independent senators to regain an absolute majority in the Senate, Conte resigned as Prime Minister.[32][33][34] On the following day, a new parliamentary group, known as Europeanists, was formed in the Senate in support of Conte.[35] The group was composed by members of the Associative Movement Italians Abroad (MAIE) and other centrist and liberal senators.
On 27 January, the consultations with President Sergio Mattarella for the formation of a new cabinet began at the Quirinal Palace, meeting the presidents of the two houses, senator Elisabetta Casellati and Roberto Fico.[36]
On 28 January, President Mattarella met the delegations of For the Autonomies, Free and Equal and the new-born Europeanists, which confirmed their supports to Conte, as well as various MPs of the Mixed Group.[37] Matteo Renzi, which was received in the afternoon along with Italia Viva's delegation, opened to a new government with the same old majority, but he opposed giving the task of forming a new cabinet to Conte,[38] while Nicola Zingaretti, leader of the PD, stressed the necessity of starting a new government with Conte at its head.[39]
On 29 January, high-ranking members of the centre-right coalition (a conservative alliance between the League (Lega), Brothers of Italy (FdI), Forza Italia (FI) and other minor parties) met with President Mattarella. Matteo Salvini, leader of the League, asked for a snap election, but added that, under specific conditions, the centre-right could support a national unity government.[40][41] Mattarella also spoke with interim leader of the Five Star Movement (M5S) Vito Crimi, who said he was open to grant of Matteo Renzi's requests in exchange for IV's support for new Conte-led Government.[42] Alessandro Di Battista, leader of the anti-establishment wing of the M5S, criticized this statement, asserting he would leave the party if the latter agreed to allow Renzi's party back into the Government.[43]
Further negotiations and Draghi's mandate
edit
At the end of the consultations, Mattarella gave President of the Chamber of Deputies Roberto Fico the task of verifying whether a new Government, backef with the same majority of the previous one (that is, a coalition between M5S, PD, IV and LeU) could be formed.[44]
On the deadline day of 2 February, IV broke away from the majority due to disagreements on both platform and cabinet members; Fico consequently reported to Mattarella that an agreement had not been reached.[45] Mattarella consequently decided to invite Mario Draghi for the next day at the Quirinal Palace with the intention to offer him the task to form a national unity technocratic government.[46][47] On 3 February, Draghi officially accepted with reservation the task of forming a new cabinet and started consulting with the Presiding Officers of the two Houses of Parliament.[48] On the same day, he also met Giuseppe Conte,[49] who officially endorsed him the following day.[50]
On 10 February Matteo Salvini and Silvio Berlusconi jointly announced, after a meeting, their support for Draghi.[51] On the same day, FDI leader Giorgia Meloni distanced herself from Salvini and Berlusconi's statement, reaffirming her opposition to a Draghi-led Government.[52]
On 11 February, the national leadership of the Democratic Party unanimously voted in favour of the formation of a new cabinet.[53]
On the same day, the M5S asked its members to vote on the following question: "Should the Movement support a technical-political government that will include a super-ministry for Ecological Transition and will defend the main results achieved by the Movement, alongside the other political forces indicated by the appointed prime minister Mario Draghi?" The party's members approved the online referendum with 59.3% voting in favor.[54] Alessandro Di Battista criticized the M5S' decision to join the new Government and left the party on 11 February 2021.[55]
| Choice | Votes | % |
|---|---|---|
 Yes |
44,177 | 59.3% |
 No |
30,360 | 40.7% |
| Total | 74,537 | 100.0% |
| Registered voters/turnout | 119,544 | 62.4% |
| Sources: Associazione Rousseau | ||
Formation of Draghi's government
editOn the evening of 12 February, Draghi met with President Mattarella and presented the list of proposed ministers for his cabinet. The oath of office took place on 13 February, at 12:00 PM local time.[3][56]
On 17 February 2021, the Senate approved the new cabinet with 262 votes in favour, 40 against and 2 abstentions.[57] It was the second largest majority in the history of the Italian Republic.[58] On 18 February 2021, the Chamber of Deputies approved the new cabinet with 535 votes in favour, 56 against and 5 abstentions.[59]
| 17–18 February 2021 Investiture votes for Draghi Cabinet | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| House of Parliament | Vote | Parties | Votes |
| Senate of the Republic (Voting: 302 of 321, Majority: 152) |
Yes |
M5S (69), Lega–PSd'Az (62), FI–UDC (49), PD (35), IV–PSI (17), Eur–MAIE–CD (10), Aut (5), LeU (4), IdeA–C! (3), Eu–Az (2), Others (6) | 262 / 302
|
| No |
FdI (19), M5S (15), LeU (2), Others (4) | 40 / 302
| |
| Abstention | Aut (1), Others (1) | 2 / 321
| |
| Chamber of Deputies (Voting: 591 of 630, Majority: 296) |
Yes |
M5S (155), Lega (125), PD (91), FI (81), IV (28), CD (14), LeU (11), C! (10), NcI−USEI−AdC (5), SVP–PATT (4), Az– Eu–RI (4), Eur–MAIE–PSI (2), Others (5) | 535 / 591
|
| No |
FdI (31), M5S (16), Lega (1), LeU (1), Others (7) | 56 / 591
| |
| Abstention | M5S (5) | 5 / 630
| |
See also
edit
References
edit- ^ Conte offre un patto, Renzi ritira le ministre. La crisi è servita, Huffington Post Italia
- ^ Italy's Conte wins Senate vote to keep fragile government afloat: final tally, Reuters
- ^ a b Italy: Ex-EU bank chief Mario Draghi sworn in as PM, Deutsche Welle
- ^ "Italy: Conte to lead 'government of change'". ANSAMed. 1 June 2018. Retrieved 7 September 2019.
- ^ Giuffrida, Angela (20 August 2019). "Italian PM resigns with attack on 'opportunist' Salvini". The Guardian. Retrieved 7 September 2019.
- ^ "Grasso, possibile intesa M5s-Pd-Leu - Ultima Ora". Agenzia ANSA. 19 August 2019. Archived from the original on 19 August 2019. Retrieved 28 August 2019.
- ^ "Conte wins crucial support for new Italian govt coalition". Washington Post. Archived from the original on 28 August 2019. Retrieved 28 August 2019.
- ^ "C'è l'accordo tra M5s e Pd. Governo giallorosso ai nastri di partenza". Agi. Archived from the original on 28 August 2019. Retrieved 28 August 2019.
- ^ "Governo, Conte e i ministri hanno giurato. Gentiloni in pole per successione a Moscovici". Repubblica.it. 5 September 2019. Archived from the original on 5 September 2019. Retrieved 5 September 2019.
- ^ "Renzi lascia il Pd: "Uscire dal partito sarà un bene per tutti. Anche per Conte"". rep.repubblica.it. 16 September 2019.
- ^ Politica, Redazione (17 September 2019). "Renzi: "Il nome della nuova sfida che stiamo per lanciare sarà Italia viva"". Corriere della Sera. Archived from the original on 24 September 2019. Retrieved 2 October 2019.
- ^ "Matteo Renzi lascia il Pd e fonda nuovo partito: telefona a Conte e annuncia l'addio al Pd, Le ragioni della svolta in una intervista a Repubblica". Repubblica.it. 16 September 2019. Archived from the original on 2 October 2019. Retrieved 2 October 2019.
- ^ "L'iniziativa. Renzi saluta il Pd e lancia "Italia viva". "Siamo 40 in Parlamento"". www.avvenire.it. 17 September 2019. Archived from the original on 2 October 2019. Retrieved 2 October 2019.
- ^ A un passo dalla crisi di governo: Renzi pronto a ritirare le ministre. Ecco gli scenari possibili, Open Online
- ^ Italian government totters as Conte, Renzi divide deepens, Reuters
- ^ Governo, Conte sfida Renzi: 'Se si sfila andiamo in aula. Sul Recovery non va bene: dobbiamo correre', la Repubblica
- ^ Meredith, Sam; Amaro, Silvia (13 January 2021). "Italy's government in crisis after former PM pulls support for ruling coalition". CNBC.com. CNBC. CNBC International. Retrieved 13 January 2021.
- ^ Matteo Renzi annuncia dimissioni ministre IV e attacca il governo, ANSA
- ^ La crisi di governo, Conte in Cdm: "Grave responsabilità Iv, danno a Paese". Zingaretti: "Crisi con 500 morti, da Iv atto gravissimo contro l'Italia", la Repubblica
- ^ Crisi di governo, Zingaretti: «Un atto gravissimo contro l'Italia». Salvini e Meloni: ora elezioni, Corriere della Sera
- ^ Crisi, il governo fa quadrato intorno a Conte. Franceschini: “Un attacco a tutti noi”. Speranza: “Avanti al suo fianco”. Fraccaro: “Inconcepibile”, Il Fatto Quotidiano
- ^ "Di Maio: "Da Renzi gesto irresponsabile, strade divise ora"". lastampa.it (in Italian). 14 January 2021. Retrieved 14 January 2021.
- ^ In questi mesi Giuseppe Conte ha servito il Paese con disciplina ed onore. Avanti al suo fianco, Roberto Speranza – Twitter
- ^ Il Pd e il Movimento Cinque Stelle vogliono andare avanti con Conte, Fanpage
- ^ "Giorgia Meloni e Matteo Salvini: "Elezioni subito". La leader Fdi: "Governo allo sfascio"". www.ilmessaggero.it (in Italian). 13 January 2021. Retrieved 14 January 2021.
- ^ "Conte cerca il voto in Aula. Ora è caccia ai 'costruttori'. Fronda nel M5s - Politica". Agenzia ANSA (in Italian). 14 January 2021. Retrieved 25 January 2021.
- ^ "Italy PM Conte comfortably wins lower house confidence vote". Reuters. 18 January 2021. Retrieved 18 January 2021.
- ^ Crisi di governo, via libera della Camera alla fiducia a Conte con 321 voti. Il premier: "Strappo con Iv incancellabile". Polverini vota sì e lascia Forza Italia, la Repubblica
- ^ "Italian PM Giuseppe Conte's government survives Senate confidence vote". euronews. 19 January 2021. Retrieved 19 January 2021.
- ^ Crisi di governo, sì del Senato alla fiducia con 156 voti. Ma scoppia il caso Ciampolillo. Sì dei forzisti Rossi e Causin. Meloni e Salvini: "Ci rivolgeremo al Colle", la Repubblica
- ^ Il Senato vota la fiducia a Conte: il Governo ha la maggioranza relativa con 156 sì, Fanpage
- ^ Legorano, Giovanni (25 January 2021). "Italian Prime Minister Resigns Amid Struggle Over How to Revive Economy From Covid-19". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 25 January 2021.
- ^ Crisi di governo, Conte si dimette: "Grazie a ogni singolo ministro". Alle 12 sale al Quirinale e spera nel 'Ter'. La regia passa a Mattarella, la Repubblica
- ^ Italy's Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte to resign, BBC
- ^ Al Senato nasce il gruppo dei responsabili: si chiama "Europeisti", TGCOM 24
- ^ Al via le consultazioni, Mattarella saluta i giornalisti, ANSA
- ^ Governo, Causin (Europeisti): “Conte è elemento di attrazione, non escludiamo un partito. Italia Viva? Fa la schifiltosa ma è nata come noi”, Il Fatto Quotidiano
- ^ Governo: secondo giorno di consultazioni. Renzi: 'Dopo i veti ci dicano se ci vogliono', ANSA
- ^ Consultazioni, Zingaretti: "Pd sostiene incarico a Conte, è punto di sintesi", la Repubblica
- ^ "Mattarella: "Adotterò un'iniziativa immediata". E convoca il presidente Fico per un mandato esplorativo". lastampa.it (in Italian). 29 January 2021. Retrieved 29 January 2021.
- ^ Centrodestra a Mattarella: incarico esplorativo al presidente Casellati, TgCom 24
- ^ Crimi “Pronti a confronto anche con Italia Viva, ma serve lealtà”, Il Tempo
- ^ Governo, alleanza con Renzi? Di Battista ai M5S: «Arrivederci e grazie», Corriere della Sera
- ^ Mattarella: “Possibile conferma della maggioranza attuale, va verificata”. Fico convocato al Quirinale, Il Fatto Quotidiano
- ^ "La vecchia maggioranza non si è messa d'accordo" (in Italian). Il Post. 2 February 2021. Retrieved 2 February 2021.
- ^ "Ex-ECB chief Mario Draghi asked to form Italy's next government". euronews. 3 February 2021. Retrieved 3 February 2021.
- ^ "Mattarella sceglie un governo del presidente e convoca Mario Draghi: "Voto non opportuno con l'emergenza, serve pienezza delle funzioni"" (in Italian). Il Fatto Quotidiano. 2 February 2021. Retrieved 2 February 2021.
- ^ Crisi governo, Draghi accetta l'incarico: "Vincere pandemia e rilanciare il Paese"., Sky Tg24
- ^ Governo, Draghi incaricato. Colloquio di un'ora con Conte. Crimi: 'Ipotesi voto Rousseau non da trascurare', ANSA
- ^ Giuseppe Conte scende in campo. E si autodichiara federatore, Huffington Post
- ^ "Berlusconi e Salvini: "Sostegno a Draghi con responsabilità e senza veti"". ilGiornale.it (in Italian). 10 February 2021. Retrieved 11 February 2021.
- ^ Meloni attacca Salvini: "Non voterò la fiducia a Draghi, a lui Pd e la Boldrini vanno bene?", Internazionale
- ^ "Zingaretti: "Unità contro chi vuole destabilizzare il Pd. Ora Costituente per riforme in Parlamento"". la Repubblica (in Italian). 11 February 2021. Retrieved 11 February 2021.
- ^ "Dal voto Cinquestelle via libera al governo Draghi con il 59,3%. Di Maio: "Il movimento prende la via europea". Fico: "Niente salti ne buio"". lastampa.it (in Italian). 11 February 2021. Retrieved 11 February 2021.
- ^ Di Battista: "Lascio il M5s, non accetto un governo con questi partiti". Il Movimento a rischio scissione (in Italian)
- ^ "Governo: Draghi accetta l'incarico, presenta lista ministri". ANSA (in Italian). 12 February 2021. Retrieved 12 February 2021.
- ^ Governo, ok del Senato alla fiducia a Draghi con 262 sì. "Grazie per la stima, andrà validata dai fatti". Nel M5S 15 votano contro, la Repubblica
- ^ Draghi, ok al Senato senza record: oggi tocca alla Camera. Strappo M5S, Qui Finanza
- ^ Forgnone, Valeria; Mari, Laura (18 February 2021). "Governo, ok della Camera alla fiducia con 535 sì, 56 no e 5 astenuti. Voto contrario di un leghista che passa a Fdi. Dissenso leghista a quota 32. Draghi: "Lotta alla corruzione e alle mafie"". La Repubblica (in Italian). Retrieved 18 February 2021.