Argenteuil (Manet)
| Argenteuil | |
|---|---|
| Artist | Édouard Manet |
| Year | 1874 |
| Medium | Oil on Canvas |
| Dimensions | 148.5 cm x 114.5 cm |
| Location | Musée des Beaux-Arts de Tournai |
Argenteuil is an 1874 oil on canvas painting by Édouard Manet (1832-1883), first exhibited at the Paris Salon of 1875.[1][2] It is one of Manet's first works to qualify fully as an Impressionist work,[3] due to its naturalistic subject and its bold palette. The painting depicts a sailor and his companion sitting on a mooring dock surrounded by sailboats, the deep blue water of the Seine, and the town of Argenteuil on the far bank.[4]: 353 Argenteuil is "Manet’s Salon painting answer to Monet’s depictions of boating on the Seine"[1] with similar Impressionist subjects connecting the two colleagues.
Manet held the painting until his passing. After his death, however, Henri Van Cutsem purchased it from Manet's widow, Suzzane Manet. Van Cutsem eventually bequeathed his collection to the city of Tournai, Belgium where the painting currently resides in the Musée des beaux-arts.[5]
Context
[edit]From 1872 onwards, Manet's themes and brighter palette echoed those of Claude Monet and Auguste Renoir.[6] He spent the summer of 1874 in Gennevilliers and took the chance to visit his friend Monet, who had lived at Argenteuil since 1873. The surrounding villages beside the Seine were then full of Impressionist painters - as well as Manet and Monet, Renoir frequently travelled there and Gustave Caillebotte was based at Petit-Gennevilliers.[3] In addition to Argenteuil which is viewed as "Manet’s Salon painting answer to Monet’s depictions of boating on the Seine"[1], Manet also produced The Monet Family in their Garden (1874, New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art) and Claude Monet Painting in his Studio (1874, Munich, Neue Pinakothek) in the open air that summer while in close contact with Monet.[7]
Despite close physical proximity to the other Impressionists, Manet managed to distinguish himself through Argenteuil. While the others elected to host the First Impressionist Exhibition to display their art in 1874, Manet decided to display Argenteuil at the more traditional Paris Salon, opening Impressionism to a broader audience.[4]: 353 Even then, Manet exercised "an indisputable influence on a certain group of artists"[2]: 360 and was viewed as the leader of the Impressionists, who were referred to as "la bande á Manet" before adopting the Impressionist title.[4]: 353
Analysis
[edit]The work depicts a boatman and his companion sitting on a mooring dock surrounded by sailboats, the deep blue water of the Seine, and the town of Argenteuil on the far bank. The man, who is posed by Manet's brother in law, Rodolph Leenhoff, has a semblance of intimacy to his face while the woman, whose identity is unknown, appears to be "remarkably inexpressive" which Cachin attributes to the struggles of posing for Manet.[4]: 353 The composition is one of a system of verticals made up of the mast, the woman, and the factory chimney and horizontals made up of the parapet, rolled parasol held by the man, and the bank.[4]: 354 Manet also elects to include subtle details of color such as the white standing out on the woman's hat, the flowers held by the woman, and the red band on the man's head.[4]: 355 In Argenteuil, Cahin says, Manet masterfully displays "the lively, dazzling style" of the Impressionists while remaining "deliberate, composed."[4]: 355
Carol Armstrong elaborates on the relationship between the man and woman describing it as an "anecdotal meeting of the sexes".[1] She suggests that the encounter is sexual in nature judging from the line of the man's gaze and the positioning of his cane.[1] Furthermore, she notices paired alternatives in the man and woman as presented by the "front/profile, vertical/horizontal, formal/casual, artificial/natural, fashioned/spontaneous, feminine/masculine."[1] She believes that between these pairs, the painting leans toward those which fall "under the sign of the feminine."[1] Finally, Armstrong argues that Argenteuil, while feminine, faces its masculine counterpart in Manet's painting, Boating. She suggests that Boating, while containing the same man and woman, "reverses many of the oppositions of Argenteuil...the woman is seen in profile and the man from the front, her hat is lumpen...while his is stiff-brimmed and more precisely painted."[1]
T.J. Clark, when analyzing Argenteuil, focuses on Manet's combined elements of the middle class, the countryside, and industry.[8]: 164 He describes "the great, flat clarity of form" of Argenteuil with the elements coexisting through calculated touch and brushstrokes.[8]: 164 In particular, Clark emphasizes the flatness of the work with the woman's hat providing the strongest example. He describes it as "a black straw oval" with the white tulle acting as a metaphor to "put in doubt the picture's already fragile space" thus lapping "like a wave against the far white wall."[8]: 165 Furthermore, Clark notes the illusions of the reflection of the chimney on the water which is actually caused by ropes hanging or other factors that Manet includes in his work.[8]: 166 Clark describes them as a "kind of joke" about false equivalence and things that seem to connect but in fact, do not.[8]: 166 Finally, Clark connects the landscape in the background with the figures. He states that the "figures and the landscape do not quite belong together" in the sense that it does not appear natural.[8]: 172 Clark says that Argenteuil "was the look of a new form of life - a placid form, a modest form, but one with a claim to pleasure" enticing the viewer to observe the painting in a new light.[8]: 172–173
Critical reaction
[edit]When Argenteuil was first displayed at the Salon, it received a fair amount of criticism with a consistent focus on the color of the water.[9] Maurice Chaumelin, for instance, wrote in 1877 in Le Bien Public, "[Manet] shows us a butcher's boy, with ruddy arms and pug nose, out boating on a river of indigo...decked out in horrible finery, and looking horribly sullen."[8]: 168 Rousseau describes the work as "Marmalade from Argenteuil spread on an indigo river. The master returns as a twentieth-year student."[4]: 355 Furthermore, Gaillardon writes, "It is all too obvious that Canontiers d'Argenteuil is a disaster."[4]: 355
A few critics came to Manet's defense, however. Chesneau counters the complaint about the color of the water saying, "[Manet] paints water blue. That is the great complaint. However, if the water is blue on certain days...must he paint it the traditional green color of water?...They hiss, I applaud."[4]: 355 Additionally, Castagnary recognized Argenteuil's merits writing, "What Manet paints is contemporary life."[4]: 355
Gallery
[edit]-
-
The Monet Family in their Garden, 1874, New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art -
Banks of the Seine at Argenteuil, 1874, Courtauld Gallery
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b c d e f g h Armstrong, Carol M.; Manet, Edouard (2002). Manet Manette. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-09658-3.
- ^ a b Rewald, John (1961). The History of Impressionism. New York: Museum of Modern Art.
- ^ a b (in Spanish) Christa von Lengerke, Los maestros de la pintura occidental, Taschen, 2005 (ISBN 3-8228-4744-5), Del Impresionismo al Art Nouveau, p. 492.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Manet, Edouard; Cachin, Françoise; Melot, Michel; Moffett, Charles S.; Wilson-Bareau, Juliet (1983). Manet, 1832-1883: Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, Paris, April 22-August 8, 1983, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, September 10-November 27, 1983. Galeries nationales du Grand Palais (France), Metropolitan Museum of Art (New York, N.Y.). New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art : Abrams. ISBN 978-0-87099-359-6.
- ^ "Édouard Manet - Argenteuil". Musée des Beaux-Arts de Tournai (in French). Retrieved 2024-11-22.
- ^ (in Spanish) P. F. R. Carrassat, Maestros de la pintura, Spes Editorial, 2005 (ISBN 84-8332-597-7), p. 218
- ^ (in French) James H. Rubin (trad. Jeanne Bouniort), Manet : Initiale M, l’œil, une main, Paris, Flammarion, 2011, 416 p. (ISBN 9782081256736), p. 292-298
- ^ a b c d e f g h Clark, T.J. (1999). The Painting of Modern Life: Paris in the Art of Manet and His Followers (Revised ed.). Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-00903-1.
- ^ Manet, Édouard; Dolan, Therese, eds. (2012). Perspectives on Manet. Farnham, Surrey ; Burlington, VT: Ashgate. ISBN 978-1-4094-2074-3. OCLC 705568311.
Bibliography
[edit]- (in Italian) L. Venturi, La via dell'impressionismo : da Manet a Cézanne, G. Einaudi, 1970.
- (in French) Émile Zola, Mon salon : Manet. Écrits sur l'art, Garnier-Flammarion, 1970.
- (in French) J. Wilson-Bareau, « L'année impressionniste de Manet : Argenteuil et Venise en 1874 », Revue de l'Art, 1989.
- (in French) P. Bonafoux, De Manet à Caillebotte : les impressionnistes à Gennevilliers, Éditions Plume, 1993.
External links
[edit]- "Musée des beaux-arts de Tournai". Archived from the original on 2011-02-03. Retrieved 2019-05-22.